Published as a part of the University of California Press series of world history, A Global History of Gold Rushes is a collective book that argues that even though other commodities played a crucial part in nineteenth-century globalization, “gold stood out to the contemporaries for the dizzying velocity with which global connections were organized around its search” (30). It is consequently both an exploration in global history and a discussion about the specificity of gold in nineteenth-century globalization. This history is global in various ways: first, because it looks at circulations of people, techniques and money within gold rushes and between them; second, because it compares the phenomenon in different settings, although mainly Anglo-American ones; and third, because some of these histories look at the terrestrial globe through geology and the environment and try to address the role of “nature” in human events.
The book falls in four parts, the first one dealing with “Global Transformations in the Age of Gold.” The first chapter plays the role of a general introduction, explaining the various ways in which a gold rush was both global and local. At the same time, the authors acknowledge that gold was not the only factor of globalization, even in gold rushes, because other metals or raw materials were also pivotal in the revolution of transportation, for example, like coal.
Chapter 2 addresses the case of the California gold rush as the quintessential and mother of all subsequent gold rushes. Elliott West insists, including in the title, on the coincidence of the acquisition of California by war by the United States with the finding of gold in that area. Coincidence is not necessarily mere chance. As B. Demuth argues in the last chapter, a gold rush is made, is an encounter between natural and human factors. In California, the spatial history of Spanish and Mexican colonization and American immigration and imperialism mattered to understanding the chronology of the gold rush.
The three other parts focus on specific themes and most of them compare four main gold rushes: California, Victoria, South Africa and Klondike. Part Two focusses on settler societies and gold rush democracy, drawing on the political theme of how gold rushes were crucibles for political economies. David Goodman's article on “gold and the public good” is particularly interesting since he shows how an earlier gold rush in Georgia offered an alternative to the model of individual success and appropriation of gold with the idea that it should benefit the public (albeit a white and colonial one since the proponent of such an idea was also a promoter of Indian removal) and not only the individuals or corporations that could afford it. Mae Ngai's article explains how Chinese exclusion was global in the sense that it was voted and enforced in many (Anglo-American) places but that its meaning varied according to each political situation and played differently in the colonies and in England. She also shows that Chinese exclusion was less born in the gold fields than in political campaigns.
Part Three deals with the financial and speculative aspects of gold rushes. The authors make several points: there was more money involved in speculation than the actual gold retrieved; there were frictions between plans designed from far away and the local realities; and with the well-known evolution from individual to industrial mining, gold rushes became a matter of corporations and big capital. Thiesen's chapter is a welcome discussion of a failed project of engineering a gold rush in the Gold Coast as an alternative to South Africa.
Part Four deals with technologies, expertise and the environment. Isenberg reminds us of the dramatic environmental consequences of hydraulic mining. Tuffnell's chapter on engineers shows how their training, their experience and how they shared knowledge and techniques allowed them to connect dots between the local and the global. Their active role in gold rushes, especially in the early twentieth century, helps complicate the myth of the unskilled and spontaneous gold rusher. Demuth also contributes to this by showing how culture and geology intersected in defining the kind of mining society that would develop where gold was found.
This is overall a book worth reading not only for mining historians but also for scholars interested in the history of globalization and environmental, business and labor history. It is global in a way that should be more explicitly addressed since it mainly deals with the Anglo-American world. In that, the authors follow J. Belich and the growing field of settler colonialism studies, but it remains a problem to put Latin America and Eurasia (and other European empires) almost out of a “global history of gold rushes” without explaining or at least evoking the problem of why there were no gold rushes – at least no relevant ones – in these places in the nineteenth century.
