In the wake of the #MeToo movement, the publication of Sara E. Lampert's Starring Women: Celebrity, Patriarchy, and American Theater, 1790–1850 feels like a circuitous journey into the long-standing challenges facing female artists. Though Lampert never identifies sexual assault, which is closely tied to #MeToo, the power of women in America following the American Revolution and into the antebellum years was severely undermined by their lack of legal autonomy. In this historic period, Lampert places women in the performing arts squarely at the mercy or benevolence of their male counterparts. Contemporary society mirrors this period, with various media and entertainment male power brokers holding significant sway over the careers of female artists and often compromising autonomy and artistic freedom. Lampert contends that by enhancing their cultural capital, starring women were able to exert more control over their careers despite legal limitations. Her investigation of starring women at this time identifies gender politics, celebrity culture, and regional performance in America as she uncovers strategies utilized by celebrated actresses (11).
Lampert's extensive research mainly relies on correspondences, playbills, periodicals, and publications from the period. At the outset, Lampert anchors the patterned trajectory of female star performers with an 1854 memoir by Anna Cora Ogden Mowatt, playwright, actress, and author, who credits the itinerant star Fanny Kemble as her inspiration to take up theatre. Lampert identifies Mowatt's autobiography, combined with strategically placed press pieces, as evidence of actresses’ challenge to “lingering Protestant condemnation of the morality of the theater while asserting the legitimacy of the stage as a sphere of labor and artistic endeavor for genteel white women” (2). Additionally, the choice of stage labor is envisaged as “a more lucrative and sustainable living” given the opportunities available to women in this time (29).
In Chapter 1, “Between Stock and Star: Theater and Touring in the United States, 1790–1830,” Lampert outlines the early patterns of stardom through a newly capitalized itinerant system, where English actors’ “migrations reflect culture and economic gravitation” through the “expanding and competitive promise of American markets” (29). In the account of one English actress, Lydia Kelly, Lampert uncovers records revealing £5,000 (worth about $587,000 today) following a lucrative tour around the United States during 1824–31 (37). Financial successes like Kelly's and those of fellow female stars “would have juxtaposed starkly with contemporary reports of the depressed state of women's wages” and inspired more women to seek stage careers (43).
The value of this female labor in “stock actors and the elevated class of touring stars” came with limitations of the time, as “men expected to control and supervise the labor of their children and wives” as managers and costars to their performances (53). As she explores this familial relationship in Chapter 2, “(Dis)Obedient Daughters and Devoted Wives: The Family Politics of Stock and Star,” Lampert uncovers narratives, “ghostwritten promotional materials,” that served to alleviate fathers and husbands of societal scorn for putting wives and daughters to work; fathers and husbands were noble, as they uncovered “genius” that demanded their wives and daughters perform onstage, contrary to gender ideals and respectable professions of the genteel white woman (54–5). Though young actresses were “yoked to family interests,” strategic marriages by newly of-age actresses created some opportunity for autonomy, allowing the pursuit of either new performances or retirement (81).
The book examines several heroines of the antebellum stage over the next three chapters, including Fanny Kemble, Ellen Tree, [Madame] Celeste Elliott, and Fanny Elssler. Lampert reveals the paradoxical reality women faced in the development of American theatre, where the pursuit of autonomous fame was beholden to a public fan base, and outlines the unique challenges faced by each actress. Ultimately, their fates were limited by the same patriarchal system. However, Lampert's investigation unearths evidence, via grievances included in correspondence by male counterparts, of challenges made to the patriarchal system by leading ladies. In this evidence, male managers and publicists complain about wages and question the significant income and artistic quality of female stars in the book. In coordination with this wage data, Lampert identifies personal journals and publications that begin to attack the moral character of starring women as they started to gain more autonomy in their work selection when their celebrity rose; akin to modern victim blaming and smear tactics, powerful denizens of any era appear to use their clout to exert control over female counterparts.
In the final chapter, “The American Actress's Starring Playbook, 1831–1857,” Lampert centers her examination on commonalities found in the careers of three prominent American actresses, Josephine Clifton, Charlotte Cushman, and Matilda Heron. To uncover trends and practices among these three women, she investigates the accounts and records of their performances throughout the middle of the nineteenth century. Lampert uncovers unique properties of autonomy and earning power for these women, wherein they remained most successful outside of the expected, traditional familial roles of wife, sister, and/or daughter for female performers at this time (220). However, in her examination of letters, journals, and media publications, Lampert uncovers the still-constant struggle of starring actresses of this period to maintain a genteel feminine ideal that fit within public expectations, since “maneuvering for professional opportunities required that they pay attention to the terms of their public image” (219).
Solidifying its position along with Faye Dudden's Women in the American Theatre: Actresses and Audiences, 1790–1870 (1994) and Elizabeth Reitz Mullenix's Wearing Breeches: Gender on the Antebellum Stage (2000), Starring Women builds on much-needed expansion of the role women played in the development of North American theatre. These works all call for further examination of women and their role in early American theatre. Questions raised by Lampert's investigation of theatrical heritage demand further academic investigation into queer and gendered performance, queer theatre culture in early America, the role of theatre in pursuit of female autonomy, and the influence of theatrical practice in the development of gender roles in America.
