Konrad Kraft's Das System der kaiserzeitlichen Münzprägung in Kleinasien (1972) was the first attempt to provide a general overview of the production of civic coinages in western Asia Minor under the Principate. Kraft came to three key conclusions: (i) there were itinerant workshops of die engravers (Werkstätte); (ii) they were often also responsible for coin striking; (iii) they often reused obverse dies in the different cities they travelled to, hence the many instances of die-sharing he identified between the Antonines and the 250s. He highlighted four principal workshops that each supplied a specific network of cities (Lieferbezirk).
Despite this apparent comprehensiveness, Kraft's analysis should only be considered a first step in the exploration of local coinage production, a step cut short by his death in 1970. (See the caveats in Ann Johnston's review, Numismatic Chronicle 14 (1974), 203–7.) George Watson now offers a new contribution to the understanding of die-sharing and the local production of bronze coinage, a revised version of his doctoral thesis. He focuses on southern Asia Minor, mainly Pisidia and Lycia-Pamphylia, in the third century a.d., a region and a period that have been neglected by Kraft and subsequent scholars.
W. begins with a general introduction and a presentation of the numismatic evidence (chs 1 and 2), before coming to the two issues at the heart of the volume: the questions of die-sharing and stylistic similarities (ch. 3) and the production process (ch. 4). The study identifies three main workshops, named A, B and C, each having a different pattern and chronology. He then turns to the influence of these engraver workshops on both types and denominations and on the rhythm and volume of coin production (chs 5 and 6). Ch. 7 provides a detailed overview of the various regional patterns that emerge from the analyses; he compares his numismatic data with other evidence for connections, including inscriptions and ceramics. The analytical section of the book ends with a brief (four-page) but dense general conclusion (ch. 8). It is followed by a significant general bibliography that includes hundreds of bibliographical references (185–208), an index (615–21) and four appendices: ‘Catalogue of coins’, ‘Coins not included in the catalogue’, ‘Statistical calculations’ and ‘Concordances’. The catalogue alone covers almost 380 pages (209–588). It is introduced by two pages of instructions (209–10) and abundantly illustrated with 74 plates.
It must first be said that the catalogue is not easy handling for a non-specialist. It does not always follow usual standards for descriptions of Roman coins (e.g. it employs ‘360°’ rather than ‘12h’), and the complex numeration and presentation make it awkward to make the necessary cross-references when reading ch. 3, especially the lists that set out the cities that used a particular workshop. The catalogue also contains some imprecisions, omissions and errors which are embarrassing since it is the foundation of the overall argument.
Imprecisions concern the descriptions of busts on the obverse. This goes against the author's stated ambition (cf. ch. 3) of providing a very precise stylistic analysis in order to identify patterns shared by the cities that used a given workshop. While the busts of the Augustae are well described, those of Emperors suffer from shortcomings. It is not systematically specified whether a bust is seen from front or rear, and some descriptions need major corrections, e.g. the obverse of Watson 421a, a bronze of Codrula, does not depict a ‘male bust (Maximus) r., draped; head r., crowned (wreath)’, but ‘a laureate and cuirassed bust, r., seen from front, with an eagle on cuirass’.
Omissions are unavoidable since every numismatic corpus is a work in progress (as noted by J.-P. Callu, Revue Numismatique 171 (2014), 21–9). The author cannot be blamed for that, but the reader should be aware that the coverage, although extensive, is not comprehensive. If we consider e.g. Pamphylia under Philip I, RPC VIII comprises 141 types (RPC VIII, 1882–2022; prov. numbers) while W.'s catalogue contains 121 records. Thus, the recent publication online of RPC VII.2 and RPC VIII has brought new die-links to our knowledge. Similarly, W. notes die-links between Syedra and Laerte under Gordian III (352, n. 68), but RPC VII.2 online reveals others with Side (RPC VII.2, 2568, 2569, 2574; prov. numbers).
Some mistakes deserve to be corrected, though they do not call into question the general conclusions. For example, the reverse of Watson 595 for Colybrassus (= RPC VII, 2669; prov. number), does not represent Athena holding a spear and a ‘long torch’, but the goddess holding a spear and a shield with an olive-tree behind her, a type that dates back to Marcus Aurelius.
To conclude, Connections, Communities, and Coinage will prove valuable not only for numismatists but also historians and archaeologists working on Roman Anatolia. Some chapters (especially chs 2, 3 and 7) will be of great use in future research with their insights into the production process and their integration of archaeological data in numismatic analysis. Despite some weaknesses in the catalogue and in the presentation of the material, W. further demonstrates the capacity for die-studies and numismatic approaches to illuminate the history of the cities of Asia Minor under Roman rule.
