Case presentation
A 12-year-old boy was referred for frequent premature ventricular complex and non-sustained ventricular tachycardia. He had transposition of the great arteries with an intact ventricular septum and had undergone an arterial switch operation in his neonatal period. Although he had no residual lesions, such as pulmonary stenosis, regurgitation, and aortic root enlargement, his electrocardiography showed frequent left bundle branch block-type, superior axis premature ventricular complexes with a QRS width of 180 ms (Figure 1a), suggesting the premature ventricular complex origin was the free wall myocardium of the right ventricular inflow. The activation map created by OCTARAY® (Biosense Webster, Diamond Bar, California, USA) during a premature ventricular complex was unable to narrow down the earliest activation site because of the presence of multiple exits on the endocardial surface (Figure 1b). Although the waveform of the catheter-stimulated premature ventricular complex at the earliest activation site was very similar to that of the clinical premature ventricular complex, the QRS width was narrower, suggesting that the clinical premature ventricular complex was more likely to be of epicardial side origin (Figure 1c). Therefore, we assumed the clinical premature ventricular complex had a pure origin at the intramural or epicardial side and multiple breakout sites at the endocardial side. To identify the pure origin of the premature ventricular complex, we performed the mapping by targeting the area where the onset of the QS-type waveform of unipolar potential was delayed compared to the onset of bipolar potential, while maintaining the early activation (Figure 2a). Once the target site was identified, the catheter was placed in vertical contact with the myocardial wall in order to form a deep lesion by ablation. An application of radiofrequency energy (25 W) using a 4 mm-tip catheter (Thermocool SmartTouch®, Biosense Webster, Diamond Bar, California, USA) targeting the preceding bipolar potential with the interval to the QRS wave of 6 ms and with the interval to the unipolar potential of 17 ms eliminated the premature ventricular complex without firing a response. He has been free from recurrence of the premature ventricular complex for 4 years without antiarrhythmic drugs.
( a ) The 12-lead electrograms of the premature ventricular complex ( a ). The premature ventricular complex was left bundle branch block-type, superior axis with QRS width of 180 ms. ( b ) The activation map of the right ventricle during the premature ventricular complex was obtained from the right anterior oblique 30-degree view. (Isochronal map displayed in 10 colours every 8 ms). The premature ventricular complex was unable to narrow down the earliest activation site because of the presence of multiple exits on the endocardial surface. ( c ) The comparison of the 12-lead electrocardiogram of the clinical and the catheter-stimulated premature ventricular complex. The waveform of the catheter-stimulated premature ventricular complex (second beat) at the earliest activation site had a narrower QRS width than the clinical one (first beat), suggesting that the clinical PVC was more likely to be of epicardial side origin.

Figure 1 Long description
The image contains three sections: electrograms, an activation map, and a comparison of electrocardiograms. The electrograms show the 12-lead readings of a premature ventricular complex, which is left bundle branch block-type with a superior axis and a QRS width of 180 milliseconds. The activation map of the right ventricle during the premature ventricular complex is obtained from the right anterior oblique 30-degree view. The isochronal map is displayed in 10 colors every 8 milliseconds, showing multiple exits on the endocardial surface. The comparison of the 12-lead electrocardiograms shows the clinical premature ventricular complex and the catheter-stimulated premature ventricular complex. The waveform of the catheter-stimulated premature ventricular complex has a narrower QRS width than the clinical one, suggesting that the clinical premature ventricular complex is more likely to be of epicardial side origin.
Comparison of local intracardiac electrocardiograms at successful and unsuccessful ablation and their schematic representation on the activation map of the right ventricle during a clinical premature ventricular complex obtained from the left anterior oblique 30-degree view. (Success point) The onset of bipolar potential preceded 6 ms to the onset of surface QRS wave of premature ventricular complex while the onset of unipolar potential was delayed 17 ms to the onset of bipolar potential. (Failure point) Although the onset of bipolar potential preceded 18 ms to the onset of surface QRS wave of premature ventricular complex, the onset of unipolar potential was simultaneous with the onset of bipolar potential. ABL: ablation catheter placed at successful ablation site; RA: right atrium; uni: unipolar.

Figure 2 Long description
The image contains one diagram and two illustrations. The central diagram displays an activation map of the right ventricle during a clinical premature ventricular complex, viewed from the left anterior oblique 30-degree angle. Two illustrations flank the central diagram, each depicting a sequence of events during ablation. The left illustration shows a successful ablation where the onset of bipolar potential precedes the surface QRS wave by 6 milliseconds, and the unipolar potential is delayed by 17 milliseconds. The right illustration shows an unsuccessful ablation where the onset of bipolar potential precedes the surface QRS wave by 18 milliseconds, but the unipolar potential onset is simultaneous with the bipolar potential. The diagrams include labels for the ablation catheter, right atrium, and unipolar potential.
Discussion
It was unknown what the criteria of endocardial mapping were for the intramural or epicardial pure-origin premature ventricular complex to effectively ablate. The traditional criteria, such as early activation, pace-map consistency, and QS-type waveform of unipolar potential, are not sufficient evidence. The presence of a prepotential has been reported to be a target in an outflow tract premature ventricular complex; however, the prepotential is not always identified. Trevisi et al. reported the diagnostic criteria for identifying left-sided outflow ventricular ectopy using non-contact mapping from the right ventricle. Reference Trevisi, Silberbauer and Radinovic1 They concluded the 20 ms delayed unipolar potential compared to early activation or the 10 ms delayed compared to surface QRS onset demonstrated excellent accuracy. In our case, the delayed unipolar QS-type waveform of unipolar potential relative to early activation of bipolar potential suggested the intramural or epicardial origin away from the endocardial catheter site. The origin of the premature ventricular complex in this case was the right ventricle, so the previous studies on ablation for ventricular tachycardias originating from the intraventricular and epicardial regions of the left ventricle cannot be directly applied. The primary reason is the difference in wall thickness, and there are also anatomical differences, including the presence of the papillary muscles. The evidence is circumstantial only: premature ventricular complexes induced by catheter stimulation at that site exhibited a narrower QRS than clinical ones; mapping from the endocardial side revealed multiple exit pathways; and ultimately, effective ablation was achieved by applying the catheter perpendicular to the origin site.
Mapping of pure origin alone was not sufficient for ablation of intramural or epicardial-origin premature ventricular complex, and we were required adequate lesion formation. According to previous reports, an ablation index value of 400 was achieved at low power (25 W) for long periods of time (60 s) without producing a steam pop. Reference Mori, Kato and Sumitomo2 In addition, the catheter was cauterised with a small area of contact with the endomyocardium and without excessive contact force (9 g) in order to minimise the expansion of the myocardial oedema. Reference Thomas, Silvernagel and Angel3
The pure epicardial origin from the right ventricular free wall is uncommon in structurally normal hearts except for the left ventricular summit or crux. In our case, however, the patient had a history of an arterial switch operation for transposition of the great arteries, which may have contributed to altered myocardial conduction properties and arrhythmogenic substrate. While the heart was free of overt structural abnormalities on echocardiography, we considered that microstructural changes, undetectable by standard imaging, might have predisposed to an epicardial focus.
The potential utility of alternative strategies for epicardial-origin arrhythmias, such as bipolar ablation, direct epicardial access, and emerging technologies such as pulse field ablation, is acknowledged as future considerations. This case report study has provided electrophysiological possibility to identify the epicardial pure origin without being misled by the electrocardiogram characteristics of multiple endocardial breakout sites. It is a unique challenge, and right ventricular free wall epicardial mapping should be considered before performing direct epicardial mapping.
Data availability statement
The data that support the findings of this study are available on request from the corresponding author. The data are not publicly available due to privacy or ethical restrictions.
Acknowledgements
None.
Financial support
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency or from any commercial or not-for-profit sections.
Competing interests
All authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Informed consent
Informed consent was obtained from participants included in the study.
