With this book, Marco Giugni and his colleagues have helped to plug a still substantial gap in the literature on policy responses to unemployment – the role of trade unions, the third sector and other non-state actors in providing a basis for collective action. Giugni's introduction sets up one of the key arguments of the book – that beneath the rhetoric of empowerment and employability, the activation agenda represents a major shift towards increased conditionality in access to social protection. He then turns to a second focus for the book – the potentially (and in some cases historically) crucial role of trade unions and civil society organisations in providing a space for collective action and organisation among the unemployed. The chapters that follow offer valuable, if at times disparate, insights into often ambiguous relationships whereby these organisations have both succeeded and failed to organise and represent the demands of unemployed workers.
The main part of the book opens with four empirical chapters focusing first on key issues, then policy responses. Bengt Furaker's overview of the range, scale and effects of unemployment policies (drawing largely on OECD data) identifies a number of themes relevant to the remaining chapters, from the manner in which benefits systems tend to favour the core workforce in stable jobs over young people and other outsiders, to the lack of evidence behind claims that such benefits disincentivise work among the unemployed. A balanced account of the shift towards activation in unemployment policy identifies the potential problems around lock-in, displacement and deadweight effects, but also acknowledges the inherent difficulty in attributing specific changes in labour market participation to industrial, activation or social protection policies, compared to concurrent developments in the economy. Giuliano Bonoli then adds his own analysis of the labour market processes that increase unemployment risks in the EU and beyond, specifically focusing on how de-industrialisation and tertiarisation have destroyed jobs in traditional sectors to replace them with low-level employment that offers fewer opportunities for progression (or indeed to escape poverty).
In the first of two national case studies, Peter Dwyer and Nick Ellison provide an excellent and uncompromising analysis of how New Labour in the UK adopted right-of-centre thinking on dependency culture, and how this bankrupt concept has informed measures undermining social protection and increasing conditionality and compulsion. Maeder and Nadai's in-depth study of three different Swiss policies then reveals how unemployed people are often required to navigate complex systems of provision, handle the pressure of increased conditionality and regulation in the benefits system, and get to grips with the competing demands and agendas of different stakeholders. Meanwhile, a reductionist activation agenda offers limited real help for these job seekers in seeking to overcome complex personal, family and financial barriers to work.
The book then settles on its second key theme – the role of collective action in mediating and responding to the experience of unemployment. Giugni acknowledges in the opening pages of the book that unions have sometimes had an ambivalent relationship with the unemployed, in part reflecting a natural desire to focus resources on the core group of secure – and working – workers. This issue is taken up by Andrew Richards's fascinating account of the role of trade unionism in responding to the UK unemployment crises of the 1920s and 1980s. Richards argues that collective action among the unemployed in the interwar era happened despite limited support from the trade union movement. Changed structural conditions meant that efforts at self-mobilisation were unsustainable in the 1980s, by which time an increasingly service-oriented union movement was more concerned with providing support for unemployed people (for example, through unemployed workers’ centres) than in mobilising resistance to industrial restructuring. Jean Faniel's chapter highlights how, compared with the UK's liberal welfare regime, Belgian corporatist structures place trade unions in a more central role in responses to unemployment. Yet here too there remains a degree of ambiguity in how trade unionism engages with unemployed people, and we are left to reflect on how unions remain, to a large extent, organisations both of and for the employed.
Frédéric Royall shifts the focus to civil society, offering an interesting snapshot of the internal conflicts faced by third sector organisations in Ireland that are increasingly dependent on government funding, but therefore required to reproduce the assumptions and priorities of the state. The result has been employability services that – thanks to third sector organisations – are more responsive to the needs of local communities. But while adopting a service delivery remit has allowed for capacity building, local organisations can find themselves chasing contracts rather than representing their communities. Meanwhile, unemployed people themselves appear marginalised, passive service recipients within an increasingly professionalised third sector.
The final two chapters broaden the debate. Giugni and colleagues apply a welfare regime approach to argue that dominant conceptions of the welfare state define the political opportunities open to unemployed people to take collective action. Their typology highlights the potential importance of factors including: the coverage of the unemployment protection system, sanctions and conditionality attached to benefits, the structure and content of activation and employment conditions and labour market regulation. Finally, Christian Lahusen discusses the influence of the European Employment Strategy (EES) on media conceptualisations of the unemployment problem. Lahusen concludes that welfare regimes (and related political and institutional contexts) mean that there are considerable national-level variations in the dissemination and mediation of debates on unemployment, but that the EES has acted as institutional broker and ‘booster’ across EU states.
On the whole, Giugni and colleagues demonstrate the potentially vital role of collective responses, but also pull no punches in exposing (and then explaining) how and why trade unions and other non-governmental organisations have sometimes failed to produce coherent demands with respect to unemployment policy. As with many texts drawn from broad-ranging EU projects, this book can seem a little disjointed at times – a conclusions chapter may have been helpful in reviewing common themes and driving home key messages. However, there are some excellent individual contributions (with the chapters by Royall and Richards among the best). And as EU welfare states face the prospect of a prolonged period of high unemployment, this book could not be timelier. Despite the efforts of some policy makers to ‘blame the victims’, unemployment remains a collective problem. The Politics of Unemployment in Europe will help readers to grapple with the opportunities and challenges around collective action in response to the continuing crisis.
