John Lynch's engaging book on the life of Argentinian liberator José de San Martín anticipates the imminent appearance in Latin America of several biographic studies based on the lives of political actors also linked with the process of Spanish American independence. The increasing interest in this type of book is, of course, related to the celebration this year of the bicentenary of the independence of many Latin American nations, Argentina among them.
Not since J. C. J. Metford's San Martín the Liberator, published by Oxford University Press in 1950, has there been a book on San Martín by an English historian. Lynch's decision to write about the life and times of this prominent figure of Argentinian history is not surprising, however, given the fact that most of his academic work during the last four decades has centred on Spanish American independence and, more specifically, on Argentina. It is worth recalling that Lynch's previous work was a biography about the other great South American liberator, Simón Bolívar, published by Yale University Press in 2007, and it is therefore revealing when Lynch states in the prologue of the book under review that it was a much more demanding task to write about the life of San Martín:
We should judge [San Martín] on his own merits, not by constant comparison with the other great leader of South American independence, Simón Bolívar. Comparisons are invidious but inevitable. It is not difficult to write a life of Bolívar. Given half a chance he will write it for you himself. The historian has to defend himself against Bolívar and to preserve his own version of independence against the torrent of words with which Bolívar seeks to explain and persuade. San Martín is different. He lacks the style and panache of Bolívar, preserves a decent reticence about his private life and maintains a natural reserve about his role in the revolutions of independence. So it is a challenge for the historian, to bring him out and discover the man behind the silence (Preface, xii).
It is interesting to note that Lynch makes little attempt to indulge in the mythological dimension of his object of study. When Bartolomé Mitre decided to write his monumental biographies on the lives of Manuel Belgrano and San Martín, on the eve of the first centenary of Argentinian independence, he no doubt foresaw that both these leading characters of the emancipation process would soon be acclaimed as the most indisputable heroes of the history of their nation. In the case of San Martín, it is not an exaggeration to affirm that the consolidation of his image during the last century or so has transformed him into some kind of ‘untouchable’ for most people in Argentina. Since most of the latest works based on San Martín have essentially focused on topics related to the construction of the myth (Martín Kohan's original study Narrar a San Martín, published in 2005, being one of the best of its kind), it may sound somewhat paradoxical to suggest that the omission of this aspect in Lynch's book could be considered one of its most appealing features.
The fluent chronological narrative that characterises this study, which is packed with revealing details about the liberator's life and career, will surely appeal to a wide variety of readers. In this respect, Lynch's book is visibly in line with the legacy of the classic British biographical tradition: it is an articulate and detailed account, containing all the essential information on San Martín's life, which the author recollects from the numerous edited works on the subject, interwoven with his own comments and conclusions. The efficient manner in which this strategy is put into effect is clear evidence of Lynch's undeniable craftsmanship.
As was the case with his previous works on Juan Manuel de Rosas and Bolívar, Lynch's study on San Martín is essentially political and is therefore structured very much like those two biographies, a significant common feature being the several pages of meticulous descriptions of the political and social context that surrounded his chosen characters. In the San Martín book Lynch paints a clear picture of the state of affairs in such diverse regions as Spain, the River Plate, Chile and Peru during the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries in order to give the reader an idea of the range of complexities that awaited the future liberator.
Another notable aspect of the book is its successful attempt to decipher the main lineaments of San Martín's political thought, a dimension that has not received much attention in previous studies. The theme is central in the four chapters that deal with San Martín's traumatic experience as liberator and protector of Peru, as is evident from the titles of chaps. 7 (‘A Monarchist in a World of Republics’) and 8 (‘Liberal in a Conservative Society’). In Lynch's analytical speculations on this topic, the comparisons between the ideological inclinations of San Martín and Bolívar inevitably reappear. With regard to this specific question, Lynch concludes that ‘although the political thought of the two liberators was expressed in different terms, there was a striking similarity in their basic ideas. Both began with similar republican ideals. Both saw these eroded by circumstances’ (p. 224). Two paragraphs later, Lynch summarises what was, in his opinion, the main dilemma that tormented the Argentinian liberator regarding his ideological orientation: ‘his political thought was always finely balanced between a need for absolute power and a preference for liberal government. In San Martín's mind authority and liberty were indivisible, each a response to excess in the other’ (p. 225).
Like San Martín, many other actors engaged in the complicated Latin American political scenario of the time were confronted with the problem of adopting either monarchism or republicanism as the most efficient form of government in the newly formed nations. In this respect, Lynch hints at the truth when he stresses, in the conclusions, that San Martín's political strategies evidenced a complete detachment from the powerful political interest groups that were dominant in the regions where he operated: ‘Throughout his active career in America he was driven above all by political objectives and ideas. His only power base was the army that he himself created through his determination and organising genius’ (p. 226).
It is also in this last part of the book that Lynch makes brief references to the much-debated issue of the existence, or not, of a ‘national project’ in San Martín's liberating quest: ‘In this sense his strategy was Americanist rather than nationalist in inspiration, because American collaboration was the surest way to expand and complete the revolution for independence. These were strategies for war and revolution, not concepts for the future direction of the continent. His Americanism was left unadorned without a theoretical framework, or a comparative analysis’ (p. 227). Lynch correctly points out that, in spite of his self-proclaimed ‘Americanism’, San Martín never remotely contemplated any ideas of continental union, as was the case with Bolívar.
In conclusion, Professor Lynch's latest biographical contribution is a fluent and vivid portrayal of the Argentinian national hero that concentrates on the main highlights of his life, containing also a considerable amount of information as well as interesting analytical insights. One of the virtues of the book is the way in which Lynch succeeds in ‘humanising’ the figure of San Martín by frequently quoting a diversity of anecdotes and testimonies that reflect the doubts, contradictions and weaknesses that also formed part of his personality. This last aspect may be welcomed by many a reader, especially those sceptical and weary of the marmoreal dimension that all too often surrounds the image of San Martín.
