Given the volume of Beckett scholarship, it is surprising that Graley Herren's Samuel Beckett's Plays on Film and Television is the first full-length study of Beckett's television work. Herren focuses on the unique ability of the television medium to allow Beckett to explore some of his most vital themes, especially that of memory. Herren offers a valuable contribution to Beckett scholarship and a model for scholars serious about the role of television in literary criticism and theatre studies.
In Chapter 1 Herren makes the case for television as an ideal medium for Beckett to explore his themes of memory, melancholy, and elegy. Identifying as his primary model of analysis Clas Zilliacus's underappreciated 1976 study Beckett and Broadcasting, he moves beyond Zilliacus in several ways, most notably by arguing that not only did Beckett bring his themes to the televisual medium, but also that the medium itself, in Beckett's skillful hands, actually enriched the exploration because it consisted of already dismembered images and traces. As Herren states, “the spectacle was already spectral” (4).
Herren offers a keen genealogy of a few central figures, notably Schopenhauer, Bergson, and Freud, who influenced Beckett's conception of memory, to explore a range of themes and ideas in Beckett's televisual work. Herren is certainly not the first scholar to relate these writers to Beckett's work, nor is he novel in his choice of memory as a focal point in his analysis of Beckett; what is impressive is his ability to weave together insights from Schopenhauer, Bergson, Freud, Lacan, Derrida, Benjamin, and others in a concise, compelling manner. The work never becomes mired in theoretical language, and readers of many backgrounds will be able to follow Herren's lines of argument with ease.
In Chapter 2, Herren examines Beckett's early radio and film efforts as valuable in their own right, but also as precursors to the themes and techniques he would develop in his television plays. The bulk of this chapter is devoted to an examination of Beckett's Film, and while Herren carefully explores the flaws of this work, he positions it as a vital link to his future successful television works. In Chapter 3 Herren attempts to rescue Eh Joe, Beckett's first television play, from the negative reaction of previous critics, and crafts an elegant portrait of the work as a complex narrative on suicide and mourning. Aligning the theme of memory with the failed attempt to recompose objects of loss, Herren devotes Chapter 4 to an analysis of Ghost Trio, drawing links to Beckett's preceding works, illustrating his growth as a director, and highlighting the influence of Beethoven on Beckett. In Chapter 5, he examines … but the clouds … in the context of Yeats's influence and the larger framework of the Irish literary tradition. Again a narrative of loss and lack of consolation is the focus of Herren's study, and he argues that the televisual medium allows Beckett to explore these themes in unique ways.
In Chapter 6, Herren emphasizes the theme of musicality in his study of Beckett's most obscure television play, Quadrat I + II. While Herren offers an effective summary and challenges several previous interpretations of this play, this chapter lacks the same clarity found elsewhere in his analysis based on his overarching theme of memory. This is certainly in large part due to the extreme nature of this wordless play, but it also marks this chapter as the weakest in an otherwise focused text. In Chapter 7, Herren analyzes Nacht und Träume for its roots in Schubert, Dante, and a series of paintings by “old masters” on Christian themes, particularly Giovanni Bellini's Agony in the Garden. He concludes that “Beckett's cultural memory asserts itself … but only in the form of ‘dislocated fragments,’ robbed of their original authenticity, coherence, and pedagogical or evangelical logic” (167).
In his final chapter, Herren examines two of Beckett's works adapted from stage to screen, Comedie and Was Wo. Both of these adaptations benefited from Beckett's direct contributions or written advice, so they serve as models for Herren to assess Beckett's perspective on the adaptation of his preexisting works to the television and film media. After tracing the nature and extent of Beckett's contributions to these projects, Herren then uses these insights to examine the recent controversy over the Beckett on Film project.
Herren's book is an excellent contribution to the field and should benefit even those Beckett admirers who have little interest in his television plays. Herren provides a fascinating context for the progression of Beckett's work in television over several decades, deftly handles the daunting cultural and theoretical background required to understand Beckett's themes and allusions, and repeatedly employs clever turns of phrase, frequently relying on antithesis to sharpen his rhetoric. That said, Herren seems occasionally seduced by his own cleverness of language, so that rarely an antithetical device or turn of phrase comes across as overused, unnecessary, or dependent on a lengthy supporting passage to allow the choice expression to hit its mark. A second criticism is that Herren dismisses television in its non-Beckettian manifestations, at one point arguing that “[t]he medium traditionally demands no more activity from its audience than that they buy its advertised products” (49). While Beckett's sophistication in the televisual form is perhaps without parallel, this position—relying as it does on the most banal examples of a complex medium—does not bear up under close scrutiny. The lack of illustrations is also disappointing, but Herren's skillful descriptions go far to compensate for this. Putting those three minor complaints aside, we should praise Herren for an exciting new work that interweaves a rich body of scholarship and a close reading of Beckett's own works, letters, and production notes to form a cogent and convincing narrative.
