There are several reasons why James Joseph Sylvester makes an excellent choice for a biography. He was one of the few Jewish mathematicians in the nineteenth century, although there were a number in Germany, and one of the few pure mathematicians in Britain, a country much more attuned to the applications of mathematics when it got round to appreciating the subject at all. He also became, most interestingly, one of the few successful mathematicians in the United States.
Sylvester was born in 1814, which meant that although he studied at Cambridge, and graduated second Wrangler in 1837, he was unable to take a degree because his religion debarred him from affirming the Thirty-Nine Articles of the Church of England. Not that there was automatically a job for him to take up, because Cambridge was full of Fellows in permanent positions with little to do and new posts were rare. So Sylvester took himself to Virginia, where he fell foul of the Southern cult of honour and masculinity, and returned to London to become an actuary. There he did well; he was prominently involved with the newly founded Institute of Actuaries, which pushed successfully to make actuarial work a profession. There also he met up with the man who became his lifelong friend and mathematical companion, Arthur Cayley (and here one can note that, happily, Johns Hopkins University Press have almost simultaneously published Tony Crilly's fine biography of Cayley, Arthur Cayley: Mathematician Laureate of the Victorian Age, Baltimore, 2006).
Cayley survived as a lawyer, and a good one too, until a professorship was created for him back in Cambridge in 1879. Sylvester was not so lucky, but he worked hard, published energetically, availed himself of what contacts he had in the increasingly emancipated world of English Jews, and finally landed a professorship at the Royal Military Academy at Woolwich in 1855. It was never to be what he wanted. The Army expected a hard-working drudge with some capacity for keeping order; Sylvester expected a light teaching load and ample opportunity to conduct research. They cohabited like the partners in a marriage no one was quite willing to end until a reform of the Army's teaching some years after the disaster of the Crimea led to Sylvester's dismissal on grounds of age, and only a successful appeal to the House of Lord's secured him his pension. For the first time in his life, Sylvester now had some degree of security, and his life took a marked turn for the better.
Daniel Coit Gilman, president of Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, was looking for an inspiring mathematician and was persuaded that Sylvester could be his man. The university opened its doors in 1876, and once more Sylvester sailed for the United States, this time for glory (or such as a mathematician may hope for). He proved to be an inspiring supervisor at the research level, and several students found that working alongside him, or even at times in competition with him, gave them a good start at becoming mathematicians themselves. Among them was Christine Ladd, whom Sylvester persuaded the university to let attend his lectures, even though she was not allowed to claim her Ph.D. until 1926, forty-three years after her dissertation was written. Sylvester also settled in well to the university community and established the first journal in America devoted exclusively to mathematics, the American Journal of Mathematics, which exists to this day.
It could not last. Sylvester and Johns Hopkins eventually separated and he returned to England. Now the opportunity came up for him to be the professor of mathematics at Oxford, but he was unable to repeat his successes there, handicapped less by his advancing age than by the university's lack of interest in research mathematics.
This well-written, thoroughly researched biography will become the definitive study of Sylvester. It also says much about the scientific life and times as they were experienced by this energetic and gifted man who managed to be both an outsider and an insider in British society. Self-confident, even vain at times, prickly and also charming, Sylvester is a fascinating figure. What emerges as stealthily in this book as it must have done in his life is that his most significant achievement was not so much his work as his example.
Sylvester's mathematical interests were largely in algebra, number theory and combinatorial questions, which were the focus of his work in Baltimore. He was not much interested in geometry, and hoped to see Euclid's Elements buried in favour of more creative approaches, and he did not work in mathematical analysis, the central subject in all of nineteenth-century mathematics. Instead, he and Cayley worked to create a new, modern branch of pure mathematics: invariant theory. A conic section has an ‘invariant’, which is not altered when the coordinates, and therefore the equation of the curve, are changed, and which determines if a conic section is an ellipse, a parabola or a hyperbola. Cayley and Sylvester sought to discover what happens to more general equations involving more variables, and variables raised to higher powers. Vast amounts of calculation revealed hints. In a number of settings further invariants were discovered, and it was noticed that often they are related by further equations. But as Cayley and Sylvester explored this new terrain their conjectures about what might happen, and even their observations about what they had discovered, were naive. French, Italian and especially German mathematicians took up the subject with better notation, more sophisticated ideas and more rigour, and Cayley and Sylvester were never able to match Continental discoveries with their home-grown methods, despite repeated attempts.
Was this a defeat for the British team? In important ways, no. Cayley and Sylvester opened up a new subject in mathematics and established its importance. They established pure mathematics as a subject in Britain and earned a well-merited international reputation for it. By the time they died it was no longer possible for an underfunded and yet self-indulgent university system in Britain to continue to ignore the remarkable growth of pure mathematics in Continental Europe.
