No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 August 2004
The 11 September 2001 terrorist attacks spawned a cottage industry of instant analysis. The result has been an avalanche of books that purport to explain terrorism, Islam, and the relationship between religion and violence. Most of the books written in the shadow of these events are superficial efforts unlikely to be remembered a few years hence. Bruce Lincoln's is a rare and distinguished exception. It is sure to outlast its competitors both in providing an understanding of 11 September and in offering broader frameworks for analyzing the linkages between religion and political change.
The 11 September 2001 terrorist attacks spawned a cottage industry of instant analysis. The result has been an avalanche of books that purport to explain terrorism, Islam, and the relationship between religion and violence. Most of the books written in the shadow of these events are superficial efforts unlikely to be remembered a few years hence. Bruce Lincoln's is a rare and distinguished exception. It is sure to outlast its competitors both in providing an understanding of 11 September and in offering broader frameworks for analyzing the linkages between religion and political change.
Holy Terrors consists of six essays on religion, violence, and social change, half written before and half written after the 2001 attacks. The post–11 September chapters offer close analyses of four relevant texts: the final instructions given to the hijackers found in Mohamed Atta

s luggage; George W. Bush's address to the nation on 7 October; a videotaped address by Osama bin Laden on the same date; and a televised interview with Jerry Falwell by Pat Robertson two days after the attacks. The full texts of all four appear in appendixes. The pre–11 September chapters examine religion in terms of its relationships to culture, post-colonial states, and revolts, although two of the three were revised after 11 September.
Inevitably, collected essays face problems of cohesion. Although this volume is far more cohesive than most, it might have appeared more unified had Lincoln structured it somewhat differently. He chose to arrange the material in what may appear to be a counter-intuitive sequence. The first three chapters are those that address 11 September texts, followed by the more general chapters, originally written between 1981 and 1997. While this results in movement from the specific to the general, reversing the order might have made more apparent the application of general ideas to a limited set of cases. More significantly, the broader early essays do not appear to have decisively shaped the later ones, in part because the post–11 September chapters are far more narrowly focused and, perhaps, because the author's views have altered over the more than twenty years that separate the earliest from the latest contributions. Although each chapter has a lapidary brilliance of its own, the overall impression remains one of superbly constructed individual arguments rather than of a single, cohesive work.
That said, the book is immensely valuable, both for the light it sheds on the events of 2001 and for the author's willingness to confront the question, “What do we mean by ‘religion?”’ Lincoln advances conceptualization by eschewing an essentialist definition and instead works within a framework of four categories: discourse, practice, institution, and community. This typology both encompasses religious manifestations and provides a basis for comparison among them. It does not seek to somehow capture the essence of religion in a single sentence. Instead, by identifying domains of belief and behavior, Lincoln provides a basis for analyzing the religious elements that might be relevant to the commission of violent acts.
The value of this lies not only in its facilitation of comparative analysis, but also in its ability to break free of the notion that there are inherently “dangerous religions.” This concept has a double existence, present in both discussions of so-called fundamentalist religions and New Religious Movements (or “cults”). Lincoln wisely avoids “fundamentalist” as “a term that has inflammatory connotations and fails to capture what is truly crucial: that is, the conviction that religion ought to penetrate all aspects of social, indeed of human existence” (p. 5). His preferred term—“maximalist”—manages to avoid the incendiary associations of “fundamentalist” while capturing the tendency of religious militants to extend religion into every sphere of life.
The capacity of religion to permeate other spheres also explains Lincoln's preoccupation with the elasticity of boundaries that conventionally appear to separate religion, on the one hand, from culture and politics, on the other. The concept of a religious sphere distinct from the political was, as Lincoln suggests, the consequence of a specifically Western history of religiously driven warfare against which the modern nation-state was erected as a bulwark. Belief in the universality of this pattern assumes, erroneously, that the same history will necessarily be replicated elsewhere. When religion extends beyond the constraints regarded as customary in the West, the response is either incomprehension or the sense that some natural law has been violated. As the author demonstrates, the placement of boundaries is a dynamic process. Not only do societies differ in this respect; the same society may over time experience the expansion or contraction of the religious domain. Lincoln provides a useful set of models embodying such boundary shifts in situations characterized by varying degrees of secularism and religious diversity.
This is, in short, a work filled with insights, blending theory and analysis. It is destined to be read and cited long after the tragic events of 11 September have passed into history.