This superbly written and deftly organized book provides a vast array of information concerning the mechanics of caravanning across the Sahara in the nineteenth century, the commodities traded in that period among the region's tribes, and the participants in their exchanges. It also identifies and evaluates the institutions that supported trans-Saharan caravanning. The institutional analysis in On Trans-Saharan Trails is of interest in its own right. It alone will make the book a standard reference for African specialists, many of whom will find the perspective an eye opener. But Ghislaine Lydon's interpretations are also of interest more generally, as they address historical controversies of universal relevance.
Like traders elsewhere, those who crisscrossed the area currently divided mainly among Morocco, Mauritania, Mali, Algeria, and Niger relied on networks that used sanctioning mechanisms to promote trust and cooperation among their members. However, the trading networks of the Western Sahara also benefited from the legal infrastructure of Islam, the region's dominant religion. Merchants and investors used Islamic templates in contracting, and they settled some of their disputes through Muslim-run courts that enforced Islamic law. Lydon's work thus calls for a reconsideration of theories that downplay, if not ignore, the significance of formal trust-creation and dispute resolution systems to the viability of commercial networks based on a shared religion, ethnicity, or geographic origin.
Another prominent theme of this book concerns the use of paper as a means of contract enforcement. Lydon shows that many traders of the Sahara documented their contracts involving long-distance trade. Yet these contracts could not be used as proof in a court of law; ordinarily they lacked legal force in the absence of corroborating oral testimony by reputable witnesses to their preparation. High literacy among merchants explains the former pattern, she suggests; written contracts facilitated the operations of literate merchants by making it easier for them to keep track of accounts and to communicate both with others and themselves. As for the primacy of oral testimony in Islamic courts, it reflected low literacy in the general population.
Although the Islamic legal system played an indispensable role in Saharan commercial life, it was not completely in tune with the needs of the desert's major traders. Nor was the implied inefficiency an aberration. On Trans-Saharan Trails offers additional examples of imperfect institutions. Certain Islamic teachings on commerce and finance conflicted with common mercantile practices, which suggests that in the Sahara, as in other regions of the world, Islamic legal discourse was in some respects constraining and wasteful. Indeed, in focusing the minds of religious scholars on the illegality of interest, and refusing to recognize its uses to borrowers and lenders alike, these traditional teachings misdirected financial creativity. Lydon deserves credit for reporting inefficiencies where they caught her attention. All too often scholars focused on a particular region lose objectivity with respect to the peoples and institutions they have chosen to study. In trying to understand the logic of Saharan caravanning, Lydon maintains a critical perspective throughout.
I do not mean to imply that this is a book about the institutional shortcomings of Saharan commerce. It explains many particularities of Saharan commerce as outcomes of coordinated efforts to minimize transaction costs. For example, debt swapping and traveler's checks enabled Saharan merchants to travel safely, lowering the risks of investing in their ventures; and written contracts facilitated the organization of their multi-local and multi-party operations.
Readers with a penchant for theorizing will find the book's explanations that presume transaction-cost minimization to be in tension with its observations of inefficiency. Why were some problems of Saharan economic life solved efficiently, and others not? The book does not provide an overarching theory capable of providing answers. I point this out not as a criticism, but to suggest that social scientists interested in the grand questions of social, political, and economic history will profit enormously from reading On Trans-Saharan Trails carefully. Written by a historian with a solid understanding of modern institutional analysis and of its applications in global history, it focuses on practices, customs, norms, and laws of great relevance to major theoretical issues of our time. Hence, theorists will find the book highly stimulating.
In addition to an impressive set of secondary sources, the book is based on primary data involving national archives, family archives, and oral interviews. Several case studies based on these data make for lively and entertaining reading about the commercial endeavors, social relationships, and legal disputes of prominent families and individuals. Scholars who read these case studies are bound to wonder how representative they were of nineteenth-century life in the Sahara. They may also wish that the book offered more quantitative data. I myself wondered about the literacy rate among merchants, the volume of trade in the region, and the share of Saharan partnerships that were intertribal or interfaith. Such magnitudes would have helped to determine how the patterns brought out in the book compared with, say, those of the Islamic Middle East. I hasten to add that the Western Sahara is a vastly understudied part of the world, where the systematic collection of socioeconomic data began much later than anywhere else. Perhaps the fascinating findings in this book will provide an impetus for the development of quantitative historical data sets on the Sahara, using advanced estimation techniques.
In educating readers about the past, the best historical books also generate new research. On Trans-Saharan Trails is an excellent book both for what it uncovers and for the questions it raises. Decades from now scholars in several disciplines will be using, but also seeking to refine and develop, its many fascinating findings.
