Quite simply, there is nothing to compare to this book. By and large a majority of American music scholars today pursue knowledge of the nation's rich vernacular music traditions, and for good reasons (e.g., traditional neglect by the discipline, the job market, personal experience). Scholars in earlier generations expressed more interest in American classical music, but none ever produced a comprehensive history on the subject. For scholars interested in the role and place held by classical music in the nation's history from colonial times to today—and given its importance in the big picture they should be legion!—Horowitz's work is more than overdue.
His history is sweeping and comprehensive in subject matter, newly researched but also appropriately reliant on solid, previously published scholarship (much of it by Horowitz himself), and lovingly and beautifully written—indeed, this book bumped Larry McMurtry off my nightstand, not the result of editorial pressure from afar, but because I just enjoyed reading it. Horowitz's majestic work (618 resounding pages) is finally here and is as close to definitive on the topic as we are likely to savor for a very long time.
Right up front (xiv–xv) Horowitz answers the big “Why?” questions. They are: (1) it hasn't been done before, (2) the topic—“orchestras and opera companies, their artists and operators”—has been neglected in the literature, and (3) the narrative has closure, for the “history” of which he writes “has largely run its course.” The hook barbed in that last “Why?” was baited in the subtitle of the hardcover edition of 2005: A History of Its Rise and Fall. This is a book of “history,” with all the implications of scientific objectivism that term implies, but also a book of criticism—“Rise and Fall”—in which the author takes on the protean task of interpretation: the book includes facts and knowledge, personalities and institutions, illumination and challenge, information and pleasure.
Chronology implied by rise and fall basically controls the narrative perspective, and Horowitz reasonably begins with John S. Dwight and ends with minimalism and postmodernism. There are other sightlines, however, which together allow for, and even encourage, artful measures of digression and recursion. For example, the volume is subdivided into two more or less autonomous “books”: “‘Queen of the Arts’: Birth and Growth” (through p. 262) and “‘Great Performances’: Decline and Fall.” Book One explores the antipodal tension between Boston, with its historic cultivation of aesthetic sensitivity, refinement, idealism, intellectualism, Calvinist restraint, and civic support for the arts, and New York's messy ad hoc multiculturalism, pragmatism, and market-based cultural economy. Boston thus produced polished culture that conformed to community-held standards of expression, which critics today generally accord second-echelon status; New York composers and writers fed off the city's dynamic regard for innovation and disdain for convention in figures such as Melville and Whitman, Ives, Dvořák, and Gershwin. Book Two explores how an elite cult of culture based on larger-than-life conductors and performers ultimately alienated middle-class support for classical music. By developing a matrix of intersecting chronological timelines and social survey platforms, Horowitz makes it possible to triangulate new, even surprising, understandings.
Horowitz's book contains much to admire. We now have, for example, a comprehensive, well-researched survey of the forces that controlled American concert programming over the last 150 years—how and why orchestral concerts moved from being capital-E “Events” featuring a range of music types, genres, and styles to becoming capital-C “Concerts” of a predictable “character piece/concerto/intermission/symphony” format with no discernible programmatic or educational relationship between the “movements” of The Concert. We now have a book that critically evaluates the writings of contemporaneous music critics and ferrets out schisms, perspectives, prejudices (great and small), styles, and substantial matters that both join and divide. This process showed me what now seems obvious—that these critics focused the lens through which we today comprehend much in American music studies and did so with such easy grace and skill that we believe the understanding is of our making. We now have a book that connects the dots between an olden time, when concertgoers thought that the performance was of the music, and today, when concertgoers seem to believe that the performance is the music. We now have an integrated, revisionist study of how key figures in the history of U.S. classical music (Theodore Thomas, Henry Higginson, Charles Ives, Virgil Thomson, George Gershwin, Arturo Toscanini, et al.) assumed special places in a highly complex social, cultural, aesthetic, even political matrix, how they responded to the pressing issues in their immediate musical worlds (especially compelling: Copland and Gershwin head-butting over “the jazz threat!”), and how their efforts gave shape and heft to the big story. We now have—even more impressively, in my view—a sophisticated, finely researched treatment of the cultural institutions (from orchestras to civic organizations to concert halls to newspapers to opera companies to NBC to management agencies, and much more) that gave shape, dimension, and definition to the landscape on which the giants (and dwarfs) in our musical midst toiled and trod. Classical Music in America is not a day hike, for there are swift braided streams, billowing tempests, mountains, and floods to negotiate. But it's all so much worth the effort—just for the dawning.
Like all excellent work, Horowitz's book prompts new questions and identifies lacunae in our understanding. Some of these are relatively minor and some mere quibbles. Such as: “What? No mention of the Louisville Symphony Orchestra and its historic performances and recordings in the 1950s and 1960s of new orchestral compositions?” Others are of more weight. The second paragraph of the book implies that “classical music” is orchestral music and opera; and, in fact, the book predominantly deals with these genres, with a wing stretched over instrumental chamber music on some occasions. Only the barest attention is given to song. In fact, song is problematic when it comes to its place on a style spectrum, with some vague notion of “popular” at one pole and equally vague “classical” at the other. But all the more reason to confront the dilemma. Was Carrie Jacobs Bond (1862–1946) a legitimate successor of Schubert, or a predecessor to Lennon and McCartney? (Or both?) Was Gershwin a classical composer when he wrote the Concerto in F but a Tin Pan Alley songwriter when he penned “Fascinating Rhythm”? (Or both?) Because Horowitz suggests (541) that attention to the nation's popular music might be the proper response to the unanswered question famously posed by Leonard Bernstein in 1973—“Whither music?”—and popular music is by and large song based, I would have welcomed a more extensive discussion of the historical, cultural, and social relationship of song, with all its ambiguity and liminality, to classical music in America, with all its ambiguity and liminality.
Then there is the problem posed by the “music appreciators” that get roundly (and deservedly) thumped throughout—insidious purveyors of an overly idealized canon of musical culture that have left most Americans today constitutionally incapable of serious involvement with classical music. In justice to Horowitz, the problem lies mostly with the field of American music studies, which has been generally negligent in paying proper attention to the matter, role, and place of “music appreciation” in our narratives of historical understanding. Music appreciation is an expression of a learned tradition articulated by academicians (or quasi academicians) and, as such, is a stepchild of an academic music curriculum that can be traced back to the first U.S. academic “Professor of Music” (John Knowles Paine, Harvard University, the patriarch of the so-called Boston Classicists), who took much of his mission and his curriculum from the first European academic “Professor of Music” (Eduard Hanslick, University of Vienna, the renowned advocate of an abstract, “pure,” and classical music). The line that stretches from Hanslick through Paine (and Horatio Parker, Yale University; read Charles Ives on what he thought of Yale's curricular imperatives!) to Music 100 today is bold, direct, and larded with “values,” “standards,” and regard for “high” musical culture. It is the popularity and ubiquity of Music 100 that has musically anointed the great unwashed. The benighted Appreciators deserve directed illumination, for their (mutant?) genes have been passed from generation to generation, and are as yet being propagated through the land.
Classical Music in America was first published as a hardcover book in 2005. The subtitle for that volume (A History of Its Rise and Fall) was shortened in the 2007 paperback issue to simply A History. Horowitz added an afterword for the 2007 paperback edition that deals in part with the title change and its implications: “‘Rise and Fall’ conveyed the misimpression that my narrative ended in a pit of pessimism” (548). Ironically, by retitling the book as a “History” and adding the upbeat update on “post-classical music,” the book is reframed as less of an objective history and more of a deeply felt and expressed critical polemic crying for visionary engagement with a larger, multivalent musical world by today's concert movers and shakers (whom Horowitz castigates as largely “music businessmen”). That the historiography is grander than the history is the work's strongest feature and contributes to its finest moments: passion and caring is manifest on every page. The meliorist Joe Horowitz, who is in full, often blazing, flower here, takes no delight in reporting on “the Fall” of classical music, a music he has loved and been long engaged with as artistic director, impresario, critic, and scholar—a life's work that has been dedicated to turning the ebb. That Horowitz believes the tide is now at slack leaves us becalmed but, rigged with Classical Music in America, eager for some ripping good musicmaking ahead.
