A short answer to the above question is this. Simon de Montfort was by origin a minor French noble who went on to become one of the leading English magnates of the thirteenth century and the brother-in-law of King Henry III. He was first the close friend of the king and later his bitter enemy. He was a devout Christian, a crusader and a kindred spirit to scholars and bishops; but he was also a grasping landlord and an unscrupulous politician. Many people saw him as hero and a holy man, many others as a tyrant and a troublemaker. He played a leading role in the movement of baronial opposition to the crown which began in 1258 and which took over the country's government in a revolutionary way. He died in battle, fighting (as he would have said) for the same cause, at Evesham in Worcestershire on 4 August 1265. Those are some of the features of his life and career, of what he was and did. What he was not, contrary to popular historical folklore, was the founder of the English parliament.Footnote 1
We could reasonably ask whether Montfort was a good man or a bad man, a saint or a sinner. We are justified in asking these judgemental questions, of a sort which historians usually try to avoid, not only because they are questions which contemporaries also raised, but also because in Montfort's case they face us in a particularly obtrusive way. Their starkness is to be explained by our ability to know more about Montfort's character and temperament than about those of any other medieval nobleman. Historians can rarely assess medieval character except in the case of kings and churchmen: kings because they were the focus of public attention and the interests of chroniclers, churchmen because they often expressed themselves through their writings. But with almost all members of the medieval nobility, character and personality are very largely obscure. When historians try to construe character, they usually have to fall back on bland generalities. Because character is so difficult to elucidate, the listing of attributes has to do duty instead: nobles are ‘powerful’, ‘wealthy’, ‘chivalric’, ‘influential’ and so on. But whether these men were good humoured or bad tempered, kind or callous, clever or stupid, devoted or detached husbands and fathers, we can hardly ever know. Montfort's example is different, however, and we can speak about him with a degree of psychological penetration equally possible, among his contemporaries, only in the case of King Henry and of one or two of his bishops. This is partly because he was at the centre of public affairs for much of his life, and therefore closely observed by some very observant chroniclers, notably Matthew Paris; but also because a large part of his family archive survives, including some very informal documents which provide us with a good deal of intimate detail – some of it actually in dialogue form, like the parts of a play.Footnote 2 In addition, his intimacy with a group of highly intelligent reforming churchmen reveals much about his personality through their letters, in some cases letters of rebuke as well as praise. This leaves the historian well placed at least to ask whether Montfort was a saint or a sinner (though not necessarily to provide an answer).
A survey of Montfort's career in England may help us to disentangle some of the contradictions which his character presents. Nothing about that career was predictable from his origins, which lay wholly in France. He was born about 1208, the second son of a leading French noble, another Simon de Montfort, whose family lands lay near Paris. Much of his childhood was spent in the south of France, where his father was fighting the Albigensians, the heretical enemies of the church. As a younger son, he had no particular prospects, and as a Frenchman he had no particular interest in England. What took him across the Channel was a family claim to the English lands of the honour of Leicester, centred on the midland town which was the location for this lecture. Robert de Beaumont, earl of Leicester, the last of the Beaumont earls of Leicester, died childless in 1204. His heirs were his two sisters: Amicia, the widow of another Simon de Montfort, our Montfort's grandfather, and a second sister, Margaret, wife of Saer de Quincy, earl of Winchester. In 1207, the Beaumont lands were divided between the two sisters. Amicia's share descended first to Simon de Montfort, Amicia's son and our Montfort's father, and then to our Montfort's elder brother, Amaury de Montfort. In 1229–30, Simon bought out his brother's claim to the lands and the title, at some considerable expense, and in 1231, he arrived in England to claim in inheritance the Montfort half of the old earldom of Leicester. Rather surprisingly, Henry III allowed the claim of this unknown Frenchman, so giving Montfort a first footing in his new country.Footnote 3
During Montfort's early years in England, his landed holdings were confined to the honour of Leicester. Although the honour spread into southern England, its core lay in Leicester itself and in the nearby demesne manors of Hinckley, Shilton, Bagworth, Thornton and Desford. Kenilworth and its castle in neighbouring Warwickshire, which he acquired from the king in 1244, later extended his interest in this part of the world. One of his earliest actions in what was now his home town has made him notorious: in 1231 or 1232, he expelled the Jews from Leicester. This act of zealotry, presented as one for the salvation of Montfort's soul and for the relief of the Leicester townspeople from the burden of Jewish usury, was very much in line with contemporary values. Even enlightened churchmen saw the Jews as collectively guilty of the murder of Christ, men who were a threat to Christendom and who lived by the usury condemned both in the Bible and by Aristotle. It is significant that Robert Grosseteste, then archdeacon of Leicester and later the moral leader of the English bishops, approved of Montfort's action. It was one which had no particularly horrific consequences, since the Jews merely moved to Leicester's eastern suburbs, held not by Montfort but by his great aunt Margaret de Quincy, coheiress at the time of the earldom's partition in 1207. To condemn Montfort as a rabid anti-Semite, as some would today, is to judge him by standards very different from those of his own age.Footnote 4
In the 1230s, Montfort rose rapidly at Henry's court and began to enjoy the fruits of royal patronage. He was a foreign favourite of just the sort whom he himself was later to oppose. The reasons for his rise probably lay both in his French connections and in his personal qualities. Until 1258, the whole aim of Henry's diplomacy and foreign policy was to regain Normandy, Anjou and Poitou, the French lands held by his Angevin ancestors and lost by King John and during Henry's own minority. Montfort's ancestral roots near the borders of Normandy might facilitate the king's ambitions, and his service and possible manpower resources might have a useful part to play in future campaigns. Perhaps blooded in the renewed crusades of 1226–9 against the Albigensians, even as a young man Montfort may have been in the process of acquiring the powerful military reputation which was to culminate in his later years of warring against the king. If he was not yet ‘the most sagacious of warriors’ which he was to become,Footnote 5 the general and field commander may already have been in the making. Combined with a persuasive way of speaking and a winning manner, these assets do much to explain Henry's high regard for him.Footnote 6
The culmination of Montfort's rise to power came with his marriage in 1238 to the king's sister Eleanor, the greatest prize which the king had to bestow. As Henry's brother-in-law, Montfort was now one of the family, and, thanks partly to his marriage, a very wealthy one at that. Aged only twenty-three at time of her marriage, Eleanor was already the widow of another great noble: William Marshal, earl of Pembroke, son of the even greater William Marshal who had helped to save Henry's throne and kingdom in the civil war which followed Magna Carta in 1215. The younger William had died in 1231. As his widow, Eleanor was allowed by custom a third of her dead husband's lands as dower: in this case, a particularly valuable asset. Her dower lands in England alone, effectively in Montfort's control after the marriage, were worth about £550 a year, and there were claims to other Marshal lands in Wales and Ireland. Since the Leicester lands were worth only about £500 a year, the result of the marriage was thus to more than double Montfort's income. But here Montfort faced an uncertain future. The dower lands were held by Eleanor and her husband only for Eleanor's life and could not be alienated. At her death, they would revert to the Marshal heirs of her first husband. This prospect was a disturbing one, since it meant that the couple's large family – they had five sons by 1258 – were dependent for their future support on an endowment whose integrity would not last beyond Eleanor's death. The temporary nature of a substantial slice of his family's wealth is likely to have created the pervasive sense of insecurity which provides us with a key to many of Montfort's actions.Footnote 7
Both Montfort's rise in general and his marriage in particular were opposed by the English baronage. They saw him as a favoured royal intimate, a foreigner who had no natural standing in the country. In marrying Eleanor, he had not only achieved a position of supremacy at court but also removed from the board a valuable diplomatic counter who could have been used to advance the nation's interests through a different marriage and a possible foreign alliance. In the interests of an alien, Henry had fecklessly wasted an important asset. Yet baronial opposition did nothing to obstruct the road to fame and fortune on which Montfort's marriage seemed to have set him. In 1239, he was formally created earl of Leicester, with English lands, an English wife, and now an English title.Footnote 8 Then, unexpectedly and from the same source as Montfort's elevation, came disaster. A few months after Montfort's acquisition of his title, he and Henry quarrelled bitterly. Henry accused Montfort of seducing Eleanor before her marriage and even hinted that she had been pregnant at the time of their wedding. But more serious, and more certainly rooted in reality, was the financial basis of the quarrel. In the 1230s, Montfort had contracted a number of onerous financial obligations, caused in part by his buying out his brother Amaury's claims to the Leicester inheritance. These obligations were beyond his ability to meet, and in 1239, presuming on his position at court, he had named Henry as security for the repayment of a loan, apparently without Henry's knowledge. Already intending to crusade, Montfort had by now taken the cross, and the febrile atmosphere at court, the product of the grand falling out between the new earl and his patron, now precipitated his departure for the Holy Land.Footnote 9
After achieving little in the east except the establishment of his good name as a crusader, Montfort returned to England in 1242. But the old friendly relationship with Henry was never fully revived. Henry could not do without Montfort. Not only was he one of the family, but his range of contacts in France, and particularly at the French court, where by the 1250s (and perhaps earlier) he was on good terms with Louis IX, continued to be important for Henry's diplomacy. On the other hand, Montfort was never again quite trusted by his brother-in-law. He was more intelligent than Henry, and a far more effective and charismatic military leader, but also a man notably less mild tempered and more inclined to violent extremes. In 1248, Henry sought to make use of these qualities by sending him to Gascony, with a commission to impose order on what was a particularly disturbed and disorderly province. But the result was a steep deterioration in an already tense relationship. Once in Gascony, Montfort spent Henry's money freely and lavishly on building castles and raising troops. At the same time, he antagonised the Gascons by using the strong-arm tactics which he claimed were necessary to put down what amounted to terrorist banditry. When the Gascons complained to Henry behind Montfort's back, Henry undermined Montfort's position by entertaining their complaints and then putting him on trial at Westminster in 1252. The sense of injustice which his trial engendered was compounded by his persistent claims that his service in Gascony had left him out of pocket. Although it was inconclusive, with most of the English nobles backing Montfort, the trial left a residue of bitterness between the two men sharper even than that resulting from their first great quarrel of 1239.Footnote 10
Montfort's misgovernment of Gascony (as Henry saw it) marked a distinct stage in their association. What followed in the next few years took them further along the path to conflict. Their worsening relationship has to be seen against the wider political background of the 1250s: a time of increasing discontent with Henry's regime and of rising magnate and clerical opposition to his policies. The exercise of royal patronage was perhaps the primary cause of contention. Henry's promotion of his four Lusignan half-brothers, the sons of his mother Isabella of Angouleme by her second marriage to Hugh of Lusignan, count of La Marche in western France, was especially resented. Coming to England in 1247, the Lusignans had benefited enormously from Henry's favour, particularly in respect of the English lands which came the way of their leading member, William de Valence. As a result, popular and baronial hatred of aliens, and a concomitant rise in English national feeling, both of them factors in English politics since the reign of Richard I, now became increasingly marked, costing the king who was the Lusignans’ patron prestige and respect.Footnote 11 A parallel and socially more broadly based source of discontent lay in the fiscal pressure which Henry was applying to his subjects, particularly to the gentry and peasantry of provincial England. Henry's personal rule from the mid-1230s onwards had been characterised by personal extravagance, heavy spending on building (the vastly expensive rebuilding of Westminster Abbey began in 1245) and by grandiose plans for the recovery of his lost French lands. The result was a relentless drive for money, making for oppressive and extortionate government in the localities exercised chiefly through the agency of the king's ministers, his provincial sheriffs and the justices of his courts.Footnote 12 One final and crucial flashpoint lay in the question of Sicily. In 1254, Henry had accepted Pope Innocent IV's offer of the throne of Sicily on behalf of his second son, Edmund. Innocent's object was to induce Henry to drive the Hohenstaufen opponents of the papacy from their entrenched position as the rulers of Sicily. But as a consequence of his acceptance of the Sicilian throne, Henry became obliged both to send an army to reconquer the island and also to meet the papal debts already incurred in the war for Sicily. This piece of royal folly, directed towards an end which Henry stood no chance of achieving, left Henry's kingdom saddled with a huge financial burden, which fell largely on the church. The Sicilian Business, as it has come to be known, was one of the immediate causes of the revolution which began in 1258.Footnote 13
Montfort shared in some but not all of the accumulating grievances which Henry's government provoked. In particular, he detested Henry's Lusignan half-brothers. Not only were they his successful rivals in the competition for royal patronage, but William de Valence, their leader, had acquired through marriage the lordship of Pembroke in Wales, which Eleanor de Montfort claimed as part of her Marshal dower. Montfort's rivalry with the Lusignans exemplifies a broader truth: that until 1258 his antagonism towards Henry was more personal than political or constitutional. This was still more true of the financial issues which were the main cause of his growing resentment at Henry's rule. By 1258, when the government of the country was taken out of the king's hands, Montfort claimed that Henry owed him thousands of pounds. His debts had resulted partly from Montfort's service in Gascony but more especially from the intractable problems arising from Eleanor's dower. Besides her first husband's English lands, one third of which had been effectively settled on her, she also had similar claims on William Marshal's lands in Ireland and Wales, which had not been met. By a complicated process Eleanor had accepted an annual payment of £400 from the Marshal heirs in lieu of the actual land, and, at a second stage, in 1244, Henry had become the guarantor for the payment of this sum. By the 1250s, the king appears to have been defaulting on these annual payments.Footnote 14 In addition, the Montforts were claiming that the £400 payment was entirely inadequate as a true valuation of the widow's dower third in Ireland and Wales and that the sum had been inequitably fixed when Eleanor was under age and in the king's power. They went on to demand arrears of payment stretching back over twenty-six years and amounting, outrageously, to more than £24,000.Footnote 15 A related grievance lay in another of Henry's undertakings. In 1253, he had promised Montfort an annual fee of £400 a year, with the further promise that the fee would later be replaced by lands of an equivalent value. But in the mid-1250s Henry had little land to give and what there was went to the Lusignans, so providing Montfort with still fiercer grounds for resentment at the Lusignans’ position at court and at Henry's apparent untrustworthiness. If the Lusignans could benefit from Henry's generosity, why should the Montforts be excluded?Footnote 16
By 1258, therefore, the Montforts reckoned that they had been very badly done by and that Henry owed them a great deal, mainly in money but also in land. This culminating but protracted episode in the history of Montfort's personal relationship with Henry might lead us to suppose that the claims and grievances of both men lay at the heart of that relationship and that Montfort was little more than a self-interested party who used his near indispensability to the king to extract what he could from a monarch who needed his service and loyalty. Such a verdict would be to diminish both Montfort's status and the contradictions which his career embodied. On the positive side, it is clear that Montfort was a man of great abilities, powers of leadership and practical intelligence. The best evidence of these qualities comes in part from the regard in which he was held by others. In 1241, the crusader barons, knights and citizens of the kingdom of Jerusalem wanted to have him as their governor, while in 1253, the French nobles offered him the stewardship of France, in effect the regency, during Louis IX's absence on crusade. These were very high honours, coming independently from two different directions. Neither bore fruit, but each shows the wide range of Montfort's international connections and value set on his leadership outside England.Footnote 17 His special ability, and one which, as we have seen, commended him to Henry III, was military. One small example of his varied skills here comes from his rebuilding of his great midland castle at Kenilworth. So well fortified and stocked was the castle that in 1266, after Montfort's death, it was able to withstand a six-month siege, the longest in English medieval history. He was in all ways a man of weight, the Cromwell of his day. Yet his original position as an outsider in England, never completely forgotten, to some extent qualified his standing. Despite his putting down roots north of the Channel, his family home had been in France, and he maintained multiple contacts there, both with Louis IX, with the nobles of the French court and with his own relatives.Footnote 18 He was a cosmopolitan figure, with a range of experience in Gascony, France and the Holy Land which extended well beyond his English estates and which set him apart from the increasingly insular English nobility.
Montfort's weight was partly moral. He was in many ways a particularly devout Christian and a true son of the church, though he did not always behave like either. Medieval nobles are often described as ‘conventionally religious’ in their beliefs and practices, but Montfort's religion was more profound and heartfelt than this bland phrase implies. We know an unusual amount about his personal religious habits, since these were closely observed by his friends and servants and set down in the chronicles. He wore a hair shirt, the traditional underwear of the medieval holy man, and he dressed simply, normally wearing russet, the cheapest, coarsest cloth. Even in the company of magnates, he rarely wore scarlet, the most prestigious and most expensive cloth. He knew by heart the psalter and primer, spending part of each night in prayer and vigil, rising at midnight to pray, and using a candle clock to tell the hours.Footnote 19 Equally striking is Montfort's friendship circle. He was on close terms with a group of reforming bishops who formed the moral heart of the contemporary church. He was especially close to Robert Grosseteste, bishop of Lincoln, and Walter de Cantilupe, bishop of Worcester, both of them deeply conscientious pastors, and Grosseteste in addition one of the greatest scholars of the age. He had other close friends among the Franciscan friars, especially those of Oxford, the church's leaders in scholarship and moral example, and particularly renowned for their pastoral work among the urban poor.Footnote 20 Practice and experience, habit and association, all aligned Montfort with what contemporaries would have regarded as the most progressive elements in the thirteenth-century church: the crusade, the universities, pastorally minded bishops and dévot friars. Probably set on course by his early upbringing amid his father's wars against the Albigensians in the febrile crusading atmosphere of southern France, his piety may have been in part derived from the religious zealotry which characterised the lives of both his parents.Footnote 21 Like his claim to the Leicester lands, it was an aspect of his inheritance.
But it is at this point that the contradictions in Montfort's character become most evident. In his relations with others, Montfort was often rapacious and covetous, and the aggressive pursuer of his own interests. Here, we see the ‘saint or sinner’ paradox in its sharpest form. His sense of injustice at the debts which Henry owed to him was avaricious in its intensity, and in his relations with his tenants, and with at least one of the citizens of Leicester, his lordship proved to be unrelenting and sometimes extortionate.Footnote 22 He showed a good deal of self-knowledge when, according to a contemporary account, he prayed to be delivered from the sin of avarice.Footnote 23 He was sometimes rebuked by his high-minded friends among the bishops and friars for his harshness to others. Consistent with all these traits was his apparent lack of generosity and openhandedness. One striking omission from the contemporary accounts of his personal religion is their failure to say anything about the gifts to the poor which would have been expected of any noble. Nor was he particularly generous to monastic houses, often the main beneficiaries of charitable giving by the aristocracy.Footnote 24 Both acquisitive and tightfisted, he may have felt financially threatened by his partial dependence on his wife's dower, by the need to endow his large family and by his inability to secure from Henry the repayment of the money which he reckoned that the king owed him. But with an annual income which had risen to about £2,500 by 1258,Footnote 25 placing him among the richest half dozen of the earls, he could hardly claim poverty as an excuse for avarice.
We need to keep in mind these contrasting facets of Montfort's character as we move towards the last phase of his life: the period of baronial reform and rebellion lasting from 1258 to 1265. In 1258, baronial discontent with Henry III's government reached a climax and the mounting grievances of the previous years gave birth to a new political order. The promotion of Henry's half-brothers, the Lusignans, the oppressive government of the localities, the king's financial mismanagement and the extravagant stupidity of his acceptance of the Sicilian throne produced a movement of near unified opposition to Henry's regime. In combination with new divisions at Henry's court, leading former courtiers to desert the king, these grievances gave rise to a great baronial coalition which came together to demand a general reform of the kingdom. Montfort was a prominent member of that coalition, though he was by no means its sole leader. The government of the country was taken out of the king's hands and handed over to a baronial council of fifteen. Of this council, Montfort was again a member. A series of reforms, the Provisions of Oxford, were drawn up at the Oxford parliament of June 1258, which the leading barons and the king himself swore to maintain. These were later augmented by other reforms of law and administration, culminating in the Provisions of Westminster of October 1259, the whole programme being known collectively (and confusingly) as the Provisions of Oxford. The oath to the Provisions was to be central to the future history of the movement.Footnote 26
These measures constituted something like a revolution. With the transfer to the new council of powers central to Henry's kingship, most notably perhaps the power to appoint ministers,Footnote 27 the crown had effectively been put into commission. This was a quasi-republican constitution, even going beyond what had been attempted by King John's opponents in 1215. In essence, the new movement aimed to curb the king's powers of decision making, to reform the law and to institute a more just and equitable system of local government. Beyond these objectives, the movement had certain characteristics which served to define it. In the first place, it embodied popular as well as baronial aspirations. Promising better government for the localities, it was widely supported by the knights and country gentry and even by the peasantry. The social breadth both of political awareness and of political discontent in the country and the countryside was a factor on the barons’ side. But the movement was also seen as a moral crusade: one which had justice for its watchword and which sought for fair dealings between government and subjects. This moral dimension does much to explain the support given to the movement by some of the English bishops. It was demonstrated by one of the most unusual features of the reform movement: the attempt to apply reforming principles not only to relations between the king and his subjects but also to those between the barons and their tenants. In its early stages at least, this was not just a political rising against the king but an attempt to deliver justice on a much broader front.Footnote 28
What happened in the next few years is a complicated story. The baronial council survived until the last days of 1260 and for most of that time it governed the country. It gradually disintegrated, and with it the great coalition of 1258, because of the unwillingness of most barons to apply reform to their own estates, because of the bidding power of royal patronage, and because of an underlying conservative loyalty to the monarchy which had always been one of Henry's strengths. Montfort's course, however, was different from that of his timeserving fellow magnates. His guiding star throughout these years was his oath to the Provisions of Oxford: an oath which he could not deny without perjuring himself and risking his soul. A major factor which came into play here was Montfort's conscience. On moral matters, Montfort had a particularly tender conscience. Its operation can be seen particularly clearly in relation to his marriage. That his wife Eleanor had taken a vow of chastity after being widowed made him very uneasy, and his marriage was entered into, says one of the chronicles, ‘not without harm to his conscience’. This was the force which was now brought to bear on the politics of reform.Footnote 29
Yet Montfort's conscience was a selective instrument, one which did nothing to inhibit his pressing his private claims against the crown and which used reform to private ends. All through the early years of the reform movement he continued to pursue Henry for the payment of Eleanor's dower. The dower and the Provisions interlocked in complicated ways. In 1259, Montfort deliberately obstructed an Anglo-French settlement in an attempt to secure the settlement of his and Eleanor's financial claims, giving little attention to the enforcement of the reforming programme which occupied his fellow councillors; while in 1262, he published in England a papal bull confirming the Provisions only after negotiations at Louis IX's court for a settlement of his private claims had broken down.Footnote 30 Oath-bound to the Provisions he may have been, but the reforms also gave him a lever which could be used to private advantage. There were times when what was expedient and what was moral helpfully coincided.
The disintegration of the baronial opposition from 1261 onwards combined with Montfort's virtuous but judicious adherence to the Provisions to give him the leadership of what remained of the reforming cause. In 1262, Henry had obtained papal absolution from his oath to the Provisions, a coup which seemed to confirm his restoration to power and the overthrow of reform. The only way in which reform could now be maintained was through force. By 1263, Montfort and his followers, mainly members of the minor baronage, the local knights and his own retinue, were openly pitted against the king in what became a civil war. In May 1264, during the course of that war, Montfort won a great victory over the royalists at Lewes in Sussex. It delivered the king and his eldest son, the Lord Edward, into his hands and left him effectively in command of the country. Although there remained a dangerous periphery of continuing royalist resistance from the barons of the Welsh marches, this was the high point of his power.Footnote 31
In some ways, he used that power very effectively. In June 1264 and January 1265, he held two famous parliaments, summoning elected knight from the counties to both and burgesses from the towns to the second. What was new here was not so much their presence, for knights at least had appeared in earlier parliaments, but their acceptance as an integral part of the political community and their participation in political discussion.Footnote 32 Montfort's backing by a broadly based parliament was seen as a way of legitimising what was otherwise a thoroughly illegitimate regime, its power based on little more than victory in battle. In the autumn of 1264, Montfort's forces, supported by some prominent bishops, held off for some months a threatened French invasion and successfully challenged a papal legate who threatened the country with an interdict. Nor were the Provisions forgotten. They were published throughout the shires in December 1264 and enforced in the ensuing January parliament.Footnote 33 These events made Montfort something of a national hero – his country's leader against an alien power, the scourge of an oppressive monarch and the vindicator of reform.
In retrospect, however, we can see that Montfort was heading for disaster. He had replaced the king as the country's ruler, and although orders still went out in Henry's name he was effectively a captive. Montfort's novel access to the whole machinery of government and patronage now allowed full play to the acquisitiveness which had always been a central feature of his character. He used power to pile up a fortune for himself and his family. Many of the lands confiscated from the losers at Lewes were given to his sons. Guy, the fourth son, was given vast lands in Devon and Cornwall which had belonged to Richard of Cornwall, the king's brother, and another of the Lewes captives. Amaury, the clerical third son, was made treasurer of York, one of the richest positions in the church.Footnote 34 Victory had given him the means to endow his sons which his marriage alone could not have given him. His wealth brought him a huge following, seen in the 140 paid knights who kept company with him when he spent Christmas 1264 at his great castle of Kenilworth.Footnote 35 His obvious relish for power, its trappings and the opportunities for self-advancement which it provided in the end cost him much support. Yet what is more remarkable is that throughout this period so many of his followers, including those among the bishops, still stood by him. His rule was not entirely a one-man enterprise and he was evidently still seen to offer a better prospect of justice and good government than was likely to come from a restored monarchy.
Despite his apparent supremacy, in the late winter of 1265 Montfort's position began to deteriorate. The crucial step in his downward path was his desertion by Gilbert de Clare, earl of Gloucester. The only member of the higher nobility whose support Montfort had secured, Clare had become antagonised by Montfort's aggrandisement, by his failure to give Clare an adequate share of the spoils after Lewes, and by his treatment of Henry and Edward. In addition, he apparently raised the question of Montfort's alien origins, thus bringing into the open one of the ambiguities always latent in Montfort's position as an English magnate.Footnote 36 In combination with the continuing danger posed by the Welsh marcher barons (of whom Clare himself was one), Clare's desertion threatened to undermine Montfort's whole position. In April 1265, Montfort attempted to take military action against Clare and the marchers by launching a campaign on the south-eastern borders of Wales, but with an inadequate army. In the following month, the Lord Edward escaped from custody in Hereford and moved north to join forces with the marchers at Wigmore. The loss of Edward, whose military skills rivalled Montfort's, was the beginning of the end. In July, Montfort moved eastwards, crossing the Severn and hoping to link up with his son, Simon, whom he expected to advance to join him with an army from Kenilworth. But this tactic failed. Simon's army was surprised and scattered in a dawn raid on Kenilworth by Edward's forces. They then advanced on Evesham, where Montfort's little army was trapped in the great bend of the Avon which winds around the town. In the battle which followed, Montfort and his eldest son Henry were both killed, Montfort's body dismembered, the king released and the altar of the abbey at Evesham left running with the blood of those Montfortians who had vainly thought to find sanctuary there.Footnote 37 The whole experiment of baronial reform seemed to be over.
But here, appearances were partly deceptive. It is true that after Evesham Henry's monarchy seemed to have been liberated. The baronial council had gone, and with it all formal constitutional restraints on the monarchy, save those embodied in Magna Carta. Royal authority was restored. Although until 1267 there was continuing resistance to the restored monarch, in London, at Kenilworth and in parts of the countryside, peace gradually returned. Yet much had changed. Until his death in 1272, Henry ruled in a generally acceptable way. There were no in-groups of alien favourites; parliament was consulted about taxation and policymaking; the knights of the countryside acquired a larger place in politics; and the Montfortians were gradually brought back into public life after the débâcle of Evesham. Most significant of all perhaps, the bulk of the legal and administrative reforms introduced by the baronial council were given permanent legal force in the Statute of Marlborough of 1267. Montfort and the reformers had taught Henry the importance of consensus in politics and of ruling through a broadly based oligarchy of magnates and ministers rather than through a narrow clique of friends and courtiers. The same policies were followed by Edward I, the princely victor of Evesham, who, in the first part of his reign from 1272 to 1294, restored the legitimate authority of the crown in a period of brilliantly successful kingship. The posthumous Montfort was thus more successful than his bloody end at Evesham might have led any of his friends or enemies to expect.Footnote 38 He himself became the focus of a popular cult. Miracles were said to be worked at his shrine on the Evesham battlefield, and the sick and the lame travelled across England to seek cures there. So in the eyes of at least some contemporaries Montfort, though no doubt a sinner, was certainly a saint as well.Footnote 39
A final verdict on Montfort is difficult to reach. In many ways, he stands out as an adventurer. In his younger days, he had been very much a man on the make: a younger son, a foreigner with no background in England, driven by ambition, whose marriage to the king's sister gave him the richest prize imaginable. Both before and after the great political divide of 1258, he showed the same personal qualities of self-promotion and self-seeking. The internal tendencies evident in his rise to power in England in the early 1230s were equally evident when he ruled the country in the 1260s. Yet the idealist is almost as conspicuous as the go-getter, visible not only in Montfort's devoutness, his austere practices and his circle of high-minded friends in the church, but more especially in his defence of the Provisions of Oxford, the core measures of baronial reform. When almost all the magnates had dropped away from the reforming cause, Montfort stood fast, bound hand and foot in conscience by his oath to maintain the Provisions. In 1262, when the king was in the ascendant and almost all the barons had submitted, Montfort left for France, saying that he would rather die landless than abandon the truth as a perjured man.Footnote 40 He did not have to act thus. He could at any time have settled with Henry, submitted, abandoned the Provisions and enjoyed a quiet life in England. But this his conscience would not allow him to do.
We cannot therefore simply say that Montfort was a hypocrite. He was genuinely and deeply committed to political reform, which he saw as a sort of moral crusade and a matter of conscience. Nor, certainly, can he be acquitted of the charge of unscrupulously and consistently pursuing his own interests. There is no entirely satisfactory answer to the conundrum posed by Montfort's character, but part of an answer may lie in his capacity for self-deception. We might see him as the victim of what Dr Johnson called, in a memorable and moving phrase, ‘the treachery of the human heart’:Footnote 41 that is to say, the infinite ability which we all possess to some extent to delude ourselves about our real motives and by this kind of self-deception to confuse what we are doing for ourselves with a more selfless and abstract good. His pursuit of Eleanor's dower claims against Henry came at a time of ongoing political crisis in 1258–9; but was he not also seeking for himself the justice which the reformers intended to make freely available to all? The point is made still explicitly by one of the chronicles writing about the events of 1264–5 after the battle of Lewes. Montfort, he says, took personal control of the lands, castles and possessions of the defeated royalists because he foresaw that only in this way could he maintain his dominance until the Provisions had been finally secured.Footnote 42 The interests of Montfort, in other words, were the interests of reform. We may be sceptical about this interpretation of his actions. Yet it may well be the case that Montfort really did see his advancement in these terms and that he really had persuaded himself that reform was best served by his own promotion.
In the end, we should perhaps see Montfort as a classical tragic hero: a man of high abilities and intelligence, a master of men and a figure of weight and moral worth, who in the end overreached himself and was brought down by his own ambitions and personal failings. It would be foolish to pretend that such a depiction is in all ways psychologically convincing. But it is one mark of Montfort's unique position that there is no other medieval noble whose mind we can hold up to the light in quite so subtle a way.
