Hongjie Wang's Power and Politics in Tenth-Century China: The Former Shu Regime is a solid entry in the field of Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms studies. The growth of this field in the past five years has been dramatic, if only because there was so little available in English beforehand, and not much more in Chinese or Japanese. Just as importantly, the new research in English has broken with the traditional view of the first half of the tenth century as simply a chaotic interregnum between great dynasties. Hongjie Wang's book continues this trend, seeing the period as interesting for its own reasons, particularly for the light it sheds upon major threads of Chinese political ideology like the Mandate of Heaven. He adds a new aspect to this ongoing discussion by focusing on the early decades of the period, and the rise and fall of the Former Shu (907–25) regime in Sichuan. Up until Wang's work, most scholars writing in English were either Song-dynasty historians reaching back to the later part of the period just before the founding of the Song, or, like Naomi Standen, historians comparing the period to the Song in order to describe changes in values over the course of the tenth century. Wang describes instead the development of a new polity out of the ruins of the collapsing Tang dynasty.
The Former Shu kingdom was created by a Tang general-cum-Sichuan-warlord-cum-emperor named Wang Jian. This fascinating character adroitly navigated the treacherous military and political waters of the collapsing Tang dynasty, and the no less dangerous shoals of the subsequent time of multistate struggle, to form a strong, prosperous, unified state in Sichuan. Wang Jian's accomplishments were made even clearer by the defeat and destruction of his state shortly after his death in 918. His son, Wang Yan, proved unable to manage either his own military or the political challenges posed by the newly installed Later Tang dynasty on the Central Plains. Peace had rapidly eroded the once mighty Shu army, and Wang Yan's literate and highly cultured court broke down into factional violence that alienated many supporters of the regime. The Shu army offered almost no resistance to the invading Later Tang armies in 925, and Wang Yan and his entourage were executed outside of Chang'an in 926.
Wang Jian was successful because he was not only a skilled general, but also a capable diplomat who cultivated the civil elites within his territory. Wang managed to “share” the Mandate of Heaven with the Later Liang emperor, by mutual agreement, and thus preserved the political ideology of the Tang without sacrificing pragmatic realpolitik. Both powers were happy to accept this construction since it allowed them to avoid a pointless conflict and to concentrate on more pressing matters. In Shu, Wang brought in many civil officials to manage his government, balancing somewhat the power of his generals and adopted sons, and winning support from local elites. It was an extremely precarious balancing act that began to break down as Wang Jian declined in body and mind.
Hongjie Wang has written an admirably straightforward and unadorned narrative of Wang Jian's rise and the creation of the Former Shu state. He neither overinterprets his sources nor unnecessarily complicates his account. He does, however, leave a major thesis undeveloped in the book. In the introduction, Wang emphasizes the need to examine the earlier part of the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period and areas outside of the Central Plains as a corrective to the current scholarly focus on the northern dynasties. Since he further argues that there was a more normal and balanced interstate environment in the earlier part of the period, this suggests that the Later Zhou-Song consolidation was a break with the established trend, rather than the culmination of gradual developments over several decades. While I might agree with this notion, I would have liked to see it fully discussed. If it is true, this would cause a serious reconsideration of the history of the period.
My only real criticism of this book concerns the consistently loose translations of Chinese passages. This is mostly a matter of personal taste, but I frequently found myself mentally straining to accept them as accurate. Wang's lengthy discussion of the Song bias of the historical sources was perhaps necessary when he was writing his dissertation, but the work of Naomi Standen has obviated this need. What is required now, though this hardly qualifies as a Five Dynasties topic, is a more nuanced examination of Song history writing. Surely the understood nature of the Five Dynasties had some effect upon Song political culture. Song history writing focused on the northern dynasties. Yet the cultures of the Shu and the Southern Tang strongly influenced Song culture, and it is worth asking why Song historians chose to neglect those polities in their writings about the Five Dynasties period. Still, Hongjie Wang's book is a good place to start thinking about the rest of China during the Five Dynasties period.
