A political history from the bottom up, Mining for the Nation dwells on a highly prescient subject: the articulation of a cross-class, multi-party alliance for broadening the exclusionary borders of citizenship. Its subject is the upsurge of Chile's Popular Front in the late 1930s, its grassroots expressions, and its breakdown in the late 1940s. This book was published in a year when a decades-long consensus between right-wing and centre-left coalitions in Chile was being seriously confronted by multitudinous demonstrations, out of which there appears to have emerged a counter-hegemonic structure of sentiment. After months of mobilisations, with the government's approval ratings and confidence in political institutions reaching unprecedentedly low levels, one of the remaining questions is how the gap between social participation and institutional representation might be bridged. Pinochet's 1973 coup against the Popular Unity government, heir to the Popular Front, signified the beginning of an age of neoliberal tragedy, and agreements, afterwards, which radically changed Chilean economics and politics. That cultural and epistemological rupture has created difficulties for both memory and historiography. As the dictatorship's trauma was followed by fear and silence, a long battle for memory has focused on state terror and/or popular resistance. However, stories and histories of the period from the 1930s until 1973, a period of an expanding state and growing popular politicisation, have barely been explored.
In Mining for the Nation, Jody Pavilack proffers a detailed analysis of this period. Based on extensive research in a wide variety of archives and a number of in-depth interviews, the author builds a narrative that intertwines communal, national and international articulations of ideology, politics and identity. Focusing on the formation of the Popular Front, Pavilack shares what appears to be a common trope of Chileanist historians from the United States: a certain notion of progress in the relationship between popular mobilisation, political representation, economic improvements and institutional legitimacy. In this sense, the author locates herself in a historiographical tradition initiated by Brian Loveman and Peter Winn in the 1970s and 1980s, and continued by younger scholars as Thomas Klubock, Karin Rosenblatt, Elizabeth Hutchinson and Heidi Tinsmann. Especially inspiring for Pavilack is Klubock's study on gender, class and politics in the copper mines. Focusing on the hopes and tragedies aroused by the Popular Front experience, the book starts with the Popular Front's emergence as a project of the Communist International and its regional formation in Chile's coal-mining zone, in the southern province of Concepción.
The combination of different levels of analysis allows the author to reframe some long-standing assumptions in Chilean historiography. Pavilack refutes at least three key myths. First, she undermines the notion that peasants' political rights were traded for right-wing support to secure productive state investments and improvements for urban workers. She shows not only that grassroots actors were worried about the fate of rural unionisation, but that industrial workers were themselves part of a rural-urban environment. Second, she argues against the conception of the Popular Front as a top-down agreement among political parties, determined by ‘foreign powers’, which left unions and popular sectors as passive followers. Finally, she denies that President González Videla's repressive turn was imposed by the United States in the context of an intensifying Cold War. Throughout the book, the notion of passivity – whether popular acquiescence in the face of institutional politics or government passivity with respect to international processes – is replaced by social and political empowerment at different levels, further complicating and so enriching the tales of dependency and subordination. In this sense, the book is in dialogue with Greg Grandin's work and other new cultural studies of the Cold War in the region.
Organised in three parts, the book starts by addressing the relationship between state, political system and labour movement in the 1920s and 1930s. The Communist Party's institutional will is contrasted with political turmoil and the permanence of repressive measures against peasants and proletarians. Pavilack attempts always to ground political processes in everyday politics in the coal-mining areas, looking, for example, at the tensions in town councils between representatives of workers and companies, both associated with different factions of national parties. Chapter 2, ‘Challenging Exclusion: The Birth of the Popular Front in the Coal Region’, is possibly the best in producing a fluid articulation between international, national and local politics. An exemplary analysis of judicial records underpins a nuanced account of the mining towns' environment, where rural life and labour were combined with the omnipresence of the companies. Tracing the genealogies and trajectories of certain leaders illuminates the mixed lines of identity, class and political conflict in the region. Struggles in coal mines and municipal halls paved the way for the Popular Front's triumph in the presidential election of 1938; this subject is explored in chapter 3, where it is analysed as the result of a shift in centre and centre-left politics of alliance, motivated by international anti-fascism movements, worker mobilisation and an erratic response by government.
In the second part of the book Pavilack demonstrates the strong linkages between social demands, international developments and state definitions. Even though there was a clear continuity in the state's use of force and appeal to repressive legislation, there was also a rhetoric of inclusion, citizenship and class conciliation which extended state hegemony while empowering working-class families. In the context of the Second World War and the first (and technically the only) government of the Popular Front, tripartite labour agreements favoured wage demands rather than workplace control. Although some historians, such as Julio Pinto, have shown that popular nationalism had its roots in the nineteenth century and did not appear among Marxist-oriented workers in the 1930s, the way Pavilack weaves her argument about the apparently unlikely combination of anti-fascism, pro-Soviet and pro-US stances, class-oriented militancy and nationalism is still quite compelling. Throughout part II she clearly shows how both regional workers and metropolitan politicians combined, adopted and shifted alliances and vocabularies, producing a political field where nationalism, internationalism and class interests determined an ever-growing and diversified pool of resources.
The final section, ‘Rupture and Betrayal’, deals with a shocking but unsurprising shift. Gabriel González, a close ally of the Communist Party and the first president to appoint Communist Party members to the cabinet, betrayed his previous allegiances by outlawing the party and persecuting its militants. The Law for the Permanent Defence of Democracy appears to be not solely a reaction to US pressure, but rather the result of a combination of factors. Workers' mobilisations were their principal means of political action, and the resistance of the political order to their rights as workers and as Chileans was institutionally expressed. Armed responses by the state, as well as the application of internal security laws, were not novel at all, but the new legal order added a systemic element which lasted for a decade. Workers' sense of betrayal led to mobilisation, mobilisation to growing fears on the part of the government and elite, and these fears to heavy repression.
It does amaze, in the light of the torture, confinement and exile of thousands of their number, that the Communists continued to trust in the viability of democratic transformations for the benefit of workers. The only answer suggested by the author seems to be that Chilean workers in general, and those of the Communist Party in particular, had expressed themselves in a highly institutional way at least since the late 1920s, bolstered by the fact that their efforts in constituting centre-left coalitions did result in social improvements. However, as left-wing electoral growth and a rise in unionisation and mobilisation led, as the author shows, to mounting panic among the elites, who dramatically resorted to repression as a response after 1947 and 1973, there is something still missing from the big political picture. As we historians are rather better at analysing the past than predicting the future, it would not be fair to demand an answer from this book. But if it is possible to respond in positive terms to the immediate question about the historical likelihood of articulating transformative political coalitions, unifying a variety of middle- and working-class demands, there is still another issue that remains open. If once again popular empowerment, inclusive citizenship and political participation end up being crushed by elite fear and the fury of the state, is there something that can be done to escape the tragedy that has followed those periods of renewed hopefulness?
