In social policy research, tremendous energy has been invested into assigning and reassigning welfare states to regime types. Also, the study of the path-dependent nature of policy developments in mature welfare states is well represented: especially continental welfare states have been accused of policy lock-ins, held in place by contribution-based eligibility rights and powerful veto players – both serious reform obstacles for policy makers. Up to the 1990s, such stability predictions were successful in explaining the relative immobility of welfare states. However, in recent years, even continental welfare states departed significantly from their well-trodden paths. The contradiction between predicted super-stability and the observed massive policy reorientation provides the convincing starting point for Sabina Stiller's Ideational Leadership in German Welfare State Reform: How Politicians and Policy Ideas Transform Resilient Institutions.
If regime typologies and theories of historical institutionalism are seen as only being able to explain continuity or at best incremental change, what alternative concepts can be used to explain empirical findings of major welfare state reforms? Sabina Stiller argues that political agency has been ignored, and prematurely so. In contrast to rather pessimistic accounts that attribute strategies such as blame avoidance or hiding reform processes (‘politics of stealth’) to policy makers, Stiller develops a more optimistic vision: the concept of ideational leadership (IL). IL is about explaining how structural reforms can be accomplished in allegedly resilient welfare states. Drawing from both leadership and ideational literatures, an IL-type actor will:
(1) expose the drawbacks of the policy status quo,
(2) consistently make efforts to legitimate the alternative policy promoted and the principles underlying it,
(3) frame opposition to reform as being problematic for social welfare, and
(4) make efforts at consensus building.
Furthermore, an ideational leader is:
(5) inherently policy-oriented rather than power-oriented (p. 39).
While the IL concept is appealing because of its positive attitude towards change, the reader is sometimes confused about the causal nexus to structural reform. Is IL a precondition for structural reform, or just one political strategy among others to achieve it? Or, the other way round, is structural reform even a precondition for IL? Although Stiller argues against such a potential tautology (p. 34), when reading her book one gets the impression that IL is a successful strategy by definition, as it is so intrinsically tied to structural reforms. To increase the empirical value of the concept, more effort should have been put into the explanation of the conditions under which the IL hypothesis could be falsified. Furthermore, IL is attributed explanatory power even when its presence can be traced only to some extent, in some aspects; this adds to the empirical vagueness in measuring the independent variable. Therefore, the concept tends to invite ex-post analyses that might overestimate the role IL plays in welfare state reforms.
To test the IL concept empirically, the author focuses on welfare state reforms in Germany, a country often seen as the incarnation of the continental regime type. This case selection is compelling: ‘If far-reaching reforms do occur there, they can be expected to occur anywhere’ (p. 16). The reader is offered information from a broad range of printed sources and from 35 interviews with policy experts. After an informative overview on general German social policy developments since the 1970s, Stiller turns to in-depth case studies of IL components in major reforms. In particular, she focuses on the role of the Minister of Health, Horst Seehofer, in the health care reforms of 1992 and 1996, on the role of the Minister of Labour and Social Affairs, Walter Riester, in restructuring the pension system in 2001, and of the Minister of Labour and the Economy, Wolfgang Clement, in the Hartz IV labour market policy reforms that took effect in 2005. For readers interested in these path-breaking reforms, the book offers fascinating accounts of the reform process. Traces of IL can be found in all reforms under study, but ‘there is no compelling evidence for either a structural reform or effective IL’ (p. 109) in Seehofer's 1996 health reform. Next to the IL aspects, making concessions to reform critics played an important role in Riester's pension reform and in Clement's reform of labour market policy.
In the final chapter, the author assesses the extent to which the German welfare state is still in line with the Bismarckian principles, which made it the hallmark of the conservative regime type. But before the concluding assessment is made, a cursory description of family policy interrupts the chapter. This seems out of place here as it is not linked to the IL concept and opens up a whole new policy field too late in the game – though this new field is often portrayed as the major non-Bismarckian interluder, as the new kid on the policy block.
Finally, the author concludes, all these welfare reforms in the past two decades have hybridised and not dualised the German ‘welfare state edifice’, the latter having been suggested, amongst others, by Bleses and Seeleib-Kaiser (Reference Bleses and Seeleib-Kaiser2004) and Palier and Martin (Reference Palier and Martin2008). This edifice is ‘rather dynamic in nature as it features hybrid institutional characteristics that have not yet firmly been anchored’ (pp. 196 f.). Thus, the German welfare state is seen as being currently in transition: traditional Bismarckian principles have lost ground, while a set of new principles has not yet become hegemonic, and it is still unclear where, in the long run, the journey will be going.
This book, nonetheless, adds some value to welfare state analysis. It offers detailed insights into major welfare state reform processes in Germany, and it presents a theoretical framework for explaining how agency can trigger reforms even in those welfare states that are thought of as being ‘frozen’. Here, the author breaks new ground with her concept of IL, of ideational leadership. Regrettable about this book is that it shares one problem with all ideational approaches: while in each individual case the empirical analysis seems convincing, one cannot deny an ex-post bias which makes for overstating how significant ideas and individual policy makers are for welfare state reforms.
