In Phonographies: Grooves in Sonic Afro-Modernity, Alexander Weheliye situates sonic blackness at the center of Western modernity. This book shows how significant literary and cinematic representations of modernity revolve around descriptions of the sounds and social relations envisioned and enacted through recordings of Black music. Like Paul Gilroy and Houston Baker, Weheliye insists on acknowledging and honoring Black modernism as more than the particular and parochial creation of a marginal aggrieved group. Instead, Weheliye argues that sonic blackness exemplifies Western modernity's core characteristics and contributions. Starting from a uniquely situated standpoint, sonic Afro-modernity has superseded its historical and social particularisms to become a central element in modernity in general.
This book ranges widely for its research objects. It links together the practices and products of popular culture with canonical works of literature and social criticism. It challenges the hegemony of visual metaphors in cultural criticism with an emphasis on sound. As Weheliye's deft phrasing puts it, he believes that thinking about sound is essential for sound thinking. His arguments eschew the binary opposition between virtuous originals and degraded copies by exploring the generative possibilities of mechanical reproduction, especially its capacity to make new things audible, legible, and possible.
Weheliye invites us to learn how the literary techniques of quotation, citation, and oration in writings by W. E. B. Du Bois and Ralph Ellison evoke and honor practices with important roots in mass-mediated forms of Black music. He finds parallel expressions of Afro-modernity in Darnell Martin's film I Like It Like That and in Ralph Ellison's essay “Living With Music.” Weheliye writes knowingly and perceptively about the ways in which national identities are both affirmed and contested in lyrics by the Haitian American hip-hop group The Fugees and the Afro-German hip-hop ensemble Advanced Chemistry. Like Sterling Stuckey's classic argument in Slave Culture about the centrality of the ring shout to the thought of elite Black intellectuals, Weheliye argues that the cutting, sampling, versioning, mixing, dubbing, layering, and flowing of turntablists and sound system disc jockeys encompass archives, epistemologies, imaginaries, and ontologies that inflect modernity's greatest triumphs with unmistakably Black resonances.
Phonographies succeeds best as an inventory and analysis of discourses. Weheliye's arguments and prose flow most smoothly when he writes about literary texts, critical essays, and song lyrics. His object of study is not so much sound, technology, and blackness as it is representations of sound, technology, and blackness. He demonstrates how representations of Black sounds have been deployed repeatedly to make sense out of modernity's cultures, politics, philosophies, economies, and social relations. Afro-sonic modernity has been where the liberal citizen subject meets the cyborg, where technology intersects with art, where commerce and culture collide, and where memories of ancestors pervade contacts with strangers. Weheliye makes a persuasive case that there would be no modernity without blackness and its many representations.
Yet in his zeal to give Black people and Black culture a central role in the creation of modernity, Weheliye may pass too quickly over the ways in which sonic blackness speaks most eloquently, not to modernity but to its contradictions. He makes a good case that there would be no modernity without blackness, but his evidence does not confirm his assertion of the converse formulation that there would be no blackness without modernity. Farah Jasmine Griffin's critiques of the migration narrative in Black culture reveal that Black artists have long tempered modernity's embrace of the metropolitan realm populated by strangers with rich cultural creations that place “the stranger” in dialogue with “the ancestor.”Footnote 1 Similarly, Alejandro Madrid's research on the contemporary Nor-tec collective from Tijuana, Mexico, draws deftly on the sociology of Anthony Giddens to explain how race looms large in contemporary culture as much from the contradictions of modernity as from its triumphs.Footnote 2
Weheliye properly credits Black modernists with embracing new technologies to create new forms of art, identity, and social membership, but he seems less sensitive to the ways in which those “new” techniques have a long and venerable history. As John Szwed has shown, the mediated, amplified, augmented, and distorted sounds of electronic instruments and digital samplers have acoustic ancestors in the buzz tones and split tones of Afro-diasporic singing, plunger mutes, and instrumental virtuosity.Footnote 3 Computer-sequenced phasing and delay can be understood as new, but also as modern forms of call and response. The mixing and scratching of dub and hip-hop disc jockeys that Weheliye credits with de-territorializing and re-territorializing contemporary music have predecessors in the ways that bop musicians built songs around the chord progressions of previous songs and in Ornette Coleman's rejections of a tonal or rhythmic center. Weheliye astutely perceives the contributions that sonic Afro-modernity makes to modernity, but he undervalues what it means for Black musicians to make those contributions from a musical tradition that both conforms to and departs from the traditions of tonal functional harmony in Western art music. As George E. Lewis has shown in his discussion of the characteristics that distinguish the modernist improvisations of John Cage from the Afrological traditions of improvisation in jazz and blues, what the Western tradition sometimes views as provocative rebellion against stodgy tradition, the Afrological tradition might view as a return to a dynamic tradition, to the “changing same.”
The emphasis in Phonographies on the sonic realm provides a necessary and valuable corrective to the overemphasis on the visual (and a resulting underemphasis on the sonic) in studies of modernism. Yet it may be important to interrogate the division between sight and sound in the first place. Bennetta Jules-Rosette's extraordinary work on the emergence of the star persona of Josephine Baker as one of the first truly transnational cultural commodities presents a brilliant semiotic analysis of how Baker's many different public images competed with her recorded voice in conveying a unique form of modernity.Footnote 4 Recorded music and literary texts do not generally contain illustrations, but that does not mean that visual images do not remain present and powerful in the mind when they are heard and read.
Weheliye's sensitive and generative interpretations about the stances towards historical progress in the writings of Ellison and Du Bois also need fuller grounding in the contradictions of modernity. Weheliye quotes Ellison's narrator in the Invisible Man positing that history might be a gambler rather than a force in a laboratory experiment. He interprets this passage to show how sonic Afro-modernity challenges totalizing ideas of history to make room for its ex-scripted subjects. Yet it seems likely that at this point in the novel Ellison is not taking aim at history in general but at the particular determinism and teleology of the Marxist tradition, represented in the novel by the Brotherhood.
Phonographies is an original and enlightening book. It augments immeasurably our understanding of modernity, sonic blackness, and the subject positions produced and precluded in popular culture. It rejects both parochial particularisms and disembodied undifferentiated universalisms. In keeping with its research object, it is a book that mixes, dubs, and “versions” some traditional and some new subject matter in innovative ways. It does not aspire to be the last word, but it pushes the conversation along inventively and productively.
