This book belongs to a long lineage of texts that compare ‘race’ in Brazil and the United States. It is almost as if each ‘racial formation’ constituted the other, as it were, as the contrasts throw into relief the peculiarities of one and the other. Oracy Nogueira's classic essay of 1954 ‘Preconceito Racial de Marca e Preconceito Racial de Origem’ (Nogueira, 1991[1954]),Footnote 1 which, curiously enough Daniel does not cite, discusses the consequences of two distinct systems of classification; by appearance (marca) in Brazil and by descent (origem) in the USA. Thus, while the United States was understood to be locked into a bipolar taxonomy with people being classified according to supposed genealogy (the ‘one drop rule’ allocated all those with at least one real or supposed African ancestor into the category of ‘black’), Brazil was described as having a complex taxonomy of many terms with individuals being classified into them according to their appearances. In the USA, individuals who looked white could ‘pass’ but this was regarded as perilous by the guardians of white supremacy and traitorous by those who remained loyal to a black identity. In Brazil, on the other hand, everything worked the other way round. The whiter you looked the whiter you were, and so much the better! while black ancestry in the US conveyed permanent stigma, in Brazil it came to be believed that white ‘blood’ whitened. And while racial segregation, tension and conflict characterised the USA, Brazil boasted that ‘racial democracy’ reigned supreme. With the end of legal segregation in the USA in the 1960s and the return of democratic government in Brazil in the 1980s, things began to change. A small but articulate black movement in Brazil challenged the ideology of racial democracy, claiming that it was merely a sophisticated mechanism for the persistence of racial domination. By now there are many activists and others who claim that Brazil's ‘polite’ racism is in fact worse than more overt expressions held to characterise the USA.
The significant difference, perhaps, between Daniel's book and its predecessors is that it deals not only with that which is but that which might be. Thus, although the past is part of his focus of analysis book, his greatest interest centres on more recent changes and their possible consequences in both countries: in particular the rise of a consistent challenge to the one drop rule in the USA and a tendency for Brazil to move away from its complex and situational ‘racial’ taxonomy to a bipolar system rather like that which the author would like to see the end of in the USA. According to Daniel, the USA is moving away from the binary system of the one drop rule to a ternary one, while at the same time the pressure mounts in Brazil to move away from a ‘ternary’ racial formation (blacks, browns and whites) to a binary one (blacks and whites only). The author's documentation of the way the one drop rule worked and still works with splendid passages on ‘passing’, and his description of the various organisations which have fought against the one drop rule leading to the incorporation of ‘multiraciality’ made officially possible in the 2000 census, make rich and rewarding reading. His account of the history of the Brazilian ‘racial formation’ and recent changes is less well documented. Brazilian texts are few and far between, which may account for the fact that is a somewhat one-sided account; that of dominant Brazilian sociology and the black activists. The system that Oracy Nogueira described is interpreted, in a highly racialised frame, as nothing more than a carefully wrought strategy of racial domination, which, thanks to the activists and their allies in the US foundations is now under severe attack. Furthermore, I am not sure whether it is correct to describe Brazilian racial formation as ‘ternary’. While it is true that the censuses have always used three categories, daily life is much more confused. Although some believe that Brazil is made up simply of blacks and whites, others (perhaps still the majority) continue to imagine that they are positioned in some place along a complex three dimensional continuum with ancestral Amerindians, Africans and Europeans at the three apices. Popular interpretations of ‘racial’ status are strikingly homologous to Mendelian genetics. But the author is quite right when he observes that the recent introduction of affirmative action by the State does in fact establish a legalised dichotomous system of ‘racial’ classification. If the author had had greater access to recent Brazilian publications he would have discovered that this is a disputed position even among people who describe themselves as ‘progressive’. Many Brazilians of diverse colours and political persuasions are highly critical of the move to bipolarity, even if, to the contrary of the US proponents of multiraciality, they prefer the more radical stance of questioning the legalised concept of race altogether.
If the move to ‘multiraciality’ in the USA is seen as positive (the author traces the origins of his puzzlement at the one drop rule from his early childhood and has subsequently worked for pro-multiraciality organisations), why is he so content to see the introduction of a binary ‘racial formation’ in Brazil? And if one society seems to be moving away from a binary taxonomy to a ternary one, while the other moves from a ternary one to a binary one, the answer to the question posed by the subtitle of the book, ‘converging paths?’ is surely ‘no’. By the author's own account, each of the two societies is moving in the opposite direction.
Neither of these paths rejects ‘race’ as a necessary concept for political action. One could argue that changes in Brazil institute ‘race’ as a legal/political category, while the move to multiraciality in the USA merely alters the way individuals and groups define themselves in relation to ‘races’, at least for the census which now allows people to fill in more than one ‘racial’ box.
The author betrays his own doubts over continued racialisation towards the end of his book, when he states that ‘part of the struggle for achieving fully participatory racial democracies involves deconstructing the very racial categories and identities inherited from colonialism that have long served as the basis of racism and racial hierarchy in Brazil and the United States.’ But then he falls back to his prior position, endorsing ‘social engineering, government authority and official attention to racial behavior.’ So, like almost everything written about ‘race’, this book is clearly programmatic and the solutions proposed built on the persistent premise that it is possible to combat racism without questioning race as concept and criterion for political action. Whether you agree or not with the author's prescriptions, the book brings new light to new and old problems and is a more than useful contribution to the ongoing comparison of Brazil and the USA.
