No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
Any ethnically, racially, religiously, or nationally mixed city is something of a gold mine for any social researcher. The research questions seem to emanate almost directly from the field. At the same time, however, it is usually quite difficult to make novel theoretical statements about such contexts. In her research on Acre, Rebecca Torstrick succeeds in doing just this by combining sociological and anthropological perspectives and research methods and by integrating micro and macro levels of analysis. On the theoretical side of her work, Torstrick focused her research on the ways in which personal and collective identities are employed, the process through which they undergo change, and the interplay between collective and personal identities as well as different forms of identity over time. She further examines the interaction between identity and spatial boundaries. The result is a piece of research that offers an in-depth understanding not only of the relationship between the Jewish (both Ashkenazi and Mizrahi) and Arab citizens of Acre, but also of the relationship between the Israeli state and its Palestinian citizens and the forms in which local inhabitants and officials of the city of Acre engage in dialogue with this relationship by translating, accepting, or rejecting it.
Acre is an old city whose history dates back approximately 4,000 years. It was never part of the biblical Israeli polity; nor was it ever a Jewish city until it was conquered by Jewish military forces during the 1948 war. Prior to the latest Jewish conquest of Acre (which was outside of the territory allocated to the Jewish state by the United Nations' Partition Plan), it was ruled by innumerable regimes, including the Egyptian, Assyrian, Greek, Seleucid, Roman, Byzantine, Arab, Crusader, Mamluk, Ottoman, and British, as well as by different local (Arab) strongmen. Almost all of these groups left some overt or covert marks on this ancient city. Before the 1948 war, the city was predominately an Arab (both Muslim and Christian) town. Following the war, most of the Arab inhabitants fled or were uprooted from their homes, and the city was populated by several waves of Jewish population composed mainly of new immigrants from North Africa and Romania and, in the past two decades, from the former Soviet lands and Ethiopia. Since then, the Jewish–Arab demographic ratio has reflected an Arab minority: Arabs make up approximately 25–30 percent of the population, with the remainder of the population made up by the Jewish majority. Torstrick carefully documents, describes, and analyzes both the tension between and the coexistence of these two ethno-national communities and the ways in which this has varied from period to period. She insightfully shows the ways in which different patterns of coexistence and tension were influenced by local factors and events as well as by exogenous occurrences and macro-political realities.
The basic problematic, which is discussed astutely by the author, is the self-definition of the Israeli state as “Jewish and democratic.” This dual collective identity is correctly analyzed as being a contradiction in terms, where the democratic value contradicts that of “Judaism,” conceived of as a mixture of an exclusive religious and primordial or racist identity. This definition of the state has far-reaching legal, political, economic, and cultural consequences for the status of the Palestinian Arab citizens of Israel, not only in terms of locating them in a marginal and underprivileged position, but also in terms of the ways in which it comes to be articulated in local and personal relationships between Jews and Arabs, even in situations where they have common interests. To this the author adds another aspect of the Jewish Israeli political culture, which she terms “security nationalism” (other Israeli social scientists have used the terms “cultural militarism” or “military-cultural complex”). This cultural orientation serves to construct any Arab as an actual or potential enemy. This is especially pronounced during periods of heightened tension in Jewish–Arab and Jewish–Palestinian conflict. This point is illustrated very well by the author in her recounting of an anecdotal event whereby a Jewish couple invited an Arab couple to a dinner at their home. During dinner, the national television reported on a Palestinian terrorist attack that had just occurred in Tel-Aviv. The Jewish husband declared indignantly, “All the Arabs must be killed.” In response, the Arab friend offered his Jewish host a knife and said, “Okay. I'm an Arab; take the knife and kill me”.
Torstrick further notes an interesting symmetry between the Jews and Arabs in Acre, and perhaps in all of the holy land whereby both perceive the “others” as illegitimate intruders in their territory. On the one hand, the Jewish immigrants were told that they were coming to the Jewish fatherland to be freed of the fear of gentiles and of persecution, only to find themselves among real or imagined threatening Arabs (especially in the mixed Wofson neighborhood). It is not surprising therefore that there was a high turnover of Jewish population in mixed neighborhoods and cities. Nor is it surprising that the “transfer idea” (i.e., ethnic cleansing of the Arabs) achieved such widespread popularity. On the other hand, the Arabs view Acre (and the entire land) as an Arab land and hold steadfast to the belief that, if they cannot turn back the historic clock, then the very least they can do is attempt to preserve their own identity and the Arab or Palestinian character of the city.
The central and most important conclusion of this book is that the very existence of a considerable Arab Palestinian minority of citizens within boundaries of the Jewish state not only serves as a point around which Jews grapple with their own Jewish identity; it is also used as a litmus test for the quality of the Israeli state's democracy, its regime, and its social tolerance. Overall, the book is an important, well-researched, and well-written piece of scholarly work. It is a pity that it was published in hardcover and is so pricey, since this usually serves to limit the circulation of important books. It would be very unfortunate if this factor hindered access to the book. It is highly recommended and worthwhile for anyone interested in issues of ethnic relations in Israel in particular, and in the Jewish–Palestinian conflict more generally.