An inscribed statue base from first-century a.d. Iasos honours one Alexander as ‘Philosebastos and Philopatris, son of the People’ (I Iasos 84). Such titles, widespread in Roman-period epigraphy from Asia Minor, offer insights into the dynamics and mentalities of civic society. In this book, a revised Habilitationschrift, Anna Heller sets out to quantify these titles—when, where and by whom were they borne?
H. adopts an inclusive definition of ‘title’: any term used to define an individual in a laudatory manner, in any type of inscription (8–10, 58). Excluded are heros as simply a synonym for ‘deceased’, Roman titles of rank like clarissimus/lamprotatos and, by extension, civic titles of rank like bouleutikos (8–11).
H. has assembled a ‘documentary corpus’ of 21,094 inscriptions of all kinds from major epigraphic corpora of Roman-period Asia Minor, from which she extracts a ‘corpus of titles’ consisting of all 1,637 inscriptions that include titles (a total of 1,910 title-bearers or 1,763 individuals once doublets are removed). This is supplemented by a ‘complementary tally’ of all attested instances of philopatris, philosebastos, ktistes and ‘son of the city’ derived from word searches of the PHI database in the first three cases and from F. Canali De Rossi, Filius publicus (2007) in the last. The database is available online at euergetai.univ-tours.fr.
The compilation of this database is an impressive undertaking and nothing on this scale has been attempted before. By the standards of ancient history, the numbers involved are huge; by the standards of data analysis, they are not. Once the data have been sliced several ways, the numbers involved can be quite small. For example, philosebastos is more common for regular priests (7 per cent) than for priests of the Imperial cult (4 per cent), but the absolute numbers involved are fourteen examples out of 206 against twelve out of 269 (253)—how significant is this (especially as almost all philosebastoi are from Ephesos)? H. is alive to such issues; throughout the book, percentages based on small absolute numbers are greyed out and factors skewing the data are often mentioned.
Civic titles’ development is charted in ch. 1 (19–57). Although they had roots in Classical and Hellenistic ideas, the 30s b.c. were the ‘turning point’ when these ideas crystallised into a system of titles, their rise correlated with the decline in honorific inscriptions. Ch. 2 investigates how titles were granted and used. In addition to popular acclamations, titles were negotiated in the Council, or simply arrogated by individuals (58–64). They are primarily found in honorific inscriptions, especially statue bases, and about half of all localisable cases derive from sanctuaries or agorae (97–122).
Ch. 3 deals with geographic variations (123–206). Individual cities skew the data significantly. Ephesos contributes a quarter of all titles in Asia Minor. The second most common title of all, philosebastos (12 per cent of all titles), is known almost solely from there (150–1, 174–6). Most examples of the third most common title, philopatris (9 per cent of all titles), derive from early second-century Stratonikeia in Caria (167–74). Both these patterns result from individual types of inscription regularly erected at those cities. H. highlights other, unexplained variations: titles are unusually rare at Pergamon (148), virtue-titles unusually prominent in Lycia (181–2). Revealing these geographic variations is useful, but they raise the question of whether generalising about title-use across Asia Minor is valid.
This concern hangs over ch. 4, which uses the full set of data to investigate relationships between titles and individuals’ status, gender and activities (207–60). Gender gives the clearest results (221–42). Only 12 per cent of title-bearers are women—significantly lower than the percentage of women appearing in inscriptions generally. This is consistent across a range of cities. Titles differ significantly by gender; women's titles refer to their moderation and familial devotion far more often than male titles (e.g. philopator is borne by 18 per cent of female title-bearers and zero men).
H. also argues titles were not limited to ‘a restricted socio-political elite’. Rather, their ‘social diffusion was no doubt greater than is customarily believed’ (238–60). It is rare for bearers to hold multiple roles, the same role multiple times or to perform multiple benefactions. Title-bearers are attested in wide range of civic roles. This supports a reassessment of the nature of civic elites in Asia Minor generally (along the lines proposed by A. Zuiderhoek, The Politics of Munificence, 2009). It is not clear how much wider H. thinks titles’ social diffusion was and how far this reassessment should go. It is still the case that titles were overwhelmingly awarded for monetary expenditures, rather than service as doctors, teachers or athletic trainers, let alone for physical labour (247–52).
For scholars looking at individual inscriptions, sites, or regions, H.'s work will be an invaluable indicator of what is normal and what requires explanation. H.'s quantitative arguments cannot—and are not intended to—overrule qualitative arguments based on study of specific sites, individuals and inscriptions, but the reverse is true also. All scholars of the Greek city under Rome should consider them seriously.
