This book is the antihistory of relativity. Just as in our peculiarly matter-based universe it is easy to miss the existence of antimatter, we have become so comfortable with the conventional history of relativity that it is easy to miss the rest of the story. Richard Staley's Einstein's Generation seeks to uncover the forgotten contexts of the traditional milestones to modern physics, and to confront those milestones on their own terms, thus showing them in a new light.
The book begins with the experiments that still launch a thousand anachronistic textbook sidebars: the Michelson–Morley ether-drift measurements. Staley argues that instead of focusing on the significance of the experiments for relativity (i.e. was Einstein influenced by them or not), we should try to recover Michelson's own experimental logic. We are given a detailed and fascinating account of the material culture and institutional manoeuvring behind the development of the interferometer, with the astronomer Simon Newcomb's behind-the-scenes influence emerging as especially interesting. Staley is persuasive in arguing that Michelson's experimental programme was intensely focused on the development of the instrument itself, and that the ether-drift experiments were ancillary. This examination of the material culture of relativity is extended to Walter Kaufmann's electron experiments, providing one of the first close studies of these.
These narratives help the book develop the argument that the emergence of relativity was dependent on much more than just conceptual advances, and needed to draw on both material resources and a particular disciplinary alignment. In a sense, this is a discussion of how Einstein was produced (thus the title's pun) by the changes in turn-of-the-century physics, in contrast to the usual picture of Einstein driving those changes. Staley shows that what we take to be the achievements of Einstein and ‘modern physics’ was far from inevitable, but instead quite contingent on various events.
This contingency is explored most fruitfully through an examination of contemporary histories of relativity written by Einstein and other scientists working on the theory. Staley argues that scientists use narratives of the past to make claims about the present state of their discipline and the meaning of certain theories. Was Einstein's theory an outgrowth of Lorentz's, or something completely novel? Did it emerge from experimental results or from mathematical reasoning? The answers to these questions were not at all clear in the years following Einstein's miracle year, and Staley deftly shows how these disputes were fought out through apparently innocuous historical tales. Einstein's role in the development of relativity, and thus the meaning of the theory itself, stabilized only when a particular historical narrative was widely accepted.
The importance of the past to the future of physics is also an important theme in Staley's close investigation of the famous 1911 Solvay Conference. This meeting is often pointed to as marking the transition from ‘classical’ to ‘modern’ physics, but Staley again argues that we must understand what those terms meant to the historical actors themselves. His sensitive reading of the origins of the term ‘classical’ and its connotations gives us a fresh perceptive on the significance of physicists marking off part of their disciplinary history under that heading. This section of the book is a story about how physicists reinterpreted their past to mean something very particular, and how in some sense historians have been culpable in going along with their narrative. The close ties between understandings of the past and claims about the meaning of physics that Staley uncovers are insightful and useful.
Einstein's Generation succeeds at rethinking the story of relativity's emergence. It carefully unpacks and redisplays the canonical events along the road to Einstein's apotheosis in a valuable way. For that very reason, the book may be difficult for those readers not already familiar with the conventional story. Nevertheless, the case made here for the propagation of relativity as the result of the interests and idiosyncrasies of a community, not just the brilliance of a gifted individual, is very effective. If it takes a village to raise a child, it takes a discipline to raise a theory.
