Israel and the Persian Gulf is a clear and concise overview of the direct and indirect interactions that have occurred between the Gulf states and Israel since 1948. In his study, Gawdat Bahgat seeks to draw together what he describes as two separate Middle East subsystems: the Persian Gulf and the Levant. Bahgat argues that these two subsystems have for too long been viewed as separate, and he asserts that these two subregions are not just linked but that “developments in one region are echoed in the other” (pp. vii, 3). Israel and the Persian Gulf thus strives to fill a gap in the literature by illustrating how these two areas are inextricably tied and by explaining how stability in one region reinforces the other. These two regions have many deep-rooted connections that Bahgat very skillfully draws out, and in doing so he points out how the futures of both regions are inseparably linked. As Bahgat shows, a comprehensive peace in the region must address instability and sources of unrest in both the Levant and the Gulf simultaneously.
The study examines three different case studies. The first focuses on Israeli–Iranian relations, the second on Iraq's policy toward Israel (until 2003), and the third on the Gulf monarchies. The Israeli–Iranian relationship is an excellent place to begin because the experience with Iran has had such a decisive impact on how Israel interacts with Muslim states to this day. Bahgat does a fine job highlighting all the key episodes, and he provides a very thorough and detailed assessment of the major issues and obstacles that have characterized the relationship. Although there is perhaps too much emphasis placed on imperial Iran's desire to exploit Israel's American lobby, Bahgat aptly highlights Iran's role as a transit point for Iraqi Jews making aliya and the role this had in encouraging Tel Aviv to engage with Tehran (p. 14). Ben Gurion's “periphery policy” is assessed; however, it is perhaps lamentable that it does not receive greater attention because of its centrality for Israeli interaction within the region.
The second section examines Iraqi policy toward Israel until 2003. This is a very timely and insightful examination of a key aspect of Iraq's historic foreign policy. As Bahgat demonstrates, Baghdad's Israel policy had far-reaching implications, often impacting the country in numerous ways. As one of the most militantly anti-Zionist and anti-Israeli states in the region, Iraq under Saddam suffered considerably for its confrontational stance. Its positions impacted relations with Washington and led Iraq and Israel into conflict on several occasions. The Iraqi case proves Baghat's thesis quite well, that stability in the two subsystems are directly linked. In addition to the strong policy outline, Bahgat provides an excellent historical synopsis of the Iraqi Jewish community, including their struggle to emigrate to Israel and discussion of how successive Iraqi governments have treated the local Jewish community.
The third section explores the Gulf monarchies and their experiences with the State of Israel. This chapter is largely focused on Saudi Arabia; the five smaller monarchies are briefly examined in a short section at the end of the chapter. The reasons for this are several, including that for much of the period under examination in this study, the smaller Gulf monarchies were either not yet fully independent or were otherwise focused on regional matters closer to home. Therefore, Baghat argues, they had a limited role in the Arab–Israeli conflict until much later in the 20th century.
As for Saudi Arabia, the kingdom's position toward Tel Aviv throughout the Arab–Israeli conflict is detailed, as are the forces that shaped those attitudes, which Bahgat identifies as Islam, petroleum, and the relationship with the United States. Particular focus is given to Riyadh's role in organizing the 1973 oil embargo, the Saudi peace plans of 1981 and 2002, and Saudi Arabia's key “diplomatic and financial role in supporting the Palestinians and other Arab states in both launching wars and making peace with Israel” (p. 109). Despite the progress made by the ʿAbdullah peace plan, in the author's estimation, Saudi caution will mean that it will still take some time until Riyadh and Tel Aviv engage in full and complete recognition and normalization of relations.
By focusing on the interactions that have occurred over the past half century between Israel and the Gulf states, Bahgat illuminates the dynamic relations that have characterized an understudied aspect of Israel's recent foreign-policy experience. These ties—both overt as well as clandestine—reveal a depth of connections that betray the casual notion that Israel and the Gulf have had nothing to do with each another. Bahgat's work is therefore a valuable contribution to the growing body of literature exploring Israel's relationships with its Muslim neighbors, and Israel's periodic support of various Kurdish insurrections is an excellent case in point (p. 93).
Admittedly this study does not focus on either the foreign policies of Israel or the Gulf states. Rather, this work examines all the major events that have taken place between these actors during the past half century and then assesses these incidents to determine how they might impact the course of future events. These lessons learned, according to Bahgat, provide insight into how these two subregions might interact in the future. The resulting analysis in Israel and the Persian Gulf is noteworthy for its clarity and coherence in distilling over fifty years of complex and often contradictory policies into manageable historical vignettes that will prove useful for students and policy analysts alike.
