Murat Birdal's book on the Ottoman Public Debt Administration (OPDA) is a timely reminder of some of the ways in which public debt, international monetary flows, direct foreign investments, and fiscal regimes of the world economy changed and were modified in the wake of the Great Depression of the late 19th century—themes that are again under discussion today in the midst of another major crisis of capitalism. In a study the author describes as combining the world-systems perspective with an institutional analysis, Birdal looks at the Ottoman Empire's relation to European (British and French, to be specific) financial institutions. He tells the story of how options for domestic borrowing from the local financiers, the infamous Galata bankers, were exhausted around the mid-19th century and how the Ottoman financial bureaucracy reluctantly turned to external borrowing in the aftermath of the Crimean War. The debt default following the Russian war in 1877 in the midst of the Great Depression and the establishment of the OPDA by British and French creditors to recuperate Ottoman debt form the main focus of the book.
Birdal then explains in some detail the organizational structure of the OPDA and how it administered revenues from certain commodities (salt, silk, spirits, fisheries, and, most important, tobacco) over which it was granted monopoly rights until the Ottoman debt was recuperated. He emphasizes how capital flows into the empire radically increased after this and underlines the transformative impact the OPDA's administrative practices had on the Ottoman bureaucracy (a new institutional framework in the fiscal system and new technologies of production, which were then taken up by the Ottoman administration). He also shows how the OPDA facilitated foreign direct investment in the empire, especially for the construction and operation of a number of railway lines. Based on the author's doctoral dissertation, the book lays down in a concise and comprehensive manner (although the contribution of the game-theoretic model in Chapter 3 to the overall argument remains doubtful) the workings of an international commission set up by British and French creditors, which ultimately ran whole sectors of the Ottoman economy. It thus opens up a number of empirical and theoretical issues.
Despite the author's reliance on it, world-systems theory is not the only theoretical model alternative to the neoclassical, comparative-advantage, international trade theory, which explains the debt relationship on the basis of imperialism. And despite the author's contention that one of the major theoretical contributions of the book is to highlight the transformative impact of European practices on the local administration and economy, the dual role of such interventions has already been well demonstrated in more nuanced works ranging from Aijaz Ahmad's “Marx on India” (in In Theory: Classes, Nations, Literatures, Aijaz Ahmed [London: Verso, 1994]) to Bill Warren's Imperialism (London: Verso, 1980) and Roger Owen's State, Power and Politics in the Making of the Modern Middle East (London: Routledge, 1992), among others. The emphasis on unequal trade relations between the core and the periphery underlying the understanding of imperialism inherent in world-systems theory has long been criticized for its neglect of property and production relations, for example, and for the division of the world into a core and periphery that remains geographically and temporally ill defined. There is more to this criticism than simply the often mentioned dichotomy between “internal and external dynamics.” This weakness is apparent in the book's failure to take into account many important aspects of the transformation in the Ottoman tax regime (tax farming taking the form of domestic borrowing, for instance), or the transition from a provisionalist mentality to more market-oriented institutional arrangements in the production and distribution of major agricultural commodities such as grain, olive oil, and so forth, over the course of the 19th century. This major omission of the book amounts to silencing the voices of local actors (administrators, cultivators, etc.) and results in a failure to address the nature and dynamics of local institutional innovations in fiscal, administrative, and economic spheres.
Birdal states that he is combining world-systems theory with an institutional analysis. The problem with neoclassical institutional analyses (à la Douglass North et al.) is that they have a tendency to turn into a catalogue of absences and presences whereby, rather circularly, the ahistorically idealized “successful institutions” of the West (usually meaning either Britain or France) are sought in the target country, and the absence of such idealized entities there suffices for an explanation of failure. Rather than falling into a nativist defensiveness of the “we had it, too” kind, the way to escape this kind of reductionism seems to be to locate institutions (both in Europe and elsewhere) historically in their respective fiscal and administrative (and political) contexts. The corporation, modern accounting techniques, state budgets, commissions of reform, and taxation, for example, each had its own administrative and fiscal contexts. It would have been more interesting to try to see the innovations and modifications in existing institutions and then ask how this process was shaped by a combination of domestic and international power configurations at specific times, paying due attention to the local and global actors within those configurations. It would then become possible to better analyze how the OPDA operated in this more carefully drawn complicated framework, as well as the points of contention and struggle from the point of view of the fundamental fiscal and administrative reorganization of the empire (the overhaul of the taxation system, codification of law, experimentation with novel administrative practices, etc.)—issues that the author fails to address.
The author is right in arguing for the importance of institutional innovations, but it is hard to claim, as he seems to do as a result of his neglect of the wider transformation in the Ottoman administration and economy, that the OPDA was a primary source for this; there were a host of channels through which knowledge transfers took place (in fiscality, administrative practices, law, etc.) throughout the century, and many were in different ways implicated in power relations. The OPDA, however, was not the only conduit for the transfer of knowledge, and it was not the most egalitarian of these conduits. Therefore it was bound to create resistance within the Ottoman administration.
Arguably the most interesting chapter of the book is the one on the tobacco sector and the Régie company, in which Birdal tells the story of how the company farmed out from the OPDA the monopoly right to control the sale and distribution of tobacco within the empire as well as the right to collect the tobacco tithe. He also traces changes in production and trade patterns exclusively from the reports of the company and the OPDA. This chapter would have provided a good opportunity to see how the production and trade of tobacco was transformed in the empire had the author carried out a more comprehensive analysis of the Ottoman regulation of tobacco production and trade prior to the establishment of the Régie. It would then have been possible, for example, to compare the change with that of grain production and trade, which in the course of the century was increasingly released from the logic of provisionalism. There is more to this—that is, the attempt to institutionalize a new domestic trade regime—than a simple story of increased fiscal efficiency through European intervention. To do this, however, would have required research in the Ottoman sources, which might have brought to the analysis the sense of historical dynamics and the agency of the local actors, which are sorely lacking in the book.
Overall, this is a well-written book as far as the internal organization and workings of the OPDA are concerned and amply demonstrates some of its consequences on the Ottoman economy of the 19th century. In this respect, it will be a valuable source for economic historians of the region.
