I. INTRODUCTION
In this paper, we focus on the least-well-known member of the first generation of the Austrian School, Friedrich von Wieser, and emphasize his contribution to the institutional tradition in economics. The institutional dimension of Wieser’s contribution is often neglected in the literature, although surprisingly, two of his major works, Social Economics (written in 1914, translated in 1927; hereinafter [1927a] 1967) and Das Gesetz der Macht (written in 1926), translated into English as The Law of Power (1983; hereinafter [1926] 1983), were reviewed and introduced by two, famous, ‘old’ institutionalists, Wesley Clair Mitchell and Warren Joseph Samuels. Footnote 1 Wieser’s contribution to monetary theory has also been rather neglected, although, as will be argued in this paper, 1) it is far from being negligible, and 2) it illustrates the institutional dimension of his economics.
The paper is organized as follows. Section II stresses the institutional background of Wieser’s economics. In section III, his monetary approach is presented and interpreted as an illustration of the institutional mark of his economics. Section IV concludes.
II. WIESER’S CONTRIBUTION TO INSTITUTIONAL ECONOMICS
The Difficult Exegesis of Wieser’s Overall Approach to Economics
Wieser’s contribution to economics is, still today, either neglected Footnote 2 or misinterpreted. Footnote 3 On the one hand, he is wrongly but often viewed as a faithful follower of Carl Menger, but paling into insignificance beside Eugene von Böhm-Bawerk. Symptomatically, in his History of Economic Analysis, Joseph Alloïs Schumpeter (1954, p. 913) considered that Wieser “was the worst technician of the three great Austrians.” Moreover, Schumpeter’s exposition of Wieser’s contribution is focused on his contribution to pure economics—his theory of value—and overlooks his sociological work. Footnote 4 This has certainly contributed to a fragmented view of Wieser’s achievements. It is all the more regrettable that in his obituary of Wieser, published in The Economic Journal in 1927, Footnote 5 Schumpeter recognizes that “every element of [Wieser’s work] formed part of an harmonious whole, which unfolded itself slowly and grew organically to an imposing height and breadth” (Schumpeter Reference Schumpeter1927, p. 335). Finally, Schumpeter (1954, p. 844) suggests that even the members of the Austrian School, a school of thinking founded by Wieser and his brother-in-law Böhm-Bawerk, neglect Wieser’s work. The following passage from Friedrich Hayek’s (1926) obituary of Wieser, originally published in the Jahrbücher für Nationalökonomie und Statistik, gives some support to this opinion: “in terms of intellectual consistency and elegance, … [Wieser’s work] is undoubtedly inferior to Böhm-Bawerk’s work in economic analysis, but the fault lies with the incomparably greater number of phenomena taken into account by Wieser” (Hayek [Reference Hayek1926] 1992, p. 121). Like Frank Knight (Reference Knight1925) and George Joseph Stigler (1941, pp. 159–160), Hayek praises Wieser for introducing the notions of ‘marginal utility’ and ‘opportunity cost’ and solving the ‘imputation problem,’ but also observes that his writings are difficult to assimilate:
The absence of diminishing returns and of ‘effort and sacrifice’ put his theory of value at odds with the Marshallian tradition; the assumption of given commodity prices which underlies his theory of distribution was in sharp contrast with Walras; the evolution of his thought in the field of production from an early adoption of incremental changes in input proportions along Mengerian lines in the direction of ‘definite proportions’ prevented him from being assimilated by the emerging theorists of marginal productivity. (Hayek [Reference Hayek1926] 1992, p. 120)
Fifteen years later, Stigler seemed to have been thinking along the same lines, and declared the idea of Wieser’s value theory originating in the concept of “natural value” to be “incomprehensible” (Stigler Reference Stigler1941, p. 158n2). Footnote 6 Wieser’s personal traits and manners and his late support for authoritarian political regimes did nothing to boost his popularity. Footnote 7 All these factors have contributed to the underestimation of his work.
In contrast, we would endorse the view, first articulated by Wesley Mitchell, that Wieser was ahead of his time, that “the influence upon economic theory exercised by von Wieser’s formulation lies more in the future than in the past” (Mitchell Reference Mitchell and Wieser1967, p. 104). Similarly, in Oskar Morgenstern’s (Reference Morgenstern1927) laudatory obituary of Wieser, Wieser’s early inclination towards history and sociology is described as giving his theoretical approach a definitive institutional imprint, which made his contribution truly original, in contrast to the unflattering picture conveyed by the history of economic thought. In particular, in Theorie der gesellschaftlichen Wirtschaft Footnote 8 (Wieser Reference Wieser1914), translated as Social Economics (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967), Wieser insisted that the subjectivist conception of economics developed by Carl Menger was unsatisfactory in discarding the social forces holding human behavior, in particular the forces of freedom and compulsion, that imply a radical shift from the ideal, pure theoretical system—described by him in his first book, Der natürliche Wert (Wieser Reference Wieser1889), translated as Natural Value (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967), as the “Single Economy.” In what follows, this understanding is essential to grasp the institutional dimension of his contribution; in addition, it left its mark on his writings on monetary theory.
The lack of appreciation of Wieser’s contribution is the more regrettable in light of the interesting and inspiring approach he developed in his final book, Das Gesetz der Macht, Footnote 9 published just a few months before his death and considered “his crowning achievement” (Hayek [Reference Hayek1926] 1992, p. 108). In this contribution, Wieser offers an interesting mix of economic analysis and economic sociology, which justifies an institutionalist interpretation of Wieser, and which would appear much more in line with Schumpeter than with his contemporaries from the Austrian School. Footnote 10 Wieser’s approach also shares some commonalities with the German Historical School, in particular with Max Weber and Werner Sombart, regarding the emphasis put on the issues of power and leadership (Streissler Reference Streissler and Leser1986; Campagnolo and Vivel Reference Campagnolo and Vivel2012).
Also, methodologically, Wieser parts company with most of his colleagues. Although he was not interested in methodological matters per se, Footnote 11 he can, in retrospect, be considered, like Schumpeter, a proponent of Joseph Agassi’s (Reference Agassi1975) notion of “institutional individualism.” Footnote 12 Robert Ekelund (Reference Ekelund1986, p. 4) develops a similar idea, characterizing Wieser’s modified individualism as “nothing but the classical (or Mengerian) conception joined to Veblenian–Spencerian institutional and sociological theory,” and praising his work for being a precious contribution that provided a bridge from neoclassical utility theory to social economics. Footnote 13 Note, in passing, that this argument is akin to a plea to dehomogenize the Austrian School. Footnote 14 Moreover, Wieser develops an original conception of institutions in which power and social stratification play substantial roles in their emergence and evolution. This is definitely a distinctive feature of Wieser’s approach, as emphasized in section III.
This feature was already present in his habilitation thesis published in 1884—Ursprung und Hauptgesetze des wirtschaftlichen Wertes—in which he focuses on what would be the characteristics of a pre-institutional economic system. He develops this mental experiment further in Social Economics (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967), in which he exploits the method of successive approximations in order to describe social phenomena with a decreasing level of abstractness. He begins to analyze what he calls “simple economies,” characterized by “the most abstract isolating and idealizing assumptions,” and proceeds by “decreasing abstraction to conditions of reality” (to wit: direct exchange, then indirect exchange, monopolies, state intervention, international exchange) in order to describe what he calls “social economies,” then “state economy,” and finally “world economy” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967, pp. 6–13). Footnote 15 In other words, Wieser’s endeavor is “to recognize the impact of vast impersonal forces in human society, to which each individual is subjected against his volition, forces that inevitably provide events that were not wanted or even foreseen by anyone” (Hayek [Reference Hayek1926] 1992, p. 111). However, in contrast to Menger or Hayek, he is quite pessimistic about the possibility that the unforeseen result of human action will guarantee public welfare. He argues that the passage from simple economies—where the law of natural value applies and where a ‘neutral’ conception of utility is acceptable Footnote 16 —implies some qualitative changes, regarding, in particular, two related issues that Wieser considers to be of paramount importance: 1) the problem of monopoly, which he views as more important than free competition; and 2) the predominance of the struggle between the strong and the weak over the principle of equal opportunity for all. According to, and as synthesized by, Mitchell, these two propositions led Wieser to pose two questions: 1) What is the nature and the origin of this inequality in power? and 2) Where does the unity of society lie? (Mitchell Reference Mitchell1917, p. 104). Clearly, to address these questions, Wieser needed to develop a broader conception of economic theory, borrowing from other disciplines such as psychology and economic sociology. This also implied appropriate amendments to the classical theory of value.
First, Wieser could not endorse a neutral concept of utility. For him, “man by nature is a social being” held together by the forces of freedom and the forces of compulsion (Wieser Reference Wieser1914, p. 155).
His recourse to the psychology of masses and economic sociology, as will be developed below, is a necessary step in order to establish what promotes unity of society: leadership. Footnote 17 In other words, united action requires leadership, and the mass of men show their independence chiefly in choosing which leader to obey, or how faithfully to follow the example set by the leader. Here, leadership rests upon social inequality because the relation between ruler and subject develops into a stratification of the classes, which, for Wieser, was not just an objective fact: it molded men to its image. As a result, the economic principle of least cost and highest utility does not rule men’s actions in the way assumed in simple economic theory; rather, it assumes the form of “be as good an economic man as your fellows” (Mitchell Reference Mitchell1917, p. 105). Accordingly, in a social economy, prices also are ‘stratified,’ Footnote 18 reflecting the evolution of different types of goods in relation to the social groups that consume them. Thus, the existence of three classes implies that the group of ‘mass commodities’ must be evaluated against the marginal utility of the poor; the set of ‘intermediate goods’ must be evaluated according to the preferences of the middle classes; and the group of ‘luxury goods’ must be evaluated according to the valuations of rich people (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967, pp. 157–158). Footnote 19
However, through the initiative of leaders and through imitative acceptance by the masses, society sometimes develops certain institutions that serve the common need so well that they seem to be the creation of an organized social will. In section III, we show that money is one example of such an institution.
Second, as already pointed out, Wieser was not satisfied by naive individualist explanations, although he never rejected methodological individualism as a whole, even if, as Ekelund and Mark Thornton (Reference Ekelund and Thornton1986, p. 4) suggest and as already hinted at before, Footnote 20 “Wieser’s first intellectual romance with history, together with his early enchantment with mass historical movements, exemplified in Virgil, Homer, the Niebelungenlied and Leo Tolstoy’s ‘history of the anonymous masses’, could seriously mislead scholars into believing that Wieser’s unit of social analysis was collective in nature.” Quite the contrary, in Social Economics, Wieser makes it clear that “the explanation must still run in terms of the individual,” since “[t]he individuals which comprise the society are the sole possessors of all consciousness and of all will” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967, p. 154). According to Wieser ([1926] 1983, p. 146), classical individualism can be amended to provide alternative explanations other “than the one which suggests itself in the personal sphere for the relations between individuals” and affords no room for “the element of constraint or command without which the state could neither originate nor endure and which can be clearly established for money as well.” Footnote 21 However, Wieser is even less satisfied by collectivist or organic explanations, stating that “in a roundabout way, [they] lead back to the individualistic explanation[s] by taking the people and the masses as a magnified individual” (ibid., p. 146).
For this reason he favored the ‘modified’ individualism we have interpreted as a version of Agassi’s (Reference Agassi1975) institutional individualism. Wieser’s analysis of institutions and money reinforces this interpretation.
Wieser’s Analysis of Institutions: Role, Nature, Mode of Emergence, and Evolution
The reference to a natural economy as a fiction to describe an idealized economic system—i.e., one in which the impact of specific institutions can be compared—is symptomatic of Wieser’s approach. But, as already emphasized, his approach involves some complexity, since it also allows for feedback from individual behavior through the social powers on institutions. The social powers constitute the appropriate level of analysis that considers the interactions between individuals and institutions. They can take the form of labor unions or cartels, but also relate to customs, sentiments, norms, structure, or legislation that shape individual behavior. The cumulative actions of individuals who seek their interest under the influence and constraints of these social powers in turn promote the emergence and alterations of institutions.
Wieser’s reference to the natural economy is therefore neither a theoretical normative benchmark nor an empirical tendency of real economies. Instead, it acts as a benchmark for a pure type of ‘institutionally based’ economic system, where there is no asymmetry between social actors, and neither is there money.
On the question of the nature of institutions, Wieser’s approach may recall Menger’s distinction between pragmatic and organic institutions. From a terminology perspective, Wieser distinguishes social institutions, such as “offices, establishments and works of the most varied kinds,” from what he calls “historical formations,” such as family, tribe, state, people, nation, society, or money (see section III), according to their respective modes of emergence. In a nutshell, social institutions are characterized by being “created by governments or by other orders of power for a deliberate purpose and following a deliberate plan” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1926] 1983, p. 141; original emphasis), or “in the awareness of a task to be done,” while historical formations “grow up without the possibility of one’s becoming aware of a specific creator” but rather as a “searching force” (ibid., pp. 141–145).
By analogy with Menger’s classification, historical formations could be conceived as organic institutions, since they are the result of unintended action, and social institutions could be considered pragmatic, since they are the result of “intentions, opinions, and available instrumentalities of human social unions or their ruler” (Menger [Reference Menger1883] 1963, p. 145).
However, this analogy does not hold if one recalls that for Menger, the distinction between pragmatic and organic institutions overlaps with the distinction between “realistic-empirical” and “exact science” approaches. Although Menger admits that both approaches might complement each other, they nevertheless constitute two logically distinct perspectives. However, for Wieser, social institutions and historical formations cannot be the subject of independent analyses.
On the one hand, Wieser explains that social institutions are always embedded in “historical formations” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1926] 1983, p. 146) in the sense that an emerging social institution must necessarily fit or be consistent with the contemporary existing historical formation. Footnote 22 On the other hand, historical formations are defined in relation to power, which plays an important role in Wieser’s analysis of institutions. This characteristic stands in sharp contrast to Menger’s framework, in which power (or even state power) is virtually absent. Footnote 23 Indeed, Wieser emphasizes that historical formations constitute particular states of the evolution of society, characterized by a certain social stratification of power, which results from “the accord of many personal units of consciousness which to a certain degree give up their independence, but without a higher encompassing unit of consciousness taking their place” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1926] 1983, p. 146; original emphasis).
Wieser’s notion of power borrows from the German Historical School, especially from Max Weber. As the notion of mass, it is not to be interpreted as an autonomous collective entity, but, rather, as the very instantiation of motives of human action. As Wieser made clear in the first pages of his Social Economics, deliberate action can be traced back to two stimuli: “the purpose desire that our efforts attain their object, and an active motor stimulus that is massed under tension and strives to be discharged. Fundamentally, both desire and this force are intimately associated, but they appear distinct at the surface of consciousness” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967, p. 18). This gives support to an interpretation according to which, for Wieser, power has two roots: on one hand, the desire to achieve power; on the other hand, what results from that desire (what is referred to in Hegelian German philosophy as Begierde). This conception of human action is helpful for understanding the difference between a leader and the masses. Footnote 24
Indeed, Wieser’s analysis of power is based on the distinction between masses and leaders. It is fair to mention here that Wieser introduces this distinction more to emphasize that masses and leaders differ in terms of behavior or rationality than to suggest the idea of the intellectual superiority of the leaders Footnote 25 with respect to the masses, or to convey a pejorative meaning to the term “mass.” Moreover, though the idea of social fragmentation (encapsulated in the distinction between leaders and followers borrowed from Max Weber) is common in the Austrian economics literature, it plays a very specific role in Wieser. One could even say that the respective weights of leaders and followers are reversed in comparison with most Austrian authors. First, for Wieser, the mass plays a crucial role, in contrast to the insignificant one conferred by Schumpeter to the ‘followers,’ as compared with the heroic leader ‘entrepreneur.’ Second, Wieser considers the phenomenon of leadership to be based on the existence of inequalities within a given population: it is governed by the “law of small numbers” based “on the social success of small groups” (ibid., p. 1; original emphasis). Third, he contrasts two types of leadership: on the one hand, there is the authoritarian (personal or cooperative) kind of leadership, including despotic, lordly leadership, or small social groupings such as guilds; on the other hand, there is the impersonal or anonymous kind of leadership, which generally complements authoritarian-type leadership in instances of social life such as the development of language, art, science, law, and ethics, or the creation of money (Wieser [Reference Wieser1926] 1983, p. 40). Interestingly, this distinction is parallel to another important one made by Wieser, the distinction between external and internal power: “internal power” is “impersonal and anonymous” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1926] 1983, p. 3), while “external power” corresponds to the power that some persons or some groups exert on people with the help of “external” means such as “numerical superiority, arms or wealth” (ibid., p. 3). Internal power can be channeled by various means; for instance, science and knowledge through “historical education” contribute to the creation of the social interactions that support social internal power (ibid., p. 107). Not surprisingly, as in the case of authoritarian and anonymous types of leadership, there must be some complementarities and consistency between internal power and external power. In particular, there must be some congruence between the beliefs or representations of the masses and the leaders, which is enabled by the diffusion of values among the different leadership strata (ibid., p. 43). Footnote 26 But, more importantly, internal power is seen as a more progressive form of power, since it forces the approval of others and depends on the leaders’ strength of conviction, while external power is a primitive form of power, which rests on the threat of political forces.
In the same line of idea, if Wieser defines masses simply by the fact that they are “following the leader” (ibid., p. 38), he immediately qualifies this definition by contrasting two forms of following: dead masses or blind following, and true following. “Blind following” refers to a passive form of imitation that is reducible to sheep-like behavior: i.e., “following [the] surroundings rather than the leader” (ibid., p. 44). “True following” is the form of imitation that Wieser concentrates on, and refers to a reflective, searching type of following or active following, “which demands of the masses a certain independence of conduct and the capacity to adapt to the given circumstances” (ibid., p. 45). More interestingly, true following also involves a process of internalization (or even true identification) of power by the masses, and Wieser suggests the existence of a complex dynamic between masses and leaders, which involves the interplay of “internal power” and “external power” within a stratified society. Footnote 27 The idea of stratification among both masses (or social classes) and leaders (or dominant political rulers) is at the core of Wieser’s analysis of the selection process of leaders by masses. It is referred to by Wieser as a law: the law of increasing stratification (Wieser [Reference Wieser1926] 1983, p. 26). In a lecture he presented when he assumed the rectorship of Charles University (Vienna), he illustrated the “language battle” he witnessed when the famous university of the Hapsburg Empire had been divided into Czech and German institutions as an example of the emergence of a new mass (the Czechs) in the political scene, and described this process as a desirable step to freedom and to power (see Yagi Reference Yagi and Shionoya2001). Later, in Recht and Macht (1910), he investigated this theoretically in the context of the rise of the working class in the capitalist society, and claimed that stratification within masses provides a guarantee of future space of freedom, a safeguard against monolithic domination as well as an argument in favor of state intervention on a mass society. Furthermore, stratification also concerns the classes of leaders or the political rulers who are potentially threatened by the emergence of a new mass. This usually leads to the division of the ruling class. The same applies to the new emerging ruling class, and this may pave the way for the development of the state:
In economics it is the law that the self-interest of individuals turns out to be for the benefits of the whole by way of free competition in which everyone behaves as an egoist toward each other. Similarly [in politics], the dominant [class] egoism might be redirected to serve the whole by the resistance of the countervailing egoism based on collective solidarity. After a fierce struggle the top of the proletariat may attain the position of social power along with present power groups. But at that stage, as once on the side of bourgeoisie the unified liberal party had to separate, division will emerge inevitably within the now monolithic proletariat. Its sign is seen already among the proletarian leaders who apparently established their power within the state. The law of stratification is also valid in the case of the fourth rank. (Wieser Reference Wieser1910, p. 127; translation by Yagi Reference Yagi and Shionoya2001)
Therefore, the notions of “anonymous leadership” and “internal power” suggest more than the mere mutual interactions of leaders and followers, and provide significant illustrations of Wieser’s general method’s borrowing from social psychology and economic sociology.
First, as Wieser indicates, anonymous leadership is characterized by the fact that “the social success of small groups can be magnified to full-fledged social success if the new strength, which first was formed by the small group in its own interest, is removed from its control and placed at the disposal of the society as a whole” (ibid., p. 33; original emphasis). This means, in particular, that Wieser considers that the notion of success encompasses more than Menger’s idea of the replication by followers of supposedly economically efficient behaviors displayed by leaders. Footnote 28 As pointed out by Samuels in his introduction to The Law of Power, Wieser’s notion of success differs from Menger’s because it is not defined in abstracto as the achievement of the fittest economic state. In particular, depending on whether it is actual or perceived, success can also lead to negative outcomes, such as dictatorships. As Samuels wrote, in Menger.
Success constitutes a mechanism, as it were, of historical selection. The course of history is marked by a path of success vis-à-vis other paths which might have been. Success in this context signifies survival…. [By contrast] success, in Wieser’s analysis, has no independent positive or normative, ex ante, test. It is circumstantial, episodic, and without external or internal value basis independent of the fact of survival. It is the consequence of successes, however, which marks the course of history. (Samuels, Introduction to The Law of Power, Wieser [Reference Wieser1926] 1983, p. xxxi)
Second, Wieser refers to the Hegelian Footnote 29 notion of “objective spirit,” which he borrows from Wilhem Dilthey and Hans Freyer, Footnote 30 but does so with further qualifications. Footnote 31 For Wieser, the idea of “objective spirit” is the means to articulate individual beliefs or values using collective beliefs, in a manner that is more sophisticated than that implied by the mere imitation of leaders by the masses. Footnote 32 Moreover, objective spirit does not imply any denial of methodological individualism. What is crucial for the articulation between individual and collective values is the intensity of the “binding force” of historical formations, which rests on the fact that this intensity “is borne out of the spirit of the united individuals,” even if it could be “so enhanced that it squashes the individuals which it binds” (ibid., p. 149). In other words, it is possible that the objective spirit of a community conflicts with the individuals’ interests even though it could not have emerged without their benevolence. Consequently, the ‘objective spirit’ appears as an entity with some autonomy vis-à-vis individuals. In particular, it possesses its own developmental mechanisms, such as inertia, self-preservation, and destructive power, at both the individual and collective levels (ibid., p. 149).
Third, Wieser refers to “the law of upward mobility of classes,” Footnote 33 which implies the existence of a tendency towards the congruence of beliefs between masses and leaders. Indeed, at first, masses have no share in public power, but through social interaction—essentially through labor and art—they may have an opportunity to further their personal achievements, and therefore to resist pressure from the leaders and not completely succumb to it. As far as the ruling leaders are concerned, they themselves are aware of their own interests in harnessing the vigor of the people to augment it and better exploit these interests, such that the more enlightened rulers have a stronger affinity with the populace and will begin to share public power with it. Wieser summarizes it as follows:
In the present epoch, the face of the earth is being technically transformed by the alertness of … both those in command and those in subordination positions. All these quietly evolving and ascending collective forces have in due time been transformed into social power or they will do so, acting as a resistance first but eventually also sharing leadership roles. (Wieser [Reference Wieser1926] 1983, p. 26)
To sum up, Wieser’s contribution is marked by a wide institutionalist perspective that is linked to both the German Historical School through the influence of Max Weber and to the old American institutionalist tradition. His personal experience and observations gave him rich materials to transfer Menger’s analysis of the emergence of spontaneous orders to politics and sociology, thereby becoming the social economist of the Austrian School.
We next illustrate Wieser’s general method and conception of institutions by his reflection on money.
III. WIESER ON MONEY: AN ILLUSTRATION OF HIS INSTITUTIONAL APPROACH
Wieser’s Monetary Theory
The earlier comments about the poor reception given to Wieser’s theoretical work in general apply also to his contribution to monetary theory. Footnote 34 This is all the more surprising since his last work, written in 1926, was an article entitled “Geld,” written for the fourth edition of the Hantwörterbuch der Staatswissenschaften, edited by Elster, Weber, and Wieser (1927b). Moreover, most of Wieser’s monetary doctrines are in German and have never been translated into English. Footnote 35 Benjamin McAlester Anderson (1911) and M. H. J. Dullaart (Reference Dullaart1988) provide faithful accounts of Wieser’s monetary theory, which, while being anchored in the Austrian tradition in relation to certain aspects, such as the search for a causal explanation of value and the price of money by means of marginal utility, is idiosyncratic in others, such as his reflection on the causality between money costs and the general level of prices.
Benjamin Anderson (1911, p. 85) summarizes Wieser’s monetary doctrines set forth in two expositions, separated by five years. The first is an address delivered on the occasion of his accession to a professorship at the University of Vienna in 1904, which was published in the Zeitschrift für Volkswirtschaft, Sozialpolitik und Verwaltung under the title “Der Geldwert und seine geschichtlichen Veränderungen” (Wieser Reference Wieser1904). The second (partly written and partly spoken) Footnote 36 represents a considerable development of the first.
Dullaart (Reference Dullaart1988) also includes Wieser’s (Reference Wieser, Elster, Weber and Wieser1927b) final article on money in the discussion.
To sum up the main arguments, Wieser’s first exposition is an unconvincing attempt to provide an explanation of the value of money via marginal utility, which rests on a tautological proposition: the value of money is determined by the relation of money to all other goods that are exchanged.
In other words, the value of money depends not on its subjective use-value, its own marginal utility—it has none. The (objective) value of money depends on its value in exchange, on the marginal utility of the goods that are exchanged for it. However, this depends on prices, and prices depend, in part, on the value of money.
Wieser’s explanation is developed further in his second exposition, in which he seeks to escape the circularity involved in the conception of purchasing power and achieve an absolute conception, which would be a causal factor in the determination of general prices rather than a mere reflection of them. Therefore, he introduces a distinction between a conventional or normative public economic value of money—the “volkswirtschaftlicher Wert,” as he calls it—which differs from the more traditional objective value concept he exploits in his earlier article, since it is “the common subjective part of the individual valuations leaving out the remainder of individual peculiarities,” Footnote 37 and the personal, individual idiosyncratic value of money ([1909a] 1929, p. 502), which is more ‘relative,’ since it changes with the volume of one’s personal income, with the intensity of one’s need for money, and with market prices (Wieser [Reference Wieser and Hayek1909a] 1929, p. 509).
The rationale for this distinction is to identify a “concept of the public economic value of money which, to be sure, proceeds from the general price-level, but which excludes from its content everything that comes purely from the value of goods” (Wieser [Reference Wieser and Hayek1909a] 1929, p. 511). However, as Anderson (1911, p. 88) stresses, we find no independent definition of the economic value of money; quite the contrary, since the definition runs in terms of the values of goods: “the value of money rises when the same inner values of commodities are expressed in lower prices; it falls, when they are expressed in higher prices” (Wieser Reference Wieser1909b, pp. 511–512).
Later, in his article “Geld” (Wieser Reference Wieser, Elster, Weber and Wieser1927b, p. 682), Wieser refines his ‘conventional’ objective notion of money value by referring to the nature of money as something to be “commonly accepted by the masses” (“Massengewohnheit der Annahme”), and seems to endorse a view of the emergence of money that in many, but not all, respects is similar to Menger’s, as we discuss later.
This introduction of a mix of sociological and economic factors in the explanation of the value of money adds to the confusion in Wieser’s monetary thinking. According to Dullaart (Reference Dullaart1988), some of the confusion can be put down to Wieser’s hesitation over the relevance of quantity theory. Before 1914, he rejects it for technical reasons but mainly because he is a supporter of the banking principle and adopts John Fullarton’s principle, which implies that the quantity of money is an endogenous variable that adjusts to the needs of the economy. As Richard Arena (Reference Arena, Arena and Salvadori2004, p. 16) mentions, adoption of Fullarton’s principle implies also that Wieser agrees with the distinction between credit (i.e., the money issued by commercial banks) and notes (i.e., Central Bank money). Wieser makes it clear that the first type is temporary but the second type is definitive: “Commercial paper is a means of only provisional payment. Notes are a means of final and conclusive payment just as is money” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967, pp. 245–246). However, after 1914, and in 1927 in particular, Wieser would seem to have abandoned his resistance to quantity theory and expresses explicit agreement with the statement that “depreciation follows inflation” (Wieser Reference Wieser, Elster, Weber and Wieser1927b, p. 702), giving the reader the impression that his former critique of the quantity theory regarded only alternative explanations of the problem of rising prices.
To sum up, according to Wieser, the value of money is determined in the markets for consumption goods, by the relation between real income (i.e., the total volume of consumption goods to be paid for out of money income) and money income (including borrowings, not including savings). Footnote 38 Taking account of the distinction between personal and public value of money, Wieser explains that the personal value of money—which concerns only the laborer’s calculation, not that of the businessman—depends on the relation between an individual’s money income and his real income in terms of goods, while the public economic value of money depends on the money income of the community as a whole and its real income (Wieser [Reference Wieser and Hayek1909a] 1929, pp. 516–518). Therefore, a higher personal money income—at an unchanged price level—will decrease the personal exchange value of money, thereby inducing consumers to substitute goods for money, which, at an unchanged real income, will produce higher demand prices. In a nutshell, Wieser locates the origin of a rise in price levels in a diminishing personal value of money, which may spread to the whole economy. Ludwig von Mises ([1924] 1953) criticizes Wieser on this point; for von Mises, the diminishing marginal utility is the effect and not the cause of a rise in the price level. Also, Wieser’s point of view is not very convincing, since the causality between the marginal utility of money and the price level cannot be assessed on account of a discrepancy of different marginal utilities of money and commodities. There is no reason why a higher price level would not cause also a lower marginal utility of commodities, since consumers suppose that they are able to expand their consumption (see von Mises [Reference Mises and Batson1924] 1953, p. 157).
However, what is interesting is that Wieser generalizes his argument in order to provide an explanation of historical inflationary trends, such as periods of European inflation in the sixteenth century and around 1900. The explanation runs as follows: the mere extension of the money economy increases the amount of money income, lowers the personal value of money, lowers its public economic value, and raises prices. Hence, there is a tendency for the public economic value of money to sink, and this has been the historical fact (Wieser [Reference Wieser and Hayek1909a] 1929, pp. 519–520).
Now, what causes the extension of money income? Wieser’s argument is worthy of a lengthier discussion, since it is another example of the sociological and institutional imprint of his work. Dullaart (1988, p. 131) develops that, despite von Mises’s critique, Wieser’s explanation of the monetization of the economy borrows from Georg Simmel’s ([1900] 2004) analysis of money as the bearer of impersonal relations between men and, as a consequence, of individual freedom. It is also reminiscent of Karl Polanyi’s (1968, p. 89) account of the passage from barter to monetary exchange as involving a crowding out of reciprocity: “Reciprocity demands adequacy of response, not mathematical equality.”
For the sake of brevity, let us focus on Wieser’s main argument. According to him, the extension of the monetary economy involves more calculation and additional costs compared with the natural economy, where some costs are not included in the supply side. In other words, the passage from the natural to the monetary economy is never neutral with regard to commodity values. The additional costs include, among others, moral and insurance costs due to increasing opportunism, rising opportunity costs due to the generalization of market transactions, Footnote 39 and increased tax levies to finance education, culture, and armament programs. Footnote 40 To sum up, Wieser not only tackled the main questions in monetary theory, he also touched on the issue of monetary development. Moreover, he paid special attention to the problem of the origin of money, the topic to which the rest of the paper is devoted.
Wieser’s Analysis of the Emergence of Money
Our reconstruction of Wieser’s conception of the origin of money is based mainly on three references: Social Economics ([1927a] 1967), “Geld” (1927b), and The Law of Power ([1926] 1983). Wieser’s view of the emergence of money can be reconstructed from what we have emphasized concerning his conception of institutions and his specific critical account of Menger’s much better known explanation of the origin of money.
First, Wieser sees the process of the emergence of money as an example of historical formations and, more specifically, of “objective ones which are by no means planned institutions but results of historical development nurtured by success, an example of this being money in its original form, as yet unregulated by the state” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1926] 1983, p. 143). However, he departs from Menger by considering that other factors, such as the intervention of the state or power strata, have a determining influence on this process insofar as its maintenance and future development are concerned. For instance, he sometimes touches on the problem of the social norm nature of money by pinpointing the “binding force” or the “social power” of money through the notion of the “obligation to accept it,” which makes the payer feel protected against shifty refusal of payment (ibid., p. 165). We find a similar idea in Social Economics, where he writes that “certain goods … will be universally used, because everybody may be convinced that there is no one who will refuse to accept [them]” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967, p. 164; original emphasis).
In “Geld,” he characterizes money using a somewhat different terminology from that used in Gesetz der Macht, as “a historical-social formation [geschichtlich-gesellschaftliche Bildung]” (Wieser Reference Wieser, Elster, Weber and Wieser1927b, p. 683). He makes clear his rejection of the view of “money as an intentionally designed institution, created either by the state or by a free contract among its citizens” (ibid.). Rather, he states:
Money emerged from small beginnings little by little to reach its final form. This has happened, when one or another particularly alert economizing individuals [Wirtschafter] has recognized the benefits [of using a medium of exchange].… The example of the advantage that these individuals are able to realize induces others to imitate them. These alert individuals become the leaders with respect to others, who followed them in the use of money. (Wieser Reference Wieser, Elster, Weber and Wieser1927b, p. 683)
In conclusion, “the emergence of money can be traced back to individual incentives, but it has been only completed when the mass custom of acceptance [Massengewohnheit der Annahme] has bestowed on money a compulsory social character.… When money has [thus] been introduced as a social formation, it becomes the task of the state to regulate its technical and legal features for the general interest” (Wieser Reference Wieser, Elster, Weber and Wieser1927b, pp. 683–684; all our own translations).
These quotations help to clarify Wieser’s reasons for disagreeing with Menger’s proposition that social institutions are nothing more than the unintended social results of individual teleological factors. Footnote 41 Wieser’s main objections to Menger are related to his strictly “individualistic point of view” and the teleological character of his explanation. For Wieser, it is clear that the final form of money that emerges is not the mere result of “the individual aims of leaders whom the masses follow” (ibid., p. 165), because the process of emergence of money releases a power that produces results far beyond those set by the masses or desired by the leaders:
Money represents something more and stronger than the will of participating individuals. A money for which a mass habit of acceptance has once been established is no longer the mere result of the individual aims of leaders whom the masses follow. Neither in the beginning nor later did the leaders have in mind a social institution.… The final form of money is not a mere resultant; because of the universal social resonance that it awoke it represents a tremendous strengthening of their endeavors. (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967, p. 165; emphasis added)
This passage is a good illustration of Wieser’s institutional individualism and economic sociology. It helps also to explain his dissatisfaction with Menger’s method. As rightly pointed out by Ekelund (Reference Ekelund1986, p. 4), Wieser accepts the kernel of Menger’s individualist explanation but laments that he does not go far enough.
As emphasized above, the passage from the simple economy to the social economy involves the intrusion of power through social stratification. Under these circumstances, individuals do not act independently and do not carry through their activity entirely by their own will. Rather, they “act under the control of the more or less felt influence of the natural controls or compulsion that give them the power or force them to decision” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967, p. 166). This implies that, for Wieser, the process of the emergence of money does not only consist of a change in the technique of exchange—i.e., the passage from barter to indirect exchange—but also involves social dynamics that modify the structure of the society and therefore individual behaviors.
Geoffrey Hodgson (Reference Hodgson1992), referring to Warren Mitchell (Reference Mitchell1937, pp. 175–176 and pp. 305–306), expresses a similar view that “[t]he penetration of money exchange into social life alter[s] the very configurations of rationality, involving the particular conceptions of abstraction, measurement, quantification and calculation intent. It [is] thus a transformation of individuals rather than simply the emergence of institutions and rules” (Hodgson Reference Hodgson1992, p. 407).
By the same token, this explains Wieser’s insistence on forging a conventional concept of the objective value of money (i.e., the notion of public economic value of money) and its associated failure, according to his critics, to get rid of any causal psychological explanation. Footnote 42
More specifically, one can reconstruct how Wieser viewed the emergence of money by emphasizing the key roles of anonymous leadership and internal power for understanding the complex dynamics between leaders and masses. As already noted, for Wieser, leaders initiate a social movement whose outcome, through the masses’ selection, goes well beyond the expected results: “Only a part of the force that builds social institutions is directed by purposes; the final decisive mass-influence operates beyond the purpose” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967, p. 165). Moreover, we stressed earlier that Wieser sees the dynamics between leaders and the masses as involving “true following,” a notion we find interesting to compare with André Orléan’s (Reference Orléan, Gravereau and Tramman2001) concept of “self-referential imitation” as the kind of imitation that takes place when agents imitate, but, by so doing, create a social value or a convention that gathers some momentum and gains some autonomy vis-à-vis the individuals who initiated the dynamics. Or, to use James McGill Buchanan’s (Reference Buchanan1982) phrase, money is an example of an “order defined in the process of its emergence,” which cannot be traced back unequivocally to the initial conditions that permitted its emergence.
Wieser’s recourse to the idea of “objective spirit” and the “law of upward mobility of classes” can be mobilized in order to understand how he conceives of the population’s adhesion to the utilization of money as well as the recognition by the leaders that it is in their interests to favor the diffusion of monetary practices in the economy. In current economic parlance, this would be described by the notion of positive feedback (Arthur Reference Arthur1990) or network externality (Katz and Shapiro 1985).
However, more importantly, the emergence of money is part of a general process of institutional change that takes place in historical time and implies feedback on the economic sphere. From this standpoint, institutional impulses “are entirely dependent [for the average man] upon the practice of his time and environment for their direction and their strength” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1927a] 1967, p. 159).
IV. CONCLUDING REMARKS
Certainly, as our reconstruction of Wieser’s conception of institutions through the example of money shows, Wieser’s approach cannot be confined to an analysis in terms of equilibrium states, since it is much more in line with the Schumpeterian notion of creative destruction. However, in contrast to Schumpeter, the process of congruence between leaders and imitators’ values and beliefs, which conditions the successful adoption of an innovation, does not necessarily converge into a better economic situation—i.e., a greater national wealth—except for the losses implied by the destruction of pre-existing lines of production. For Wieser, there is no guarantee of society’s better performance or progress. He refers to the “inner rules,” such as inertia effects or self-destruction mechanisms, that underlie the law of power. These mechanisms belong to the psychology of power, and constitute what Wieser refers to as the ‘supra-social’ or ‘anti-individual’ or even ‘anti-social’ character of power, which stands “in complete reversal to the law of success” (Wieser [Reference Wieser1926] 1983, p. 71). They contribute also to explaining the emergence of collective wholes or social entities that have acquired some autonomy vis-à-vis individuals. However, this holistic feature does not lead to neglect the role of individuals within social dynamics. Indeed, Wieser explains that personal strength is at the origins of the growth of power, but “by aligning itself with the strength of a like-minded individual, [it] is being enhanced way beyond its inherent potential[;] [a]longside it, there is a strengthening of the feeling of power, though at the same time strength in no small degree is being deprived of its personal roots” (ibid., p. 70; original emphasis).
By emphasizing the relationship of individuals towards their neighborhoods, but also towards the society considered as a stratified entity, Wieser is able to deal not only with the emergence of institutions, but also with the problems of their maintenance and evolution. For instance, Wieser points to the possibility of conflicts between a new historical task and existing historical powers (ibid., p. 203), or the existence of tensions regarding the sharing of power between the leadership strata and the stratum representing the masses (ibid., p. 52). In mathematical terms, leaving aside the well-known reservations of Austrian economists towards the use of mathematical relationships, these conflicts or tensions could be assimilated to path-dependency or hysteresis effects.
In summary, Wieser’s approach is more focused on institutional change than on the problem of emergence of institutions. He describes the process of institutional change as both the result and the cause of changes in individual behavioral patterns. This reciprocal causation between behavior and institutional change involves historical time but also positive and negative feedback.
All these arguments give strong support to an interpretation of Wieser’s conception of money and its evolutionary features in terms of a more sophisticated dynamics of social interaction than that proposed by Menger. In particular, Wieser saw money as a “socially constructed institution” (see Mirowski Reference Mirowski1990) undergoing permanent changes. Therefore, Wieser assumed a hierarchical or stratified society, in contrast to Menger’s assumption of a horizontally fragmented population. Wieser emphasizes also the roles played by internal power, anonymous leadership, and objective spirit in social interactions, in order to make a population adhere or conform to a social norm of exchange.
