The authors of this survey of contemporary Sudan maintain that the repeated failures of national governments (whether civilian or military) to articulate and implement a broadly acceptable democratic political system; to untangle the Gordian knot of contentious issues rooted in regionalism, particularly those pitting the south against the north; and to address with competence recurrent economic crises of staggering proportions have driven the country to an acute state of instability. This is, of course, neither a groundbreaking nor a controversial thesis, as suggested by the subtitle of a quite similar study written fifteen years ago by Peter Woodward (Sudan, 1898–1989: The Unstable State). However, in reprising the woes of independent Sudan and carrying the narrative forward to include the policies and practices of the military regime in power since 1989, Sidahmed and Sidahmed underscore the pervasiveness and intractability of national problems deeply rooted in a political culture of uncertainty.
After an opening chapter surveying key developments in the area that became Sudan from antiquity to the termination of the Anglo–Egyptian Condominium in 1956, a second traces the tortured political history of the subsequent fifty years. Three chapters focused on foreign relations, the economy, and linkages between state and society outline the path Sudan has traveled in recent years. In an admirable attempt to make the volume as timely as possible, a brief postscript describes the situation in the autumn of 2004. Even that account, however, was overtaken by events—most notably the signing of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement—by the time the book appeared a few months later.
The series of which this book is a part appears to place a premium on brevity, perhaps in keeping with the goal of finding readers both among specialists and general audiences. Accordingly, Sidahmed and Sidahmed have packed a wealth of information into just over 150 pages of text. Their synthesis of the scholarly literature and their mining of the American, British, and Arab press result in a thorough, if occasionally somewhat tedious, account that is much stronger on the presentation of data than on its analysis. The extensive bibliography will help readers wishing to probe issues more deeply, but a disproportionate number of bibliographical entries cover the period before independence (at least in comparison to the space allocated to those years in the book). No doubt this distribution reflects the difficulties of undertaking research on topics certain to be viewed as sensitive in the volatile environment that the authors describe.
In the end, however, the utility of this book is compromised by a fatal and inexcusable flaw. It is so riddled with errors of every kind—in spelling, grammar, and syntax; in the stating of facts; and as a result of careless oversights—that the book's final draft must never have been proofread nor received the attention of an editor. In these respects, extensive portions of the book are written at a level unacceptable in an undergraduate essay. No purpose is served by—nor does space allow for—a full cataloging of these shortcomings, but consider only a sampling of the errors that mar a less than twenty-page segment of the text. “… The Islamist movement concentrated its efforts on the student body … by the mid-1070s” (p. 54); “… the Bush administration was persuaded to waiver a law …” (p. 57); “… no political force in government or opposition, northern or southern, will be able to retract on it” [the south's right to self-determination] (p. 62). On page 68, the spelling of Sudan's military ruler between 1958 and 1964 is given as “Abbud” and “Abboud” within the space of three lines (a criticism raised on the grounds of consistency, not of rigorous transliteration), and an assertion that three internal developments had had an impact on foreign policy is followed by the enumeration and discussion of four such developments. In a survey such as this, an accurate geographical context is important and particularly beneficial for nonspecialist readers. However, in the introductory section of the book, Sudan is said to stretch “between the savannah and the equator” (p. vi), thus excluding the desert regions of the northern and western parts of the country, whereas the sole map in the book (p. xxviii) includes much of the neighboring country of Ethiopia but does not show Eritrea, despite that the text refers to that country frequently and that it has been an independent state since 1993. At best, all of these findings bespeak a lackadaisical attitude on the part of the series editor and the publisher, both of whom should be embarrassed to attach their imprimatur to so slovenly a product. Nor is it understandable why the authors would permit such cavalier treatment of a work in which they appear to have invested considerable effort.
This book contains much useful information, but other studies cover much the same ground. Purchasing this volume rewards the flaunting of basic professional standards. Why would we put in our personal or institutional libraries what we would return to our undergraduates for rewriting?
