No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
Inventing Lebanon is a recent addition to a growing list of scholarly works that aim to historicize sectarianism in the Middle East. Kais Firro tries to go beyond the prevalent notion of primordial sectarian relations that supposedly dominate and define the region. In particular, he tackles a subject that many have considered the quintessential example of a historical sectarianism: the construction of a confessional Lebanese nation. Firro's main argument is that sectarian interests and affiliations were as much the result of the establishment of the “National Covenant” as they were the reasons behind its creation. He contends that the colonial creation of Greater Lebanon forced divergent ethnoreligious collective identities into a single state that in turn forced these communities to negotiate a modus vivandi to safeguard their interests even as it allowed for venues of cross-confessional cooperation. He holds further that the contradiction between these two aims underlies the uncertain nature of Lebanon as a nation.
In the first part of Inventing Lebanon, Firro looks at the idea of Lebanon as a nation; in the second part, he focuses on the political machinations that were animated by that idea as much as they gave it definition and life. The first chapter looks at the competing ideas that sought to define Lebanon alternatively as an eternally autonomous and uniquely cosmopolitan nation, as a part of a civilizationally defined Greater Syria, or as a small piece of an ethnically Arab world. In the second chapter, Firro leaps forward to look at contemporary scholars and their attempts to grapple with Lebanon's sectarianism. He explores how various authors sought to explicate Lebanon's confessional system and its persistence against the backdrop of the bloody civil war of 1975. Firro notes that explanations for Lebanese sectarianism fall into three categories. There are those, predominantly Christian, who consider Lebanon's confessional divisions of identity and power an asset that should be maintained as the underpinning of Lebanon's “uniqueness.” Other scholars, primarily Muslim, see confessionalism as a byproduct of colonialism that has distanced Lebanon from its “natural” Arab milieu and argue that only a return to that milieu will overcome the unnatural divisions even as it guarantees the rights of all religious communities. Finally, Firro notes a third tendency that argues that sectarianism is really the product of elites who have established these divisions to perpetuate their political or socioeconomic interests.
From this point, the book takes a completely different—and rather jolting—turn. Here Firro traces the development of the “National Covenant” between 1922 and 1943, the period of the French Mandate. He writes about the formation and dissolution of alliances among Lebanon's political elites along confessional lines, as well as across them for “clannish” or self-interested goals. For example, he recounts the attempts in 1930 by Émile Eddé to institute cuts in educational spending that would have closed 111 state schools. This decision would have touched a disproportionate number of Muslim students, since most Christian students attended private schools. In response, an Islamic Congress was convened—which included Sunni, Shi

i, and Druze representatives—to protest this discrimination and to affirm Lebanon's Arab identity. Yet shortly thereafter, during the 1932 contest for the presidency, Muslim and Christian elites crossed confessional lines to strike political alliances for “personal” and “clan” considerations. Thus, the Muslim deputies in Parliament rallied around Bishara al-Khuri in opposition to the Muslim candidate, Shaykh Muhammad al-Jisr, while Eddé and other Maronite elites supported al-Jisr against the wishes of the French high commissioner and the Maronite patriarch.
Firro elucidates a pattern to these vacillations. The initial reaction of the majority of Sunni Muslim elites to Greater Lebanon was to reject it in favor of an Arabist position that sought to unify the country with Syria. However, as it became evident that the French were not going to allow that to happen, and as the rejectionist position of these elites was undermined by Muslim figures from lesser families (urban and rural) who collaborated with the French, they began to negotiate a greater share of power within Lebanon. Similarly, some Maronite elites realized that their attempt to monopolize control over the country's political and economic resources were not going to be successful and thus began to negotiate a more conciliatory position that would reduce their power in exchange for guaranteeing Muslim support for an independent and sovereign Lebanon. Between these two polarities, the Druze, Shi

i, and Greek Orthodox communities sought to guarantee themselves some share in the administration and resources of the country through tactical use of confessional interests. The culmination of all these political “games” was the creation and entrenchment of the “Lebanese system,” which consecrated confessional politics even as it continued to allow for cross-confessional alliances.
The story that Firro tells in the second part is certainly as intriguing in its detail as the first part is a helpful summary of the historiography of confessionalism. However, one is hard-pressed to find the connection between the two parts of Inventing Lebanon. It is this disjuncture that weakens an otherwise good piece of scholarship. Since the second part of the book does not appear to engage the first part in any coherent sense, one is left wondering why the first part was included at all. Intricate details in the second, narrative part at times dilute the author's main point, particularly in the absence of a stronger analytical framework that would have given more meaning to the story. A more systematic connection between the two parts would have provided a meaningful critique of the existing historiography of Lebanese confessionalism, even as the story was given a greater narrative coherence and analytical relevance. Finally, it would have been more advisable to translate all French text into English to make the work more accessible to those who do not read French. The work also suffers from editorial mistakes that detract from its content. Despite these issues, I still recommend Firros's Inventing Lebanon to those specializing in Middle East studies as a good source for understanding the history of the creation of a confessional nation in Lebanon.