Given the pace at which public policy and its associated government departments, initiatives and evaluations shift and change it can be hard to keep up to date in this fast moving world. With publication lead-in times, texts focusing on policy issues can often find themselves outdated even before they reach our desks. This aligned with the national focus of public policy can combine to make such works limited in their appeal and scope. On the whole, however, this edited collection which arises from reflections on the impact of the UK's Active Learning for Active Citizenship Home Office programme and a number of other related UK citizenship initiatives and policies manages to traverse this tricky ground admirably.
The editors introduce the text as a place within which debates around the definitions, perspectives, approaches and policy agendas that contextualise community-based active citizenship and citizenship education can be explored. To do this they draw upon the experiences of those involved in community-based citizenship education in the UK but set these ‘within the context of wider debates and exchanges internationally’ (p. 2). The text will therefore hold appeal not only for readers in the UK, but also for those working and studying beyond its shores. Active Learning for Active Citizenship additionally blends academic research and practitioner narratives well, engaging with the academic literature without becoming abstract from everyday experience. As a book that is not overly academic in its tone and approach, it should therefore be of interest and use to a practitioners and teachers alike.
Section 1: ‘Themes, Perspectives and Approaches’ begins this process by considering the issue of active citizenship from a range of perspectives. Chapter 1 introduces the policy background to the Active Learning for Active Citizenship (ALAC) initiative, closely followed in Chapter 2 by a useful account of the academic debates in the area by John Annette. Further chapters in this section uncover the development of citizenship education in the compulsory school sector in England and linkages between education for citizenship across compulsory and non-compulsory educational settings as well as adult community learning spaces.
Having set the scene, Section 2: ‘Reflections from Practice’ moves on to consider ALAC in practice, beginning with broad reflections on the outcomes of the ALAC programme (Chapters 6 and 7) before focusing on the outcomes of particular areas of work within this broader landscape (Chapters 8–14). This, the largest section of the text, will be of particular interest to those working to empower and support a wide range of individuals and groups (including often marginalised groups such a migrant workers and refugees) to become active citizens.
Underpinning the text is a clear message and vision. The editors argue passionately that citizenship is at the very heart of democracy and that active citizenship should therefore be founded on the key principles and values of social justice, equality and visible fairness. However, ALAC is seen not only to help to recharge our democracy through rectifying injustice and balances of power, but is additionally viewed as a factor which can contribute towards a growth in social solidarity and community cohesion. This is an ambitious vision, but from the evidence and discussion presented in the text, it is already being acted out in real and tangible ways across the UK.
This notwithstanding, the text reminds us that work is still needed in this area. Linking the reflections on practice from Section 2 back to the theoretical and policy debates introduced in Section 1, the final section of the text (Section 3: ‘The Wider Context’) highlights some key sticking points that should be addressed if active citizenship is to move forward. One such example is the need to connect the currently fragmented learning and citizenship policies and agendas in a meaningful way (rather than leaving it up to those working in schools and communities to do so). In the penultimate chapter, Rennie Johnstone additionally reminds us of the need to build social solidarities and community cohesion on a respect for difference and not on ideals of consensus, the nation state or the common good, which take insufficient account of diversity.
Finally, Marjorie Mayo draws the discussion to a close by highlighting the need for our developing understanding of active citizenship to encapsulate a range of dimensions: the local, the national and the global. Perhaps most salutary for those amongst us who teach adults – whether in the tertiary education sectors or in community-based adult learning spaces – is Mayo's reminder that, like any kind of learning, learning to become an active citizen and to gain understanding of the dimensions of citizenship can be both facilitated and supported. We all have a vital role to play in this process.
