Walter Holland has had a long and distinguished career in a heterogeneous field of work he calls health services research (HSR). Trained as a physician and scientist, with experience as a clinician as well, Holland was for years a major figure in the important London teaching hospital St. Thomas’, working in and then leading an unusual and diverse team of statistically minded social and medical scientists that took on a remarkable series of consequential research projects that, in a number of instances, influenced major health policy decisions in the UK National Health Services.
Holland’s initial aim for this book, he reports in the preface, was to describe all the health-oriented research commissioned, financed and published in the United Kingdom during the later half of the 20th century. Realizing that much of the commissioned research could not be found, reviewed and evaluated, Holland instead crafted a publication that is more like a collection of papers on various health research themes that had been important to his career, his professional aspirations and his policy influence as well as disappointments. Those topics range from reflections on his education and early career choices to the development of HSR in the United Kingdom (and a snapshot of such research in the United States). There are chapters providing detailed accounts of phases in the UK’s treatment of such research findings, and, above all perhaps, persistent attention to the never-ending tensions between ‘basic’ and ‘problem-led research’ on the one hand and politicians and health service researchers on the other.
The sequence of chapters does not quite follow a clear logical order, with ‘personal reflections’ about how Holland went from school to medical school and beyond arriving at Chapter 4. Those reflections are of biographical interest, but do not shape what Holland is most anxious to communicate; and that is the importance of HSR, the relatively more generous funding of it in the United States compared with the United Kingdom, and the very uncertain connection between research findings and policy decisions about the subjects investigated. What strikes the reader from the United States here is the sharp contrast between the more generous research funding in the United States and the failure of most of the research to shape the health and health care agenda of the United States in the decades after the Second World War. That is not a topic this book explores while providing a snapshot of HSR in the United States that Holland observed first hand on what was a sabbatical.
There is no question that the comparative commentary identifies sharp differences: in the United States more money spent on HSR, more emphasis on the costs of care and early studies of manpower and quality issues, and greater influence of organized medicine, foundations and private industry than in the United Kingdom (with a dominant role of public funding and greater emphasis on public health issues). Much of the explanation for these differences is institutional, arrangements of governing authority that are more centralized and hierarchical in the United Kingdom than in the United States. This is not a topic that Holland explores. His roster of useful social scientists in teams of HSR range from psychologists to economists and sociologists, but excludes political analysts. Indeed, one of the persistent reflections in Holland’s writing is the power of politics (and politicians) to determine the fate of HSR rather than the quality of the research itself. However, Holland, while complaining about the unavoidable ‘politics’ surrounding decision making, is not naïve, and his most arresting writing is his history of research funding in the NHS up to the early 1990s.
It is here that Holland’s personal history intersects nicely with the subject he cares about most: how was HSR research treated in Britain. In Chapters 3, 5 and 6, Holland discusses who did what to whom in funding and addressing health research as far as he could discover. He portrays prominent leaders of the NHS, the Medical Research Council and some independent advisory committees in shaping and reshaping the health research agenda. The setting up of eight HSR units in the 1970s, for example, is given special attention, most of which were attached to leading teaching hospitals. Holland was to become the leader of one such unit at St. Thomas’ and that experience shapes much of the rest of the volume. Throughout this discussion, crucial tensions appear and reappear between the short time horizons of many, perhaps most, political leaders and the much longer time horizons of epidemiological studies, for example; or the tension between advocates of basic and applied research that parallel the strain between the independent researcher critical of government policy and the yearning of serious researchers to have their useful findings translated into practice.
Throughout this volume there is a thread of argument that Holland wants to substantiate, partly through repetition. The claim is that the most useful research on health services should be multi-disciplinary, with economists, statisticians, sociologists and epidemiologists bringing their respective disciplinary perspectives to make the research project, its conduct and its findings match high scholarly standards. However, the corollary to this claim is that, to be influential, one needs access to research policy brokers, and researchers themselves who are prepared to adapt to external timing requirements and to negotiate what is crucial about their research and what can be jettisoned for various practical reasons. All of this is quite reasonable, but does it constitute a set of lessons for those funding, doing or brokering research on public health or medical care services? That depends on what generalizations can be drawn from the detailed case studies Holland supplies in his portrait of the work at St. Thomas’ Hospital between 1962 and 1994.
Holland presents the widening scope of HSR studies at St. Thomas’, with commentary on the growing (and sometimes waning) influence of such work on the policies of the Department of Health. NHS leaders turned to research on modes of care, models to predict the need for medical services and a shift from inpatient treatment to ‘care in the community’, with general practitioners as the crucial providers. Predictably, the different parties had different views about the purposes and scope of such research. In the end, based on a large population survey, the researchers at St. Thomas’, concluded that the current supply of hospitals was sufficient for regional populations, but that more care should be provided to patients with chronic illness in the local community. Here was research bound to generate supporters and opponents, actors with substantial material and professional stakes in the hospital as the cathedral of modern medical care.
The list of studies Holland’s team addressed is quite impressive. Research on the value of automated laboratory testing, for example, concluded it was not cost effective, though widely touted. Findings about nationwide population screening were negative, despite popular appeal among many citizens and interested parties. To take another cluster of topics, the evidence suggested to the St. Thomas’ team that secondhand smoking was more dangerous than had been expected and that the promotion of low tar cigarettes was not an effective way to reduce the harms of smoking. The closing down of large mental hospitals, the organization of emergency care in hospitals, the health effects of providing milk at school, all took on established practices that had their own disciples. Indeed, the finding that withdrawing school milk had no significant health effects for all but one group of children illustrates the willingness of Holland’s team to take on established truths.
The rest of the book’s chapters continue these reviews of the fate of research studies and offer Holland’s views about a very great range of topics open to investigation. Readers will realize by now that the scope of policy topics Holland addresses is very broad. By contrast, Holland’s view of how to evaluate HSR – the field he labels HSR – is very narrow by the standards of other scholars. ‘The methods of evaluation’, Holland claims (p. 215), ‘are no different in HSR to those used in any form of research. Research commissioned or investigator-led needs to be submitted in the form of a protocol’. The protocol should contain ‘a hypothesis, the methods to be used in the investigation including appropriate analysis, the population to be investigated and methods of dissemination’. However, this cannot be true of all inquiries into health services. It is an epidemiologist converting by definition that field’s conception of research into a privileged position.
A reader from another social science field not only finds such claims of definitional authority questionable, but wonders about what are the implications of this conception of the subject for understanding the world of health care services. After all, health care seems genuinely exceptional in the scale, the cost and the sheer diversity of the activities that fall under its general label. The ‘industry’ involves a huge cast of characters, ranging from those who manage the hospital to the scientists for whom it is their laboratory. Issues of life and death are always there to debate, which makes highly emotional argumentation common. Other fields have some of these features, but no other seems to me to have quite the same intensity. Yet, there are other respects in which the health care policy arena is no different from any other. The analytic tools for understanding public policy disputes are common. Ideas about what is desirable and feasible change over time. Interested parties jostle for advantage, as they struggle over the distribution of resources and values. Governments have to decide where, and how, to use their political capital in specific institutional contexts. None of this is given much a place in the Holland formulation of what counts as HSR.
Nor does Holland pay attention to the industrial organization of health care. Health care is not only large, but one of the most rapidly expanding industries in all wealthy, developed nations. It has the largest labor force. It can be understood partly in terms of the benefits – incomes and profits – of those working in the industry. It is now the only industry whose expansion seems to be a cause of political concern rather than celebration (perhaps fracking is another example). The industry label, however, is misleading in at least one respect. It suggests homogeneity where there is heterogeneity. At one extreme in health care, there are the large pharmaceutical firms, powerful international actors able to play off governments of different countries against each other. On a smaller scale are manufacturers of medical technology, but equally keen to acquire not only a larger share of the market but to expand the market. At the other end of the organizational spectrum are solo medical practices, small group practices and specialist clinics. These are in effect small businesses, but because of the professional authority of physicians, they have a comparatively strong voice in national policy disputes. Hospitals are small enterprises compared with big pharmaceutical companies, but important players in local settings. They are often the largest single employer in a town and a driving force in the local economy. Their siting, and even more the threat of closure, can unleash powerful local protests.
The political economy of medical care, then, is the research field that Holland’s book does not address. As a result, the appeal to a common research mode that rules out many of the methods of such scholarship is limited. There is room for hypothesis testing in political economy research, but it will not be the basic method in much comparative policy analysis or the bulk of policy history. Nor will Holland’s approach to research dominate efforts to understand why one set of policy ideas emerged the winner and others the loser in any given health care policy dispute. Holland provides a delimited conception of what constitutes the core research method for understanding modern health services. The detailed – and interesting – reports of vigorous struggles reported in the book do not proceed from a hypothesis testing mode. The irony is that Walter Holland has had a fascinating role in the politics of British medical research over many decades, but did not see those politics as the object of analysis. They were both his delight and frustration. For the reader, especially, interested in the history of the British National Health Service, these developments offer a number of arresting case studies.
