No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
This brief volume (the text runs to only 184 pages) is an effort to place Pakistan's armed forces in historical perspective. Earlier books by other authors centered attention on a particular service, and especially on the Pakistani army, but this is the first attempt to address all the services in a single volume. The author, Pervaiz Iqbal Cheema, has devoted his professional life to the study of Pakistan's military establishment and comes well equipped to inform the reader about recruitment, force levels, training, and weapons systems connected with the modernization of one of the world's largest armed forces. A prominent member of the faculty at Quaid-i-Azam University, and a former holder of the Iqbal chair at Heidelberg University, he currently mentors the Policy Research Institute in Islamabad. Cheema's many publications have focused on security issues, and he is no stranger to the questions that burden Pakistani officialdom—or, for that matter, Pakistani society. What is of principal interest in this volume is the Pakistani view of global conditions and how they affect the Pakistani nation. Thus, there is an attempt to deal with the Pakistani ethos and how Pakistani society has been shaped and molded by the country's relations with its near and distant neighbors. Paramount in this regard is the outlook of the Pakistani armed forces and how they sees their role in an unstable world.
Cheema's treatment of salient matters is more conversational than studied. He gives limited attention to nuclear weapons, to Pakistan's relations with India, or to Pakistan's long association with the United States. On the question of the country's nuclear capability, he is less concerned than the outside world about the capacity of Pakistan's armed forces to control the nuclear weapons in its charge. Cheema cites the “hypocrisy” (p. 172) of those who would deny Pakistan a handful of nuclear weapons in a world brimming with tens of thousands of such devices. Moreover, he argues that Pakistan and India engaged in their celebrated wars during the first twenty-five years following their independence and avoided a renewal of hostilities in the subsequent twenty-five year period. Indeed, the author believes that peace is more likely between India and Pakistan because they possess such awesome weapons and that such understanding is now gaining support in important world capitals. Cheema urges mutual restraint on both Islamabad and New Delhi where nuclear weapons are involved. The limited deterrence of Pakistan's nuclear strategy acknowledges India's superiority, but the author nevertheless believes that Pakistan's program is sufficient to cause the two countries to find common ground for diplomatic settlement, notably on Kashmir.
Cheema does not examine Pakistan's love/hate relationship with the United States in detail, but he makes it quite clear that Washington has been a fair-weather friend, often disappearing from the scene when its own interests seemed little served by its Pakistan connection. By contrast, he asserts that China has been a steady associate and that positive feelings toward Beijing by the full spectrum of Pakistani society demonstrate how the people of Pakistan measure their government's relations with the great powers. Pakistan's relations with Afghanistan are given minimum attention, but there is an attempt to summarize the strained relations between Islamabad and Kabul from partition in 1947 through the Soviet invasion of the mountainous state. Virtually nothing is said, however, of Pakistan's military extension into Afghanistan following the Soviet withdrawal in 1989—or, for that matter, about the deployment of Inter Services Intelligence operatives in Afghanistan in an effort to influence domestic changes in that country in the post-Soviet era. Nor should the reader look for the Pakistani army's role in aiding and abetting the Taliban as it sought to seize control of the country.
In defense of the author, it should be stated that the book was completed in 1999 and first appeared in 2001. This slightly later edition makes reference to 11 September and the immediate aftermath, particularly Pervez Musharraf's decision to stand with the United States in its declared war on terrorism. But there is almost no follow-up analysis as to what Pakistan's future may be as it is again tied reluctantly to American initiatives. Nor does the author dwell on the Islamization of the Pakistani armed forces, their proclivities toward fundamentalism, or the struggle between religious and secular elements within the armed forces. The chapter devoted to the armed forces in politics is not especially informative, and Cheema seems content simply to summarize the rule of Pakistan's central military personalities—that is, Ayub Khan, Yahya Khan, Zia ul-Haq, and now Pervez Musharraf. By the same token, insufficient attention is given to the emergence of Bangladesh. Cheema describes the mistakes made by the army high command in the aftermath of the 1970 elections that precipitated the civil war and brought India's intervention and ultimately Pakistan's dismemberment. But the only conclusion apparently drawn is the need to bring the armed forces under more direct civilian control (p. 180). The army's reluctance to accept any form of direct civilian control, however, is demonstrated with the extended period of martial law imposed by General Zia ul-Haq from 1977 to 1988, and subsequently by Musharraf from 1999 to the present.
A major theme of this volume is Pakistan's military strategy, but Cheema is also cognizant that the country's armed forces continue to base their strategizing more in reaction to external events than in matters demanded by the society it is charged with making secure. The most useful sections of this book therefore are not rooted in Pakistan's defense policy or civil–military relations, or foreign-policy gambits, but in the separate chapters describing the evolution of the Pakistani army, navy, and air force. In this respect, the book is a good, fast read, a virtual overview of the growth, role, and status of the Pakistani armed forces as the country attempts to maneuver into the current millennium.