In Race, Sports, and Education: Improving Opportunities and Outcomes for Black Male Students, John N. Singer trains a critical eye on college athletics and how historically White colleges and universities (HWCU) often fail Black male athletes. Singer critically examines the experience of Black males who play Division 1 football or basketball and explores more satisfactory and equitable ways HWCU could serve the needs of these athletes (p. 6). The guiding question is “What does college sport have to do with the education of Black male athletes?” (p. 149). Singer's work addresses this question using a variety of methods and embracing the voices of the athletes themselves. The result is a fascinating look into the promise and pitfalls Black male athletes face in their pursuit of education.
Chapter One focuses on the significance of studying Black male college athletes. In this chapter, Singer digs into his own intellectual background and the influences that shaped his interest in the topic. While acknowledging the struggles of other groups and recognizing that Black male athletes are not a monolithic group, he makes a persuasive argument as to why Black male athletes face unique struggles, including the history of systemic racism, erasure, and violence. This background means students are often recruited for athletics and may show up unprepared by their P-12 education, only to find themselves required to spend hours on activities outside of academics. As a result of a system that blends academics and capitalism, serving as a feeder into professional sport, college athletics (especially football and basketball) are built around Black male athletes, but do not serve their educational needs. The educational “opportunities” offered are far too often illusory and built on exploitation.
In the second chapter, Singer delves into case studies following three teammates, “Bobby,” “Marcus,” and “Mark,” who played key roles in a major college football program. This chapter blends evidence from a questionnaire, focus group, and interviews conducted while these athletes were in school in 2002 and follow-up interviews in 2018. Singer provides insight into the program these athletes were part of and gives background on each of the three athletes, illuminating the incentives that motivate these athletes and the choices they face. Singer's approach centering the voices of these athletes pays off, highlighting how they experience access discrimination, treatment discrimination, and how race impacts their experience of higher education as athletes. It is powerful to hear in the athlete's own words, how Black male athletes at prominent programs feel like “high-class slaves” (p. 65).
These athletes also have valuable insight into potential solutions. For example, “Bobby” emphasized the need for HWCU to recognize that they are dealing with primarily 18–22-year-old Black males who have been socialized to focus on sport, and respond with better educational mentors and financial support (p. 71). The choice to center athletes’ voices and look for solutions from them as stakeholders provides insights other methods cannot. Singer explores the tangled and paradoxical relationships between the Black male athlete and his HWCU, including disenfranchisement and empowerment; prominence and invisibility; and opportunity and exclusion.
In Chapter Three, Singer presents individual narrative vignettes to further explore the experience of the Black male athlete. Singer employs a variety of methods and sources to detail how varied the Black male athlete experience can be. These stories include athletes, administrators, and faculty, ranging from those keenly aware of structures built on the oppression they operate within, to those who have had their lives changed and saved by their experience as an athlete. This range highlights what is so tragic about current structures in college athletics—athletics can be a powerful tool of education, but they are often used to subvert true education for these athletes.
What these stories share in common is what makes Singer's book so important: they all encourage the reader to think seriously about athletics and education and to do that, to consider race. Regardless of their experience, race was a defining factor for all of those interviewed. The line between college athletics and the “real world” is also porous and these stories prompt readers to recognize that the experience of the Black male athlete is only one of the myriad experiences one can have that is necessarily conditioned by race. Singer also implores the reader to think seriously about education and conceive of education as much more than just going to school and graduating (p. 145).
Finally, in Chapter Four, Singer presents a framework for how macro-, meso-, and micro-level factors interact and shape these educational opportunities. These focus on structural racism, organizational power structures, culture, political systems, and more. What emerges is not a comprehensive or exclusive accounting of these complex processes, but real insight into this complexity. Singer also provides possible solutions and reforms to better serve the educational needs of Black male athletes (p. 165–175).
On the whole, Singer's work is an impressive accomplishment. He blends methods and fields, including critical race theory, sociology, sports management, and more. The book is useful for anyone interested in education, race, or athletics. Particularly striking is his analysis of athletics as a realm of potential. Throughout the book, athletics are a source of meaning, a force of empowerment, a structure to oppress, a mechanism of exclusion, or a source of community. Singer encourages the reader to examine how race shapes one's experience as a college male athlete. He highlights the need to move beyond capital development and into human development, valuing Black male athletes as humans first. Black male athletes drive major profit centers at many institutions (p. 3), but these institutions do not invest back into these athletes. This useful framework combined with his many practical reforms leaves the reader at once concerned about these systems and hopeful that they can be better designed. Because people made these systems, people can change them, and Singer connects social science to what is truly human about endeavors like athletics and education.
