An anecdote from the sentencing procedures at Jeffrey Dahmer's infamous 1992 trial introduces Marlene K. Sokolon's new book Seeing with Free Eyes: The Poetic Justice of Euripides. Presenting brief and anguished excerpts from statements made by a victim's sister, Sokolon compares this reaction to that of characters in ancient Greek tragedy and argues that the scene highlights the contrast between private “rage” and “the calmness of court proceedings” (1). This tension, and more broadly the contradictions inherent in human reflections on justice, are the driving forces of the book's examination of justice in Euripidean tragedy.
The book is divided into three sections (“Justice in the City,” “Justice in Sacred Places,” and “Justice in the Wilderness”) and consists of introductory and concluding chapters, and nine main chapters, each of which examines one Euripidean tragedy (in order: Medea, Bacchae, Phoenician Women, Ion, Children of Heracles, Suppliant Women, Hecuba, Alcestis, and Electra). For each tragedy, Sokolon explores a range of discrete but overlapping questions of justice, including problems inherent in various conceptions of justice; the difficulty of evaluating what is or is not just; questions of how we should respond to acts of injustice, and who has the authority to make such decisions; and the role of justice in the realm of interstate relations. Rather than briefly evaluating each chapter, in what follows I discuss three chapters in some depth, highlighting strengths and weaknesses that, I believe, characterize the book as a whole.
Chapter 3 examines Euripides's Phoenician Women, a play that (re)tells the story of two brothers (Polyneices and Eteocles) fighting for power in Thebes, and the (yes, tragic) consequences for them, their families, and the community at large. As with each chapter in the book, ample space is dedicated to a summary of the historical and mythological contexts of the tragedy, the play's contents, and Euripides's innovations. From there, Sokolon explores the diverse conceptions of justice presented in a debate between the two brothers and their mother Jocasta. Polyneices, who has come to sack Thebes after Eteocles broke their power-sharing agreement, argues on behalf of oath keeping and merit—specifically his right to an inheritance equal to that of his brother. Eteocles, conversely, presents a “relativistic” notion of justice that supports his own refusal to share power with Polyneices. Jocasta rejects both of these arguments, counseling moderation, and Sokolon aptly notes that the scene “dramatizes [how] uncompromising self-interested justice ends in mutual self-destruction” (78).
The rest of the chapter focuses on the play's presentation of polarized notions of self-interest versus self-sacrifice for the community, divine justice as opposed to human law, and the various contradictions and complexities that lie within those arguments. As is true throughout, Sokolon's readings of the play are sound, and she ably relates the various arguments to strains of thought that emerge elsewhere in classical Greek literature and philosophy. Her final conclusion that the play illustrates “the potential destructiveness of a monoscopic view of justice” (86) is compelling. But as in other chapters, I found myself wishing that Sokolon would focus more closely on just one or two argumentative strands, rather than trying to tease all of them out at the same time.
In chapter 5 we turn to Children of Heracles, a play that dramatizes the question whether a city (Athens) should harbor and defend a group of refugees (the titular children). Sokolon zooms out and neatly illustrates how Euripides poses this as a question of whether a community should adopt a position of self-interest or one of altruism in response to outsiders. At first, the play appears to suggest that an altruistic response will yield long-term benefits, but as Sokolon notes, the second half of the play complicates the question considerably. As was his wont, Euripides picks away at neat narrative knots, with characters undermining positions they had taken earlier in the play, and a final twist that subverts interpretations that the play had previously advanced. Sokolon thus shows that “the line between justice and self-interest becomes blurred” (133) and that easy answers to the play's questions about how to achieve justice, and for whom, are rejected.
Each chapter makes some effort to connect the plays to contemporary dilemmas, and here Sokolon relates the conflicts presented by Children of Heracles to contemporary refugee crises. The connection is fitting, but Sokolon might fruitfully do more with it, and this is the case throughout the book. For example, in discussing the way Euripides's Alcestis explores the boundaries that should govern acts of reciprocal generosity, Sokolon notes that Alcestis's self-sacrifice “highlights the injustice of cultural expectations that women sacrifice their own self-interest for their children and husbands” (333n134). The insight is a valuable one, and might in itself be worthy of several paragraphs of discussion. Unfortunately, it is relegated to an endnote. In these cases we see perhaps most poignantly how much Sokolon can contribute to our understanding of “the poetic justice of Euripides,” but also how at times this book does not express her full potential in that regard.
With Euripides's Hecuba (chapter 7), Sokolon faces the challenge of approaching questions of justice in a play in which those issues are quite obviously central and have been treated extensively in previous scholarship. Her solution to the problem is thorough but at the same time essentially limiting. We learn of myriad issues of justice, including questions of merit, pity's role in understanding justice, and how power and autonomy (or perhaps a lack thereof) relate to justice. All these are certainly present in Hecuba, but in trying to deal with so much material, Sokolon must resort to summaries of both the play and modern interpretations, leaving little room for in-depth analysis. While this dynamic is present, to one degree or another, in every chapter of the book, with Hecuba in particular Sokolon gets bogged down trying to address every issue in the play, at the cost of truly illuminating any single one.
Ultimately, Sokolon's book succeeds in conveying the many, variegated, and indeed related ways that Euripidean tragedy explores questions of justice on the thematic and discursive level. Regarding her readings of the plays themselves, I tend to sympathize with Sokolon's conclusions, particularly those that emphasize the complexity and ambiguity of Euripides's solutions (so to speak) to the questions he raises. Impressively, Sokolon handles both the primary material and ample secondary scholarship with proficiency, while also bringing her background in political science to bear. The balance is a difficult one to strike, and while it is not always achieved perfectly, it makes for a rich set of analyses.
With nine plays covered in approximately two hundred pages, and with the need to both summarize each play and synthesize previous scholarly treatments of its main questions, the book is directed at and will be more valuable for those who are not intimately familiar with Euripidean tragedy and its reception. But even as a specialist in Euripidean drama, I found much of the book to be insightful, and many specific moments that prompted me to reconsider, or more fully consider, my interpretations of these tragedies.
