The republican theory of freedom (or republicanism) offers new insight into the importance of private property rights, the nature of homelessness, and the impact of laws that govern public property. In contrast to the negative conception of liberty as noninterference, republicanism provides a broader conception of liberty as nondomination, meaning freedom from the unilateral threat of interference by others.Footnote 1 Republican liberty acknowledges that the threat of interference undermines freedom even when individuals do not experience actual interference, and that individuals suffer domination when they are unilaterally vulnerable to others’ power.Footnote 2 Individuals enjoy republican liberty when they are protected against domination.Footnote 3
Domination exists in various forms, which can overlap and are not necessarily mutually exclusive.Footnote 4 Individuals suffer horizontal domination when they are vulnerable to the prospect of interference by others.Footnote 5 They experience vertical domination when they are unilaterally subject to risks of governmental interference.Footnote 6 And they face double domination when they are subject to both horizontal and vertical domination that may mutually reinforce one another.Footnote 7
This chapter shows how laws that govern public property subject unhoused persons to double domination for two reasons.Footnote 8 First, others exert control over unhoused persons’ opportunities to obey laws that govern public property.Footnote 9 Second, unhoused persons must make nonegalitarian sacrifices of their basic interests to obey these laws.Footnote 10 These two forms of domination – others’ control over law-abidingness and nonegalitarian trade-offs – are aggravated by unhoused persons’ lack of political and legal power. Subsequent chapters then demonstrate why the State has a greater capacity to regulate and police unhoused persons compared to people with access to housing, and to entrench them in homelessness.
4.1 The Republican Theory of Freedom
The republican theory of freedom emerged during the Roman republic.Footnote 11 It was revived during the Renaissance period and was invoked by neorepublican scholars such as Niccolò Machiavelli, James Harrington, and Montesquieu.Footnote 12 Whereas negative liberty theory construes freedom as noninterference, the republican theory of liberty construes freedom as nondomination.Footnote 13 Domination implies that others have a unilateral power to interfere with an individual’s actions, movement, or choices.Footnote 14 Individuals who suffer domination are dependent upon others’ goodwill to avoid interference.Footnote 15 Republican scholars associate domination with the notion of arbitrary (or uncontrolled) interference.Footnote 16 In the republican tradition, arbitrariness connotes that the dominated party cannot control whether they experience interference.Footnote 17 The dominating party thus dictates whether the dominated party suffers a hinderance to their action, movement, or choices.Footnote 18
Unlike negative liberty theory, republicanism accepts that a person is unfree when they experience domination without interference.Footnote 19 The prospect of such hinderances is thus sufficient to restrict liberty.Footnote 20 Domination without interference is problematic because an individual may limit their own freedom as a coping mechanism to avoid interference.Footnote 21 The individual may ingratiate others or act deferentially towards them so that others do not hinder the individual’s movement or choices.Footnote 22 The individual may adapt their preferences to those of the dominating party so that the latter does not block the individual’s choices or thwart their plans.Footnote 23 Or, the individual may abandon their authentic choices or pursuits to escape concrete obstructions by others.Footnote 24 Dominated individuals are unfree in such contexts because they depend on others’ goodwill or benevolence to avert such hinderances.Footnote 25
Historically, in the republican tradition, domination was exemplified by the relationship between master and slave, where the master holds a unilateral power to interfere with the slave’s actions, choices, and movements.Footnote 26 Negative liberty theory may construe a slave as free so long as the master does not concretely obstruct the slave’s movement or choices.Footnote 27 In contrast, republicanism acknowledges that the master’s power to interfere with the slave undermines the latter’s freedom, irrespective of whether actual interference occurs.Footnote 28
Philip Pettit notes that domination is present in a range of relationships that involve asymmetric power dynamics.Footnote 29 An abusive spouse may unilaterally interfere with their partner’s actions and plans.Footnote 30 A tyrannical parent may thwart their children’s choices.Footnote 31 And police officers have the authority to pull over drivers and question pedestrians at will.Footnote 32 Drivers and pedestrians, for their part, may comply with the police because they fear arrest, criminal charges, or physical harm.Footnote 33
Domination is different than interference in important ways.Footnote 34 First, compared to negative liberty as noninterference, republican liberty as nondomination places greater emphasis on the psychological costs of unfreedom.Footnote 35 Domination generates uncertainty as to when interference will occur, which can instill a sense of anxiety and fear in the dominated party.Footnote 36 They may become hyper-vigilant to better anticipate and avoid interference.Footnote 37 Or, they may debase themselves as a coping mechanism because they have internalized domination.Footnote 38
Second, in contrast to negative liberty, republican freedom incorporates a commitment to political equality.Footnote 39 Domination involves subjective, intersubjective, and objective components that exemplify subordination and rank-ordering.Footnote 40 Subjectively, the dominated party is aware that they are vulnerable to someone else’s power, while the dominating party is conscious that they wield that power.Footnote 41 Intersubjectively, both parties are aware of the asymmetric power dynamic inherent to their relationship, which influences how their view themselves and interact with one another.Footnote 42 Objectively, it is a matter of common knowledge within society that the dominating party wields unilateral power over the dominated party.Footnote 43 Philip Pettit remarks that in the republican tradition, free persons can pass a metaphorical “eyeball test,” meaning they can “walk tall amongst others and look any in the eye without reason for fear or deference.”Footnote 44 Individuals satisfy this test when they can live their lives and interact with one another aware that they are in “positions of relatively equal strength.”Footnote 45
Third, while negative freedom can be construed as a binary concept characterized by the presence or absence of interference, republican freedom acknowledges that domination can exist across a spectrum.Footnote 46 Republicanism affirms that different factors shape the extent of one’s liberty. Philip Pettit points out that domination can vary in intensity, frequency, and consistency.Footnote 47 For instance, a person can be subject to domination by some individuals but not others, or can experience it in some places but not others.Footnote 48 Furthermore, the threat of interference can constrain one’s freedom to act to greater or lesser extents.Footnote 49 Rather than classify one’s action as free or unfree, republicanism adopts a more holistic approach that recognizes how domination renders one’s actions increasingly or decreasingly free.Footnote 50
Individuals can experience different forms of domination: horizontal, vertical, and double.Footnote 51 Horizontal (or private) domination implies that a person is unilaterally vulnerable to another individual’s private power.Footnote 52 Examples of horizontal domination include the employer’s power to fire their employee at will, and a dominating spouse’s tyrannical control in an abusive relationship.Footnote 53
Vertical (or public) domination refers to domination by the State.Footnote 54 Republican theorists have described various forms of vertical domination. Some republican theorists associate vertical domination with individuals’ lack of a self-governing power.Footnote 55 According to this view, individuals face vertical domination when they could not vote to elect a representative government, participate in political office to shape the laws that governed them, or were ruled by an alien will (such as a dictatorial or colonial power).Footnote 56 Others observe that vertical domination arises from State power that is unconstrained by the rule of law, exercised arbitrarily, or subject to insufficient checks and balances.Footnote 57 Similarly, some suggest that individuals must have the capacity to challenge exercises of State power to enjoy republican liberty.Footnote 58 Finally, some observe that laws result in domination when the State enacts laws or implements policies that fail to track individuals’ common interests.Footnote 59
Lastly, individuals can experience double domination, meaning that they are subject to both horizontal and vertical domination that may mutually reinforce one another.Footnote 60 For instance, religious or cultural minority groups – especially minorities within minority groups – may be subject to unique threats of interference from the State and from other private individuals.Footnote 61 Cécile Laborde observes that double domination can arise in different relationships and contexts: inter- and intra-group, public and private, formal and informal, secular and religious, and more.Footnote 62 Individuals who suffer double domination may be unable to rely on the State to protect them against threats of private interference and may be unable to turn to other individuals to escape risks of governmental interference. Together, the combined effects of horizontal and vertical domination may cement an individual’s subordinated position in the public and private spheres.
4.2 Homelessness and Domination
4.2.1 Homelessness, Private Property Rights, and Horizontal Domination
Republicanism demonstrates why unhoused persons lack liberty in ways that negative and positive theories of freedom overlook. Some scholars have explored the relationship between homelessness and republican liberty.Footnote 63 Christopher Essert contends that homelessness is a legal condition where individuals are subject to horizontal domination because they lack private property rights.Footnote 64 Without private property rights, unhoused persons constantly rely on others’ permission to access private property.Footnote 65 Yet access to private property is a precondition to lawfully engage in any conduct in that location.Footnote 66 For this reason, people experiencing homelessness suffer domination because they depend on others to access their private property and do any act within that space.Footnote 67
Similarly, Jane Baron argues that unhoused persons are in a position of social and legal vulnerability because they disproportionately bear duties and liabilities associated with private property.Footnote 68 They are frequently vulnerable to others’ power of exclusion yet lack a comparable power to exclude others.Footnote 69 The private property system’s disparate allocation of powers and liabilities results in an asymmetric power dynamic, such that unhoused persons are in a condition of dependency vis-à-vis rightsholders.Footnote 70
These accounts elucidate how private property allocates power – and protects individuals against others’ power – in a manner that structures social relations.Footnote 71 Individuals must have some authority to dictate what others can and cannot do to secure their liberty.Footnote 72 A private property right provides such authority because it confers a power to exclude others and to insulate oneself against others’ power of exclusion.Footnote 73 Unhoused persons suffer horizontal domination because they lack private property rights that allocate the power to secure their freedom through means other than their physical bodies.Footnote 74
Essert and Baron’s scholarship deepen our comprehension of why unhoused persons experience horizontal domination because they lack private property rights. However, their contributions focus primarily on how people experiencing homelessness are uniquely vulnerable to others’ private power. We gain a more complete understanding of unhoused persons’ double domination when we consider the combined effects of their lack of private property rights and their vulnerability to laws that govern public property. Notably, laws that govern public property subject unhoused persons to two unique forms of double domination that further restricts their republican liberty, each of which are discussed next.Footnote 75
4.2.2 Homelessness and Dependence on Others to Obey the Law
First, people experiencing homelessness face double domination because others exert meaningful control over their ability to obey laws that govern public property.Footnote 76 Unhoused persons experience this form of double domination due to the combined effects of municipal ordinances and individuals’ private power of exclusion.Footnote 77
Municipal ordinances prohibit unhoused persons from sleeping, sheltering themselves, urinating, or defecating on public property.Footnote 78 Individuals must engage in these biologically necessary acts as part of their daily existence.Footnote 79 Unhoused persons are vulnerable to different threats of governmental interference if they alleviate their needs on public property: displacement, tickets, arrests, and incarceration.Footnote 80 They are more vulnerable to these risks of State interference because they lack private property rights, and thus a default private place where they can freely alleviate their needs and obey laws that govern public property.Footnote 81
But unhoused persons require permission from others – homeless shelter staff, restaurant or café employees, or acquaintances – to access their private property, alleviate their needs lawfully, and escape governmental coercion.Footnote 82 For these reasons, unhoused persons routinely depend on others to obey laws that regulate public property in ways that do not affect people with access to housing.Footnote 83
The upshot is that others exert control over unhoused persons’ opportunities to comply with these laws.Footnote 84 Rightsholders decide whether they grant or deny permission to access their private property.Footnote 85 Furthermore, rightsholders enjoy a broad power of exclusion that is generally insulated against judicial and constitutional review, which highlights the uncontrolled nature of interference in unhoused persons’ lives.Footnote 86 Since permission to access private property is a precondition to lawfully doing any act in that space – including need-alleviating acts – rightsholders exercise control over whether unhoused persons access private property, alleviate their needs, and obey laws that govern public property.Footnote 87
This explains why unhoused persons suffer double domination when others exert control over their opportunities to obey these laws. They experience horizontal domination because they depend on others to access private property and escape governmental coercion associated with laws that regulate public property.Footnote 88 They experience vertical domination because the State enacts and enforces laws that fail to track the shared interests of people experiencing homelessness. Notably, these laws overlook unhoused persons’ common interests in being able to control their law-abidingness, and ultimately, avoid displacement, fines, arrests, and incarceration on equal terms with others.
Coercion and punishment are objectionable when individuals lack the undominated choice to obey the law.Footnote 89 Such punishments disingenuously treat legal transgressions as the product of a free and rational choice rather than acknowledge others’ control over that choice.Footnote 90 Rather than punish individuals because they freely and unreasonably rejected available alternatives to violating the law, the State may coerce and punish individuals because they lacked such alternatives in the first place.Footnote 91 The lack of control over one’s opportunity to obey the law delegitimizes convictions and punishment, both of which are generally premised on the notion of free choice to obey the law and the availability of alternatives to lawbreaking.Footnote 92 Furthermore, the State cannot deter individuals from violating the law when others’ exerted – and continue to exert – control over their law-abidingness.Footnote 93 Since only the individual will face coercion and punishment for their legal transgressions, they alone should control their opportunities to obey the law.
Certain examples illustrate how unhoused persons experience double domination when their law-abidingness is subject to others’ control.Footnote 94 A person experiencing homelessness may attempt to access a coffee shop or restaurant to obey laws that prohibit public urination because there are few if any public washrooms in a city.Footnote 95 Yet the establishment’s employees may state that washrooms are for customers only, require individuals to make a purchase to use the washroom, or deny entry for some other reason.Footnote 96 Employees or rightsholders of other establishments may exercise their power of exclusion similarly.Footnote 97 The unhoused persons’ opportunity to access these private spaces, obey the law, and avoid police coercion are subject to others’ control. Or consider how an unhoused person must stay in a shelter to comply with laws that prohibit sleeping or camping on public property.Footnote 98 However, shelter staff may deny entry to individuals for various reasons. They may limit the length of one’s stay, impose sobriety or curfew requirements, or deny entry for other reasons.Footnote 99 The rules that govern homeless shelters – and the discretionary decisions of their employees – influence whether unhoused persons can freely obey laws that prohibit sleeping or camping on public property.Footnote 100
Admittedly, rightsholders may exercise their power of exclusion benevolently and grant unhoused persons access to use their private property, such that they can obey these laws.Footnote 101 Yet domination without interference persists in such contexts.Footnote 102 Unhoused persons still rely on others’ permission to use private property and escape interference from laws that govern public property, and others continue to exert control over unhoused persons’ law-abidingness.Footnote 103
4.2.3 Laws that Govern Public Property and Nonegalitarian Trade-Offs
Second, unhoused persons face double domination when they must make nonegalitarian trade-offs (or sacrifices) to obey laws that regulate public property.Footnote 104 A nonegalitarian trade-off implies that only certain individuals must risk their health, safety, property, or other interests to comply with the law.Footnote 105 Individuals who refuse to make those sacrifices and who violate the law face a different threat of interference: coercion and punishment.
The law imposes nonegalitarian trade-offs on unhoused persons in various contexts. They may be required to stay in a shelter that is dangerous, unsanitary, or overcrowded to obey laws that ban sleeping or camping on public property.Footnote 106 They may be victims of property crime or violent crime during their stay at a shelter.Footnote 107 Certain shelters have rodent and insect infestations, while others have communicable disease outbreaks, such as staph infections and tuberculosis.Footnote 108 Some shelters are overcrowded, which creates risks of communicable disease transmission.Footnote 109 Unhoused persons may also sleep in a secluded and more dangerous area because they do not want to be caught violating laws that govern public property.Footnote 110
The nonegalitarian trade-offs imposed by such laws subject unhoused persons to double domination for the following reasons. They may be required to submit to various threats of horizontal interference – such as violence, theft, and overcrowding in shelters – to escape governmental interference from laws that govern public property.Footnote 111 Yet they face potential displacement, fines, arrests, and incarceration if they refuse to submit themselves to horizontal domination within shelters and violate municipal ordinances.Footnote 112 Unhoused persons are subject to vertical domination from nonegalitarian trade-offs because the law fails to track their common interests in security, autonomy, and physical and mental well-being.Footnote 113 Laws that impose nonegalitarian trade-offs treat certain individuals’ interests as less worthy of equal concern and respect.Footnote 114
The State may require individuals to sacrifice interests of varying degrees of importance. Scholars recognize the primacy of interests related to survival and physical integrity – such as health and security – compared to other interests.Footnote 115 For instance, Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of human needs places survival and safety-related interests above those related to esteem or the desire for knowledge.Footnote 116 The latter cannot be satisfied if the former are not protected.Footnote 117 Similarly, Andrew von Hirsch and Nils Jareborg argue that crimes that endanger survival or physical integrity are more serious than crimes that merely decrease one’s well-being.Footnote 118 They note that survival must be safeguarded to improve one’s quality of life.Footnote 119 These theorists do not disregard the importance of interests other than survival, security, or well-being. They simply recognize that the threat to certain interests is comparatively more serious than the threat to other interests.
The republican theory of freedom captures how laws can impose nonegalitarian trade-offs that result in different degrees of domination. Recall how domination can occur across a spectrum of intensity, frequency, or consistency.Footnote 120 Republicanism acknowledges why the threat of interference to some interests is worse than the threat of interference to others. Laws that govern public property produce greater and more egregious domination when individuals must sacrifice their most fundamental interests – survival, security, physical integrity, and mental well-being – to obey them. Conversely, laws that impose nonegalitarian sacrifices to interests such as companionship or privacy are still morally objectionable and result in domination, yet to a lesser extent than laws that endanger one’s survival or physical integrity. For instance, although an unhoused person may have a significant other, they may sleep in a shelter that does not admit couples to obey an urban camping ban – a nonegalitarian sacrifice that other individuals are not required to make. Such nonegalitarian trade-offs still constitute a form of domination, although one that is less severe than other nonegalitarian sacrifices.
4.3 Homelessness, Domination, and Uncontrolled Interference
These two forms of domination – others’ control over law-abidingness and nonegalitarian trade-offs – are exacerbated by unhoused persons’ lack of political and legal power to control the interference they face. People experiencing homelessness generally lack the political power – and financial resources – to lobby governmental officials so that they enact laws or policies that improve access to housing or reduce domination.Footnote 121 Furthermore, unhoused persons are rarely elected as lawmakers or participate in governmental decision-making bodies.Footnote 122 Some jurisdictions impose a requirement that lawmakers own real property or have a certain value of assets, which further precludes impecunious persons from participating in political office.Footnote 123 Unhoused persons may be unable to vote because they lack a fixed address or governmental identification.Footnote 124 For these reasons, they may not enjoy the participatory power to shape housing policy or influence the enactment of laws that regulate homelessness and public property.Footnote 125
Discrimination – and the contempt or hostility that others have for unhoused persons – also contributes to their political powerlessness.Footnote 126 Groups, such as impecunious persons and unhoused persons, may be highly stigmatized and politically unpopular.Footnote 127 Individuals living in poverty also tend to be blamed for their plight.Footnote 128 Research demonstrates that they are generally viewed unfavorably by a significant portion of the population.Footnote 129 Furthermore, poverty and homelessness are associated with negative feelings and stereotypes.Footnote 130 These considerations explain why groups that enjoy greater political clout may be reluctant to assist unhoused persons or advocate for them.Footnote 131
Unhoused persons also lack the legal power to control interference to which they are subject. Like other police interventions, the discretionary enforcement of laws that govern public property tends to be low-visibility and is not subject to meaningful judicial scrutiny (more on this point in the next chapter).Footnote 132 Police encounters that result in unhoused persons being displaced, fined, or arrested will not be subject to oversight by the legal system – a form of insufficiently controlled interference that exemplifies domination.Footnote 133 Unhoused persons may be unable to afford to pay for legal representation to defend their rights in various contexts, such as civil damage claims for unlawful police conduct, eviction protection in housing court, or human rights tribunal complaints related to housing or employment discrimination.Footnote 134 Unhoused persons’ legal and political powerlessness worsen the domination that they experience, and aggravate the uncontrolled nature of that interference.
4.4 Conclusion
This chapter introduced the republican conception of freedom. It demonstrated why unhoused persons lack this third form of freedom that is distinct from negative and positive conceptions of liberty. It explained why laws that govern public property subject unhoused persons to two forms of double domination. Namely, unhoused persons depend on others to obey laws that govern public property, and they must make nonegalitarian sacrifices to comply with these laws. Unhoused persons’ legal and political powerlessness worsens these forms of domination. Together, the previous chapter and this chapter illustrate why people experiencing homelessness enjoy less positive, negative, and republican liberty than others.
But why does the State have the power to subject unhoused persons to double domination? The next chapters explain why the State has a greater power to regulate and to police unhoused persons’ need-alleviating acts compared to people with access to housing, and to entrench them in the condition of homelessness.
