Globalized Islam is an important new book about a topic that still receives surprisingly little attention from scholars of Islam—how the dynamics and experiences that define contemporary globalization have impacted the Muslim world. Although focusing primarily on globalization's political and cultural impact, with largely superficial discussions of its economic dynamics, the richness of analysis and breadth of data make it a pioneering contribution to the literature on globalization and Islam.
Roy considers globalized Islam to be the result of the complex interrelationship of globalization, Westernization, and the increasingly important phenomenon of Muslims living as minorities in Europe and the United States. These experiences must be explored in a context where existing norms of religious expression and guidance have lost their authority, which has led to significant changes in the way Muslims engage their faith.
The most important aspect of the globalization of Islam is the evolution of what Roy terms “neofundamentalism”: a response to the “failure of political Islam” to offer a viable blueprint for establishing and administering an Islamic state. What makes neofundamentalism specifically “new” is, first, that its ideologues see globalization as “an opportunity, not a loss” to create a “universal religious identity” delinked from any specific culture. Second, neofundamentalism is most often a phenomenon of rootless and deterritorialized Muslim youth, especially second- or even third-generation residents of Western countries.
We see the evidence of this phenomenon from the growing popularity of lay Muslim preachers across various Muslim societies to, more negatively, the multiculturalism of groups such as al-Qaءida. The phenomenon is a result of two crucial processes: first, the permanent migration of millions of Muslims outside the dar al-islam; second, the “unhomeliness” brought on by the often unwelcome penetration of Western cultural symbols associated with globalization since the era of high imperialism.
This larger process has spelled the death knell for the Islamist politics of the past two generations. What has emerged in its place is the first post-Islamist generation, in which politics predominates over the religious (even if at first glance it seems to be the reverse) based on a kind of anti-intellectualism that often refuses to engage non-Salafi ideas yet offers a sometimes sophisticated critique of neoliberalism.
Paradoxically, neofundamentalism can also signify the “privatization of re-Islamization” (p. 97), symbolized by the spread of a kind of neoliberal Islamism of “new ‘Islamic’ businessmen [who] openly advocate the free market, see personal wealth as a blessing from God.” This finding is quite important because “neofundamentalism goes along with a belittling and deliberate diminution of the state,” which is replaced by a focus on reconstructing Islam one individual at a time. In this manner, neofundamentalism can help facilitate the very political–economic processes it seeks to combat.
Several of Roy's arguments raise problematic issues: the most important among them being how to draw boundaries between neofundamentalist and other types of Muslim belief or practice, and particularly the ambivalent relationship between neofundamentalists and Islamists. Indeed, Roy discusses a blurring of the divide between Muslim Brothers, neofundamentalists, and conservatives and the political basis of the choice of certain groups to use violence. As important is the need to clarify his understanding of culture. Neofundamentalism is a globalized phenomenon because it embodies in itself an explicit process of “deculturation”—rebuilding the ummah on a purely religious basis through a decontextualization of religious practices “from any specific culture” (p. 259).
Making this process possible is, for Roy, Islam's metamorphosis from culture to “mere” religion. Although he rightly argues that neofundamentalism “valoriz[es] uprootedness” through a focus on the individual believer (p. 269), his argument that religion and culture are in the globalized era two separate phenomena and that globalized Islam's “imaginary ummah” is “beyond ethnicity, race, language, culture, and not embedded in a specific territory” seems open to question.
The “passage to the West” is perhaps the key movement in Roy's narrative of the birth of globalized Islam. He argues that there is a “loss of religious authority” and an “objectification of Islam” in this process, which dilutes a formerly “pristine culture where religion was embedded in a given culture” (p. 151). However, no culture is ever pristine nor is there only one culture in a given society, as the conflicts within immigrant communities living in the same neighborhoods makes clear.
Whatever issue one might take with some of the book's arguments, their saliency was apparent in writing this review, during which time the 6 July 2005 London terrorist bombings occurred. Here Roy's focus on the impact of Westernization and secularization—the production of a younger generation of rootless believers who see their position in the West as transitory and have no stake in their societies, and their disconnect from established Muslim communities and their concerns—was revealed in all its richness. Indeed, that one might find much to debate with the specific arguments of the book is a testament to its far-reaching goals and willingness to take conceptual risks to begin a much needed (if necessarily imperfect) process of defining the terms that will in turn define the field of Islamic studies in the coming years. One can hope that this book will help motivate a much needed rethinking of terminology in discussing various religiously motivated Muslim social movements.
Globalization and the Muslim World marks an important contribution to the state of the art in scholarship on globalization in the Muslim world. Particularly because the research for the eleven contributions was conducted before September 11, it reminds us of the priorities of scholars right before “everything changed” and the priorities of many scholars naturally shifted toward the myriad of issues involved in the war on terror.
Indeed, the volume's chapters highlight the problems mainstream scholarship has encountered when theorizing globalization—first, as largely a phenomenon of the global North (when it has in fact long been indigenized in the global South), and second, in “trivializing religious activism” as a valid and modern form of globalized experience. The book's first chapter, Birgit Schaebler's “Civilizing Others,” proves this point with a discussion of how similar European and Muslim understandings of “civilization” were until the era of high imperialism saw Europeans reimagine the Muslim world into a backward and nonmodern region that, at best, was an object to be civilized. It was then that civilization was transformed from a “universal concept” in which all peoples could participate to one that at the same time signified several large-scale blocs of cultures and heritages that were differentiated by their position along the spectrum of barbarity and modernity.
Further expanding the notion of the breadth of civilization, Mehrzad Boroujerdi's chapter, “Subduing Globalization,” offers a powerful admonition to scholars in and of the West to pay greater attention to indigenous productions of globalized knowledge on its own terms, that is, without trying to reference or contextualize it within Western paradigms. Boroujerdi demonstrates, in a manner similar to the work of anthropologists Jean and John Comaroff on the “South–South” networks of critical theory, how the indigenization movements in the Muslim world belie the claims of many Western scholars that such knowledge is necessarily defined as “apologetic, chauvinist, essentialist,” and other negative traits.
Indeed, the idea of freeing “captive minds” has occupied a whole generation of Southern intellectuals. Underlying this belief are the dual insights that Western culture and social sciences were not the only valid models for Southern scholars to follow (or even the best ones). What is interesting is that this sentiment emerged out of the same suspicion of Western master narratives of universal rationality and value-free science that motivated post-Nietzschean theory in the West.
At the same time, however, the indigenization process is fraught with difficulties because it can produce a kind of “cultural schizophrenia” in which “religiously sanctioned social science,” for example, critiques modernity yet tries to fulfill the same social roles as modern social science. This latter point also emerges from Jocelyne Cesari's chapter, “Islam in the West,” which explores how the individualization and secularization of Islam as it develops in the Muslim diaspora of the West has sometimes led to a “clash of civilizations” within Muslim families, rather than at the “civilizational” level that is the focus of mainstream policy scholars such as Samuel Huntington.
What is important about the dynamics she discusses is how they reflect an increasing “universalization” of Islam through the seemingly opposed process of individualization and personalization of the religion. For those unable to participate in such a transition, however, Leif Stenberg's chapter on “Islam, Knowledge, and ‘the West’” demonstrates how the rationalities underlying the construction of new ideological relations to history by some conservative Islamists aim to construct a normative history to guide believers for whom the West (and by extension, many aspects of their home societies) have “taken a fundamentally wrong direction” (p. 103).
Part 2 of the book builds on the insights of the first part by exploring the long durée of globalization and then its reach into the most modern forms of media: the Internet and the “global muftis” produced by satellite television. Specifically, Heather Sharkey's chapter, “Globalization, Migration, and Identity,” offers a valuable discussion of how a seeming backwater of globalization, 19th-century Sudan, was actually a major node of global integration and movement of peoples, goods, and cultural symbols. Jakob Skovgaard-Petersen's chapter, “The Global Mufti,” reminds us that sometimes the figures and media who are often the most obviously “global,” such as Yusuf al-Qaradawi and al-Jazeera, are potentially not as interesting as other, less publicized scholars and networks, such as the Egyptian imam Shaykh al-Shaءrawi. The latter's program, on Egyptian television, is argued to be more “global” even as it looks more traditional.
Finally, Anne Marie Oliver's closing chapter returns to an issue—the “anxiety of civilization”—that was an important component of the earlier discussions of the volume. Her analysis of Hamas's supposed literalism shows it not to be merely a “deglobalizing reaction” to an oppressive modernity but also part of an attempt to construct a counteruniversalistic ideology that serves linguistic and aesthetic purposes as well as political and religious ones. Indeed, in a manner similar to the recent work of Palestinian scholar May Jayyusi, Oliver reminds us that spectacular acts of violence such as suicide bombings and the literalism they represent “always point to a subversive force at work,” whose aesthetic dynamics need to be elaborated in a much more sophisticated manner than has heretofore been achieved (p. 214).
Although she does not make this argument, it seems from her discussion that the allure of suicide bombings (and, we can suppose, the large-scale violence inflicted by the Isreali Defense Forces upon Palestinians as well) can come at least in part from the belief in the “genetically encoded” irredeemability of the other, and the danger of language whose seductiveness can lead one to trust an enemy who can only do one harm.
Globalization and the Muslim World is a useful volume both for scholars who are trying to ground their research in a different set of arguments and theoretical framework than that of mainstream debates on globalization and for upper level undergraduate and graduate courses on globalization and modern Islam. Despite being the product of a pre September 11 world, it should retain a high degree of relevance to contemporary globalization and Islamic studies for some time to come.
