As the United States Congress began its 113th session, 72 freshman members arrived on Capitol Hill to represent their congressional districts for the first time. It would be universally heralded as the most diverse freshman class in history, containing four new African Americans, 10 new Latinos, five new Asian Americans, 24 new women, the first two Hindus, the first Buddhist, the first non-theist to openly acknowledge her belief prior to getting elected, and four new LGBT members, including the first openly bisexual congresswomen and the first openly gay congressman of color. But for all their diversity, each of them had at least one thing in common: none of them had ever been a member of Congress before. How do freshman policy-makers legislate? What unique challenges do they face? What accounts for variations in their legislative activity?
While there are countless ways to conceptualize a congressperson's “legislative activity”—including speeches given on the floor, amendments offered in committee, press release hits, communications with the executive branch, coordination efforts with local officials, coalition-building within the chamber, committee hearing attendance, caucus organizing, appearances on Sunday morning talk shows, and a host of other activities—I focus here on bill sponsorships and cosponsorships. For all of their activities, producing legislation is something all legislators are expected to do.
With only six months of the session behind them, it is already clear that some freshman members have gotten into the swing of things much more quickly than others. The number of bills introduced so far by any single member ranges from 0 to 13, with a mean of 2 bills and a standard deviation of 3.5. The number of acquired cosponsorships this session by any single member ranges from 0 to 455, with a mean of 36 and a standard deviation of 95. What accounts for this variation? While a satisfactory answer to this question would require a systematic multivariate study of every freshman office, my time as a legislative fellow in the office of Matt Cartwright afforded me some clues. In short, I learned that both the quantity and quality of legislative activity in a freshman office can be largely explained by the top staffers' amount of previous congressional experience.
Like many other new members of the 113th Congress, Matt Cartwright had absolutely no prior political experience before arriving to Washington. The ten-term incumbent he defeated in the primary alleged that this lack of experience would render him an ineffectual policy-maker, and the Luzern County Democrat's Chairwoman summed up their endorsement of Holden over Cartwright in a single word: “experience.” For many voters in Pennsylvania's 17th district, the start-up costs of electing a new candidate—even a candidate more ideologically in tune with their districts—were simply too high.
But Cartwright won the election, and has, at least where producing legislation is concerned, proven much more active than his colleagues. At the time of this writing, he has produced more legislation and garnered more intra-chamber support for his bills than any other freshman in the House of Representatives. Figures 1 and 2 illustrate just how much more active he is on these dimensions than his colleagues: he has introduced four times the number of bills as the median freshman and acquired 10 times more cosponsors.
Figure 1
Figure 2
Staffing Quickly
The reason for these numbers can largely be traced back to a decision he made before the session even began: to avoid the very common practice of filling his top staff positions with campaign loyalists, and instead hiring a chief of staff (CS) and legislative director (LD) with more than three decades of combined congressional experience. A few anecdotes illustrate just how important this can be for a freshman congressperson's legislative productivity.
First, while many other offices took more than two months to completely fill their legislative staff positions, Congressman Cartwright accomplished this same task almost immediately. One reason he could do this involved the CS's and LD's familiarity with talented staffers in other offices who were now (post election) looking for a new home. Another reason had to do with their experience working with various congressional fellowship programs on the Hill. While some offices are not even aware that such fellowship programs exist—much less that they offer talented, hard-working, PhD-holding, free labor—Cartwright's LD already knew who to contact and when to contact them. (In fact, my hiring was largely the result of his successful experiences working alongside fellows in Congressman Russ Carnahan's office.) As a result of their previous congressional experience, the CS and LD could quickly build Cartwright's legislative staff in a way that enabled the congressman to hit the ground running as soon as the session began.
Setting Goals
After becoming one of the first fully staffed freshman offices in Congress, Cartwright's LD told us that he wanted our office to produce more legislation and secure more support for that legislation than any other freshman in the House of Representatives. To this end, he decided that we would strive to introduce one bill per week, every Thursday. Having spent many years on the Hill, he knew that this goal was so ambitious that no other freshman office would even come close to meeting it. As Figures 1 and 2 illustrate, he has proven correct.
Moreover, the rhythm fostered by this one-bill-per-Thursday policy tremendously increased the office's efficiency. We always knew exactly when to reach out to the committees of jurisdiction, interest group contacts, and members of relevant caucuses. We knew exactly when to begin writing and sending “Dear-Colleagues” to other members who might be interested in cosponsoring our bill, when to draft the actual bill text, and when to prepare the press release. Every Thursday, we would already have the official bill prepared to hand the congressman, along with the accompanying Statement of Constitutionality and formal list of original cosponsors to take to the cloakroom. And the congressman always knew to whip for original cosponsors on the House floor the preceding day. After two weeks or so of settling into this routine, the Cartwright office operated like clockwork while many other freshmen offices still struggled to find their feet.
Further contributing to Cartwright's sponsorship and cosponsorship count, the LD brought with him a precompiled list of what he called “orphaned” bills (bills introduced in a past Congress whose sponsor had either retired, died, or been voted out of office) and “single parent” bills (Senate bills without a House companion). The legislative staff could therefore sift through this list of bills as one might sift through a restaurant menu, choosing which ones we might like to propose to the congressman to introduce. Whenever we selected a bill from this list (which was about half of the time), it meant the vast majority of legwork for that week had already been accomplished by the bill's previous sponsor. Producing legislation is much easier when someone else has already drafted the bill text, acquired a list of cosponsors, and enlisted the formal support of several interest groups and caucuses. The time and resources this simple shortcut saved our office cannot be understated.
Optimizing Experience
These are only a few examples of how hiring a CS and LD with decades of congressional experience helped the Congressman produce more legislation and garner more intra-chamber support for that legislation than any other newly-elected member in the House of Representatives. While it is true that an experienced staff is a boon to any member of Congress, it is tremendously more important in the office of a freshman. There are at least four reasons for this:
Autonomy
One reason an experienced staff matters more in a freshman office is because it must operate more autonomously than the staff of an entrenched incumbent. A congressperson's most valuable resource is time, and freshman members of Congress have less of it than anyone. Because newly elected members must spend much of their time campaigning in their districts, fund-raising on the phone, and otherwise settling into their new chaotic lifestyle, they are incentivized to hand more of the legislative reigns over to their staff if they want a legislatively productive first term.
Connections
Second, experienced staffers have acquired connections in other congressional offices, on committee staff, and in interest groups. While this is important in any congressional office, it is much more important in an office where the legislator is unfamiliar with her 439 colleagues. Having friends on Capitol Hill can lead to support from across the aisle, the acquisition of cosponsors, endorsements from interest groups, and more favorable consideration in committee. It is often said that business cards are the currency on Capitol Hill, and experienced staffers have simply had longer to acquire them.
Path-Dependence
Third, as is the case in any professional work environment, an office's first occupants set the office's tone and, more concretely, establish practices and routines that outlive their originators. With the exception of a congressional office's first staff, individuals typically quit and are hired one at a time. This means that the routines established by an office's first staff remain more or less stable even as staffers come and go.
Procedural Knowledge
Fourth, experienced legislative staffers understand the nuts and bolts of policy-making in Washington. This is important because even members of Congress with decades of law experience will struggle to understand floor procedure and other technical features of drafting legislation when they first arrive. An LD who knows what it means, for example, to “move to strike the last word,” to “vote against ordering the previous question,” and for the House to “resolve itself into the Committee of the Whole,” can help the member navigate this confusing arena of legislative procedure instead of letting more seasoned members rule the floor.
Conclusion
For these reasons and more, hiring a CS and LD with Hill experience is much more important in a freshman office than it is in that of a more senior congressperson. Newly elected members of Congress who pay close attention to the composition of their staff, and especially to who they choose to fill these top two positions, will likely set the stage for a more legislatively productive first term (which is important, because anyone's first term may also be their last).
Acknowledgments
I would like to thank John Brehm, J. Mark Hansen, and William Howell for their guidance, and Jeffrey Biggs, Matt Cartwright, Jeremy Marcus, Hunter Ridgway, and Mae Stevens for showing me how the sausage is made.
NOTES
1. He also personally interviewed everyone who worked for him, all the way down to the interns. No staffer I have spoken to (and by now I have spoken to many) has ever heard of another member of Congress do this.
2. Introducing one bill per week is much more difficult for a freshman than a senior. While senior members are afforded the luxury of introducing bills they sponsored in previous sessions, freshmen have no legislative history and so must start from scratch.
