The ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights (AICHR) was inaugurated on 23 October 2009 as a “consultative inter-governmental body” with a mandate to promote human rights and fundamental freedoms. As its Terms of Reference make clear, the AICHR is premised upon a “non-confrontational” and “constructive” approach to developing human rights norms and standards in ASEAN. Its powers and purposes are “consultative”, “educative”, and “promotional” and its Terms of Reference emphasize the importance of non-intervention and the preservation of sovereignty. It lacks any semblance of enforcement powers or triggers for sanctions and has understandably been described by critics as a body without teeth.
Hao Duy Phan begins his book, based upon his 2009 thesis, by exploring an institutional theory of human rights, which holds that the extent to which human rights are protected depends upon the strength and integrity of the institutions established to protect those rights. He is particularly concerned to explore the extent to which global human rights treaties and other human rights institutions at regional level can influence state behaviour to improve human rights standards overall. He concludes that the weakness of the “lowest common denominator” approach to human rights at the global level “necessitates a regional approach of human rights protection, existing in parallel with the global system of human rights institutions” (p. 41).
Having confirmed that regional human rights institutions are necessary, Phan then argues that the AICHR in its current form is destined to remain, at best, a “modest mechanism” (p. 91). For Phan, what the region “really needs” is a “strong mechanism composed of independent experts who are able to investigate reports of human rights violations, consider individual complaints free from outside interference, and issue decisions that states are obligated to follow” (p. 91). There needs to be an authoritative interpretation and obligatory application of human rights norms by a judicial organ, “as no right is genuinely assured unless it is safeguarded by a competent court” (p. 130).
Given that it remains unlikely that ASEAN will create an effective human rights mechanism any time soon (p. 125), Phan proposes an alternative, “selective approach”, according to which the “leading and more advanced” states in Southeast Asia would take the lead in establishing a strong human rights protection body, along the lines of the regional human rights courts existing in Europe, the Americas, and Africa (p. 129). According to Phan's reasoning, “a regional human rights mechanism that starts first with more advanced states in terms of human rights delivers stronger human rights protection than an approach that covers all states its designers hope to finally include” (p. 129). Phan suggests that Thailand, the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, and Timor-Leste (not currently an ASEAN member) should be regarded as “possible founding members of a proposed regional human rights court” (p. 135), but does not assume that all of these countries or only these countries might eventually be involved. ASEAN member countries have a history of allowing two or three members to work bilaterally or trilaterally, while allowing other nations to join later if they wish to (p. 158).
While Phan's proposal has much to commend it, he makes no effort to consider his “selective approach” in the light of any political theories of human rights. At best, he appears, like Tan Hsien-Li in her study of the AICHR,Footnote 2 to implicitly endorse what has become the stock principle of mainstream Western political thought: the idea that industrialization and economic development (“modernization”) lead to democracy, liberalism, and the social conditions necessary for the realization of human rights. He further assumes that only time is needed before those nations currently not politically “ready” to join in the establishment of a strong regional human rights mechanism evolve in their economic and social development trajectory to the stage where they will be willing to join their liberal democratic brethren on the bench of a regional human rights court.
The strength of ASEAN's commitment to community building is one political reality that Phan fails to take sufficiently into account. Even when ASEAN has deviated from its collective approach, it has remained united in its determination to preserve the appearance of Community strength. Phan acknowledges that there “may undoubtedly be some drawbacks” to his suggested “selective approach” to human rights, in particular the concern that it may perpetuate a “widening gap between the two groups of states in the region in terms of economic development”. Moreover, some problems, including the most egregious human rights challenges, can only be addressed through the united action of all members.Footnote 3
Phan's study is a competently written PhD thesis providing close analysis of the development of regional human rights institutions. The reader is left wondering, however, at the wisdom of proposing a two-track system for the sub-regional protection of human rights: one for those states in the throes of development and democratization, and another for those which hold a different vision of the common good, or remain burdened by historical legacies of conflict and poverty.Footnote 4
