Josephine Machon concedes, in the preface to Immersive Theatres, that she has set herself a formidable challenge in attempting to offer a nuanced, complex meditation on what defines immersive theatre practice, while acknowledging that immersive theatre is impossible to define as a performative genre “with fixed and determinate codes and conventions, because it is not one” (xvi; italics hers). Admitting that her study “embraces the fuzziness around the edges in engaging in the debate about what immersive theatre is” (xvii), Machon offers a clearly articulated, wide-ranging survey of the history, theories, and practices of immersive theatre in Great Britain from the 1980s to the present. Although immersive theatre cannot and arguably should not be reduced to a series of set definitions and shared performance constraints, Machon's interdisciplinary approach—drawing upon game theory, anthropology, architecture, performance studies, philosophy, visual art, and her own work on (syn)aesthetics—proposes a critical discourse by which we might better understand and study this vibrant, contemporary theatre practice.
Immersive Theatres is organized into two parts. The first charts the historical development and theoretical foundations of immersive theatre, identifying potential (and varied) origins of current practice, and theorizing the codes and conventions applicable and consistent across a broad range of productions and performances. The theories introduced and explained in Part I are illustrated through discussions of performance and production in Part II, which is a valuable collection of original interviews with leading directors, designers, and performers whose work consistently engages audience members in immersive practice: Michael Morris (Artangel), Felix Barrett (Punchdrunk), Bruce Gladwin (Back to Back Theatre), Christer Lundahl and Martina Seitl (Lundahl & Seitl), Silvia Mercuriali, Tassos Stevens (Coney), Samantha Holdsworth (Nimble Fish), Pete Higgin (Punchdrunk Enrichment), Louise Ann Wilson, Bill Mitchell and Sue Hill (WildWorks), Adrian Howells, and Tristan Sharps (dreamthinkspeak). Perhaps inspired by the narrative freedom immersive theatre often offers its audience members, Machon invites her reader to take any number of approaches to the book, whether reading it from start to finish, beginning with the interviews and then turning to the considerations of theory and practice, or jumping around from theory to practice and back again.
The book begins with an introduction in which Machon provides a condensed history, or “immersive inheritance” of immersive theatre, choosing not to “give an exhaustive account of relevant practices and practitioners” but rather “show[] an artistic trajectory and identif[y] possible origins of current immersive practice” (28–9). Though this is a valid approach, I found this “artistic trajectory” to be at times contradictory and a bit too abbreviated. Machon locates immersive theatre's beginnings with the modernist period (1905–59) but notes that interdisciplinary modernist practice arguably evolved from Wagner's Gesamtkunstwerk and early Romanticism. She then adds that the “fun, flux and furore [sic] that exists in immersive practices begins with Commedia dell'arte and European street theatre traditions” (29). This performative flux and fun informs much of early twentieth-century performance, from dadaism to midcentury happenings and installations, before Antonin Artaud emerges, according to Machon, as a principal innovator of what immersive theatre will become with his “total theatre,” influencing future theorists and practitioners like Richard Schechner, Julian Beck and Judith Malina, and Jerzy Grotowski, among others (30). I would have liked to have seen more time devoted to developing this historical line of inquiry, particularly because the artistic-trajectory approach inevitably tempts the reader to find other examples of sensually immersive theatre practices from other centuries, such as the symbolists and their experiments with smell, or the immersive staging of select medieval productions.
In Chapter 1, “Definitions and Details,” Machon uses a table to demonstrate the differences between traditional and immersive theatres in terms of approach and outcome. The chapter then expands on the terms and characteristics identified in the table, defining immersion and the immersive in performance terms by adapting theories from virtual art and game theory, particularly Gordon Calleja's description of immersion and presence in digital gaming. Chapter 2, “Features and Finer Details: A Scale of Immersivity,” considers how a potential audience member might gauge an immersive event by identifying central features of this theatrical form, namely: involvement of the audience, prioritization of the sensual world, and the significance of space and place to the design and story of the work. Chapter 3, “Immersive Perspectives,” presents a range of interdisciplinary theories to complicate notions of embodied presence in performance. In what I believe to be the strongest chapter, Machon presents her own work on (syn)aesthetics as a means to analyze sensual presence and reception in immersive theatre. Specifically, she considers the (syn)aesthetic nature of immersive practice, “in which intuition and instinct are central to the audience-participant's navigation and appreciation of the work” (105).
Of particular interest to scholars of immersive theatre are the lengthy interviews with leading practitioners in Part II. Taken as a group, these interviews offer exciting, contrapuntal conversations on the nature of live performance, the interdisciplinary nature of immersive practice, and the role of the individual audience member to the work. Although the artists often offer contradictory perspectives on immersive practice, they also echo one another, particularly when they offer their thoughts on why immersive theatre has become so popular. Repeatedly, artists note that people have a genuine desire for sentient human interaction, to make human contact in an age that is increasingly technologically driven. Although artists welcome this need, many of them spoke of the pressures they felt to surprise constantly their growing audiences with new experiences and ever more innovative and detailed designs. I especially enjoyed reading Felix Barrett's views on Punchdrunk's evolving dramaturgy but also appreciated hearing from other theatre artists with whose work I am less familiar.
Immersive Theatres will be useful for students, scholars, and practitioners of theatre and performance studies. Its innovative structure, interdisciplinary methodology, provocative questions, and valuable descriptions of productions will make it a welcome addition to the growing body of work on reception theory, immersive practice, as well as alternative theatre spaces and staging.
