This pioneering work presents a historical account of Bengal's three major annual festivals dedicated to the goddesses Durgā, Kālī and Jagaddhātrī. With meticulous detail, Rachel McDermott presents the breath-taking panorama of celebration, social jousting and communal bonding that is characteristic of these autumnal rites. Her study illuminates the decidedly public context within which the evolution of the festivals takes place and how they have influenced each other over a period spanning pre-colonial to post-colonial eras, both in the sub-continent and in the Bengali diasporas.
McDermott's central argument establishes three thematic foci that reveal the contours of these inter-connected religious festivals or pūjās in their public settings: 1) the revelry that is their ever-present accompaniment; 2) the rivalry among the agonistic cultural contestations on display during festival days; and 3) the evocation of longing for, and re-assertion of, social bonds at a time when families and friends reunite and enact the symbolic narrative of the goddess returning for an annual visit to her natal home. These three general characteristics provide the distinctive rasa, or flavor, of the pūjā festivals. In a dazzling feat of scholarship, McDermott shows how this dominant tone has retained a consistency despite the continually shifting social and political contexts of the last three centuries.
One arena McDermott identifies as contributing to the unique flavor of the pūjās is the entwining of the performance of religious ritual with a competitive search for status and prestige. Another is where religious ritual participates in a larger interplay with, and mirroring of, social and political themes of the day. McDermott argues that these both have a common origin in the concerns of the urban, middle-class (and in earlier times, the landed gentry) that have been the primary shaping force behind the historical development of pūjā festivities. She claims that for this segment of Bengali society, “from the beginning, status and representation have been the prizes of these celebrations” (p. 160) whether in the field of cultural expression or martial prowess. The capaciousness of pūjā festivities that make them ideal occasions for the presentation of these concerns of the moment also contribute to their ongoing resilience. Both contestation and continuity remain twin themes accompanying the distinctive public dimension and grandeur of these celebrations. Moreover, as McDermott successfully shows, this is what has allowed the festivities to take root and adapt to very different sorts of environments in the Bengali diaspora.
This project is evenly devoted to studying historically the “elite” politics and foundations of the pūjā celebrations (chapters 1–4), the pageantry of the festivals, and their role as a theatre for the display of wealth and social debate (chapters 5–8) as well as collective cultural memory integral to Bengali identity (chapter 9). Although this scope is wide its largesse could not include, as McDermott readily acknowledges, an account of multi-sectarian experiences during the pūjās, especially with respect to Bengali Muslims who may participate in the festivities as a cultural practice. The divide between cultural identity and religious identity (not to mention class identity) is certainly complex here, as McDermott recognizes. Still, an analysis of this shifting boundary and its implications would have added an important dimension to the study, especially in the context of the overwhelmingly mixed religious identity of Bengal.
Additionally, the book's emphasis on the agonistic atmosphere fuelled by competing levels of pomp and ceremony—its revelry as rivalry, as it were—might also have included other facets of cultural life. Although the public spectacle and what McDermott describes as its “carnivalesque” qualities (p. 157) can certainly be accounted for in this way, what remains a question is how these aesthetically wrought presentations (the pomp and circumstance of it all) are specifically formational in their political and social concerns. Emphasizing the principal motive behind the lavish celebrations of pūjā rituals as status seeking leaves the ideational component out. Such an added consideration would place the aesthetics of the festivals, on the basis of which they were putatively produced and enjoyed, within the wider context of interpersonal protocols and even ethical practices or rationales as they obtained for communal life. This would suggest a way to treat these festivals as modes through which individuals are formed and interpolated into the structure of public life in a highly reflexive manner and place the pūjās within a wider set of aesthetic practices and ethical cultivations concerned with the body, the mind and the world. If the festivals constituted a sort of aesthetic and cultural power as McDermott maintains then the question arises as to what the nature of this power really was in multiple spheres of influence, not only that of competition through public spectacle.
McDermott's comprehensive and revelatory study of the complex and intertwined fortunes of Durgā, Kālī and Jagaddhātrī pūjās is an indispensable addition to the field of Bengal Studies and, more broadly, to anyone interested in the history of religious practice in South Asia. It promises to remain a seminal contribution to the understanding of the vital role religious festivals play in making history.
