Phyllis Weliver's monograph Mary Gladstone and the Victorian Salon: Music, Literature, Liberalism examines Victorian salon culture through the lens of Gladstone's own socio-political, cultural, educational and religious background and thus makes a valuable contribution to both Gladstone biography and salon research. As socio-cultural institutions, salons had a huge political, artistic and scientific impact on nineteenth-century discourse throughout Europe. Their attempts at challenging social, religious and educational boundaries were welcomed by the (usually female) salon hosts, their regular attendees, and their fluctuating circles of visitors. Salons, in the broadest sense, are regular social gatherings in a private space that encouraged a wide range of activities: philosophical and/or political discussion, the art of conversation, music, poetry and drama recitals, dance, tableaux vivants, painting, board games and quizzes, tea and food sampling, and crafts. While some of these pastimes were regional in nature and/or depended on each individual salon's purpose and the host's preferences, it was the arts of conversation, music, and poetry which apparently were present at most gatherings.
When considering salon research to date, three problems emerge. First, music performed in salons is not primarily part of compositional history but, rather, is both reason for and result of cultural practice. Thus, music that was heard in salons should be considered within the context of cultural history rather than solely through the lens of music and/or compositional history.Footnote 1 However, a large part of nineteenth-century salon repertoire is unknown today and its examination is not always easy due to accessibility issues. Second, salon culture primarily has been researched with respect to such important cultural centres as Berlin, Paris or Weimar.Footnote 2 However, much can be learnt from the scrutiny of certain socio-culturally less sophisticated locations. Only recently have musicologists and cultural historians started to pay attention to seemingly less significant regions. These examinations have already proven that, within their own contexts, these centres had a remarkable cultural reverberation.Footnote 3 Third, many of these early studies have led to the assumption that salons were permeable spaces, open to members of all societal classes and strata. By way of contrast, Barbara Hahn posits that this notion is no more than a ‘mythos’ which is challenged by the heterogeneity of the salon landscape across Europe, and which questions the tenability of generalizations with regard to audience, repertoire and etiquette. To date, only a few individual salons have been researched in great detail, but those that have been examined demonstrate that aspects of accessibility and social permeability were based primarily on individual circumstances and cannot be generalized. For instance, Hahn argues that Rahel Levin's Berlin Dachstube (attic), an early-nineteenth-century salon, was much less culturally open and integrative than early scholarship would suggest.Footnote 4 In the light of these three aspects, there is an ongoing need for an analysis of salons in less sophisticated music-cultural centres, and for case studies of specific salons more generally, especially with a focus on socio-cultural implications for musical repertoire and performance practices in these salons.
With regard to British salon culture more particularly, there have been some general cultural-historical studies published in the past two decades or so, but specific details on individual British gatherings and their music-practical habits remain obscure.Footnote 5 Phyllis Weliver addresses this research lacuna in her monograph Mary Gladstone and the Victorian Salon: Music, Literature, Liberalism on three levels. A detailed case study, this book offers fascinating insights into links between arts and politics in general, personal connections that Mary Gladstone cultivated with specific cultural and political protagonists, and selected musical repertoire performed and conceived in her salon. The amateur pianist Mary Gladstone (1847–1927) was the daughter of the British politician William Ewart Gladstone (1809–1898) and his wife Catherine (née Glynne, 1812–1900). It was in the Gladstones' family home that regular social gatherings called ‘Thursday Breakfasts’ were held. Initiated by William Ewart Gladstone himself, the gatherings were first focused on his main interests, which included theology, politics and literature (p. 116). After his marriage in 1839, his wife took over the administrator's role, as she was a talented entertainer and organizer (p. 121). Their daughter Mary first participated at the gatherings as a discussant, and by the 1880s she had become the salon's hostess. Weliver's study of the Gladstone salon is primarily concerned with the 1870s and 1880s, a period during which music became increasingly important for this salon due to Mary Gladstone's own musical affinity.
The book is divided into two parts: Part I, Intellectual History, and Part II, Musical and Literary Case Studies. Each part contains four chapters. The first part approaches music in the Gladstone salon (Chapter 4) through the lenses of philosophy (Chapter 1), liberalism (Chapter 2), and salon culture (Chapter 3). On a more subtle level, the second part discusses Mary Gladstone's social activities within the contexts of the foundation of the Royal College of Music (Chapter 5), Alfred Tennyson's poetry (Chapter 6), and Gladstone's music criticism with reference to George Eliot's novel Daniel Deronda (Chapter 7), followed by a brief conclusion (Chapter 8). Weliver examines the Victorian salon on different layers, demonstrating the complexity of the salon as a heterogeneous institution that challenged the boundaries between ‘private’ and ‘public’. For instance, the author thematizes the divide between Gladstone's attempts at keeping the salon apolitical while still fostering political discussion (pp. 50, 126, 166). Weliver uncovers these apparent paradoxes by illuminating Gladstone's own life and the circumstances of her time through a multitude of sources: diaries, Gladstone's correspondence with family and friends, other significant protagonists’ correspondence, newspaper clippings, historical records (for instance, Keble College Occasional Papers and the Catalogue of Donors to Newnham College), music, and annotated poetry.
The first chapter, ‘Idealist Philosophy, Culture and the Gladstones’, provides a brief biographical contextualization and establishes that Mary Gladstone's upbringing was by and large determined by paternal leadership and by the liberal mind set of her father, William Ewart Gladstone, who served as British Prime Minister from December 1868 to February 1874, from April 1880 to June 1885, from January to July 1886, and from August 1892 to March 1894 (pp. 11–14). Such important influences as the Oxford educational system, in particular the Keble College Group and T.H. Green's Idealist philosophy, the church, and Mary Gladstone's role as her father's private secretary, are considered within the context of Mary's understanding of salon culture and social life (pp. 79ff). Weliver posits that Gladstone introduced a new form of socializing, which combined both her family's traditional literary/political gatherings and serious music-making (p. 37).
The second chapter, ‘The Passion of Liberalism’, grapples with definitions of liberalism and proposes a merge of liberal views and Christian values in the Gladstones' self-conception (p. 47). Music, according to Weliver, served as a means of communication, a pacifier when political tensions between salon attendees threatened to become offensive (p. 62). The salon was primarily attended by political friends and acquaintances, not all of whom, however, shared William Ewart Gladstone's enthusiasm for liberalism (Arthur Balfour, for instance, joined the Conservative Party in the late 1870s). Despite political discrepancies Gladstone's gatherings created a sense of mutual understanding by foregrounding such shared interests as music, literature and painting (attendees who helped to foster this atmosphere include, for example, the poets Robert Browning, Alfred Tennyson and his son Hallam, the composer George W. Macfarren, the actor J.L. Toole, the painter Edward Burne-Jones (all p. 62), the composer Alexander Campbell Mackenzie, and the opera company founder Carl Rosa (both p. 130).
The third chapter is more specifically on the Victorian Salon. It is somewhat puzzling when Weliver claims that, besides a few studies of British musical salons, ‘musicologists have examined musical salons in France, America and Spain, too, but they ignore ideas of the “social”’ (p. 89). To a certain extent, this may be true for America and Spain; however, much scholarship has been devoted to social aspects of French and German private music-cultural practice, for example.Footnote 6 Weliver then explains that Mendelssohn's Sonntagsmusiken turned Leipzig into an attractive centre for British composers and musicians due to Felix Mendelssohn's presence in that city. Felix Mendelssohn certainly did gather many international musical protagonists in Leipzig, where he resided from 1835–41 and again from September 1845 until his death in 1847. However, it was Mendelssohn's sister, Fanny Hensel, who entertained the Sonntagsmusiken in her home in Berlin (p. 93). Mendelssohn participated at his sister's musicales whenever he was in Berlin, and it is true that many mutual friends of the Mendelssohns who first met Felix in Leipzig would then travel to Berlin to visit Fanny and vice versa. However, the connection between Felix Mendelssohn's years in Leipzig and the Sonntagsmusiken, footnoted as ‘his salons’, is not immediately clear here.Footnote 7 This confusion is a little disappointing, as Hensel's gathering must be one of the best-documented gatherings and has been researched by many German-language and, more recently, by English-language scholars.Footnote 8
Weliver then depicts liberal features in both salon culture and Gladstone's salon in particular. She discusses the specific format and structure of Gladstone's gatherings, including themes, times, visitors, games, joint travels to galleries or lectures, and some aspects of repertoire (pp. 112ff). These details are fascinating, as they help to create a clearer picture of the regularity and nature of social life fostered by Gladstone.
Chapter 4, the concluding chapter of Part I, provides further details on music in Gladstone's salon. Most engagingly, it addresses fundamental questions centring on musical experience, etiquette and listening habits (pp. 125ff) while connecting aspects of private musical culture with public performance in the concert hall. Weliver argues that salon culture developed in correspondence with the changing musical taste on London's concert stages, a compelling idea, considering that the boundaries between public and private, and between amateurism and professionalism became increasingly blurry in the nineteenth-century European salon (p. 127).Footnote 9 An entire section is devoted to Mary Gladstone's musical analysis in her diary; here, Weliver's ambition to let the sources speak for themselves surfaces beautifully, as this section includes a large number of direct quotations as well as two images showing excerpts from the diary.
Part II includes three in-depth case studies, all of which approach Gladstone's social circles from a unique perspective. The first, on the Royal College of Music, offers an analytical excursion into life-writing practices and their implications for historians. Here, Weliver reflects on her own methodology and comments on the antagonism between privacy and public knowledge when analysing someone's diary. She explains that ‘privacy here means that space between what the diarist knows and what the audience reads; the diarist creates privacy by limiting her penned confidences’ (p. 176). It is these small asides which are of immense value on a larger intellectual scale that distinguish Weliver's book from other (less critical) publications on salon culture. Weliver then builds this chapter around the axes of private writing, social writing and relational writing, an approach which helps to understand the intersections of Gladstone's private social circles and her public musical engagement.
The next chapter is on Alfred Tennyson's salon readings. Tennyson attended Gladstone's salon and his poetry was discussed there. Through an examination of the composer Hubert Parry's annotated copy of Tennyson's poetry, Weliver uncovers characteristics of Gladstone's salon: first, she draws a link between music and poetry by analysing the recital aesthetics, through which she reconstructs concrete examples of what type of repertoire was performed at the Gladstones's. Second, she emphasizes the salon's potential to enable artistic innovation between poets and composers. And third, by unveiling Tennyson's own autobiographical documents, Weliver stresses the poet's desire to have his poetry set to music, which enables an aesthetic evaluation of text settings (pp. 207ff). Here, Weliver devotes a captivating section to Tennyson's phonograph, which demonstrates wonderfully how new technology had an impact on private music-cultural practice in the late nineteenth century (pp. 219ff). Lastly, Weliver offers an in-depth analysis of a selection of Emily Tennyson's settings of her husband's words; unfortunately, no musical examples are included here. Rather, Weliver footnotes her own work on Tennyson's songs – quite possibly an entrancing point of enquiry in the future (p. 224).
The last chapter, on music criticism and George Eliot's novel Daniel Deronda, concludes that Daniel Deronda inspired Mary Gladstone's own music criticism, and that in both the novel and in Gladstone's home, music, literature, and politics merged to one form of social interaction (p. 269). Weliver bases her analysis on music-critical passages in Gladstone's diary and correspondence. What is most interesting here (and throughout the book) is the comparison with other gatherings, for instance those of Sir Mountstuart Grant Duff (p. 112), the Prussian Ambassador, the Chevalier de Bunsen (p. 125), Alfred Tennyson (p. 171), and Charlotte and Ignaz Moscheles (p. 241). While it was not Weliver's aim to explore those other gatherings at great depth, their mention contextualizes Gladstone's salon within its own socio-musical world.
Weliver's book invites further studies of these rather unknown salons, as well as the repertoire which was performed there. Moreover, some details concerning Gladstone's musical taste call for further attention. For instance, a short section at the end of Chapter 2, ‘Liberalism and Music’, reveals that Gladstone liked Parry, Handel and Wagner (p. 82) – admittedly an odd combination which, in itself, might warrant a whole book. Weliver's study also brings to light some unknown composers: Maude Valérie White, who performed her songs with Sophie Robertson in Gladstone's home (p. 87), Fabio Campana (p. 136), and Emily Tennyson (p. 223), to name but a few.
The book includes eight illustrations and the layout is unconventional: the left margins are huge, allowing for ample annotations by the reader. Sometimes two footnotes appear in the same line, depending on length, which can be confusing at first. The thinness of the paper creates a strong bleed, but everyone will agree that a book's paper quality and layout should not determine the way its content is digested. Weliver uses many abbreviations throughout the book (for instance, GOM for ‘Grand Old Man’, meaning Mary Gladstone's father, William Ewart Gladstone), which may require a good memory on the reader's end. An overview of abbreviations is included at the beginning of the book, which provides useful guidance. Despite these small points of criticism, I recommend this book wholeheartedly to everyone who has an interest in the socio-cultural history of the salon, women in (musical) society, and/or Victorian history more generally. The book may seem complex in places and some background reading may be required. However, when read meticulously, it demonstrates beautifully how salon culture and private performance are interwoven with concepts and contexts of public music-making, socio-politics, literature, technology, and biography.
