The centenary of the start of the World War I has seen an upsurge of publications dealing with nearly every aspect of the conflict and covering many of the hitherto understudied regional dimensions of the war. The outpouring of scholarly and popular works has filled many of the remaining lacunae in our understanding of the impact of four years of war in the Middle East and North Africa. In A Land of Aching Hearts, Leila Tarazi Fawaz provides a magisterial account of the manifold ways in which exposure to, and participation in, the fighting shaped the lives of peoples and societies in the Arab world. Fawaz explores the strategies—both in desperation and creativity—through which ordinary people across the region adapted to political, economic, and social dislocation. The result is an enriching account of “the right mix of ingenuity and practicality [that] often meant the difference between success and failure, life and death” (p. 4).
In contradistinction to the “top-down” military and diplomatic history that has characterized much of the Anglophone writing about World War I in the Middle East, Fawaz adopts a “bottom-up” approach focused primarily on social and cultural history. She makes use of a wide variety of Arabic sources, ranging from contemporary documents to postwar memoirs and the subsequent portrayal of the conflict in works of fiction and in individual and collective memory. Such an approach, Fawaz argues, is vital because “the Great War was the turning point from a stable politics to a tumultuous future, and remains a dominant memory in the region even a century later” (p. 274). The many legacies of the war arose as the four years of fighting and its turbulent aftermath not only resulted in the redrawing of the political and economic landscape but also transformed the regional and international politics of the modern Middle East that emerged from the conflict.
A Land of Aching Hearts is organized around a series of themes such as “Living the Great War,” “Entrepreneurs and Profiteers,” “The Soldiering Experience,” and “Cooperation and Disaffection.” As these chapter titles imply, the war was as much an opportunity for a lucky few as it was a hardship for the majority of individuals caught up in the fighting. Fawaz gives a particularly evocative account of the devastation wreaked by the famine caused in part by the plague of locusts in the Levant that ravaged the area in 1915. Thus, one eyewitness reported how the density of the locust cloud was so great that “[m]illions upon millions of white wings filled the air like opaque snow and hid the sun,” while another recorded similarly how “the sun is almost veiled” (p. 95). In one of the few weaknesses of the book, Fawaz is curiously muted on the Armenians’ suffering, devoting just two paragraphs to the Armenian Genocide (pp. 100–101) compared with four pages on the Armenians’ role as merchants and businesspeople (pp. 140–44). This is a notable and puzzling omission.
Against the many hardships caused by economic dislocation and political upheaval, Fawaz also documents how resourceful local entrepreneurs—including agents and spies on all sides—were able to turn the difficult conditions to material advantage. Such opportunities arose as “the presence of large foreign armies combined with the vicissitudes of war to close some doors and open others” (p. 158). Tellingly, Fawaz notes that there was no shortage of potential agents willing to work for the British and the French in order to better make meager ends meet. As a result, it should come as no surprise that “the information they provided at times was really nothing spectacular but just common knowledge or that culled from the local rumor mills” (p. 146). Another figure who managed to turn the misfortune of war to his advantage was the future prime minister of Iraq, Jaʿfar al-ʿAskari, who changed sides during his detention at a prisoner of war camp in Egypt and subsequently recruited heavily for the Arab Revolt among fellow “Arab prisoners, officers, and enlisted men alike” (p. 185).
As the region became divided into a series of battlegrounds over which the multinational forces of four empires fought for the entire four years of World War I, it drew in hundreds of thousands of local participants, voluntarily or not, into combatant and support roles. The experience both of soldiering and, for many, leaving the confines of local community and traveling long distances for the first time, had a profound effect on perceived identities, with significant implications for the reformulation of political affiliation after the war ended as new ideologies emerged that transcended prewar notions of belonging and loyalty to local clans or tribes.
South Asians made up a large proportion of the combatants and noncombatants that propelled the (British-led) Mesopotamian and Egyptian Expeditionary Forces toward the capture of Baghdad and Jerusalem in March and December 1917. These cities’ capture went some way toward redressing the military defeats experienced in each campaign at Gaza and Kut respectively, and provided a much-needed political boost to David Lloyd George's new government in London. Recent scholarship has emphasized the vital role of Indian soldiers and laborers in literally carrying the British and imperial armies to victory. Fawaz devotes an entire chapter to examining how South Asians adapted to the Middle East and shines an intriguing light on the lesser-known experiences of thousands of Arabs taken prisoner by British forces and transported to internment camps in India for the duration of the war. These (and other) flows built upon the deeper historical patterns of settlement and exchange that for centuries past had connected India with the Middle East.
Fawaz has produced an excellent account packed with information that will provide enduring value to scholars, students, and the general public. Current policymakers would also do well to engage with the book's major themes as they grapple with a region in the renewed throes of upheaval. Indeed, Fawaz ends with a series of compelling observations regarding the unresolved nature of the “complex and lasting legacy” of the war in the Middle East as an outcome of how the victorious powers in 1919 carved up the region “in ways that ignored natural divisions in favor of artificial borders that still cause resentment or conflict” (p. 277). Fawaz suggests that the outcomes of the peace treaties meant that for many who survived the years of conflict “all the sacrifices were in vain” and “the peoples of the Middle East learned the hard way not to trust any ruler's promises” (p. 273). In addition, Fawaz identifies a parallel with the 2011 Arab Spring as she argues “[t]hings have come full circle since the Great War, which created a window of opportunity for a new participatory type of politics” (p. 273). It is to be hoped that officials and onlookers from the region and beyond absorb the rich pickings offered by Fawaz of the conflict that effectively created the modern Middle East but also laid the foundations of many of its subsequent fissures.
