In The Changing Dynamic of Cuban Civil Society, Alexander Gray and Antoni Kapcia successfully critique the political agendas and analytical assumptions implicit in studies of Cuban civil society. They show how competing ideologies have obscured a sustained analysis of participatory democracy on the island, and their collection offers an important alternative approach. Specifically, the essays investigate how Cuban civil society was imagined and transformed after the dramatic social and economic upheaval following the loss of Soviet subsidies in the 1990s. The collection presents both a broader historical examination of the role of civil society organisations in the Revolutionary process, as well as ethnographic insight into how groups and individuals operate on the ground.
Throughout the collection, the authors highlight the heterogeneity of Cuban perspectives and complicate representations of the Cuban government as a unified entity devoid of contestation. For instance, during the 1990s a debate erupted regarding the role of civil society among Cuban academics and within the state-controlled press. An important essay by Michelle Marín-Dogan outlines that debate and its resurgence a decade later, sparked by the publication of Cuban philosopher Jorge Luis Acanda's book. Marín-Dogan provides a close reading of the competing interpretations of Marxism that played a central role in this dialogue. Her examination raises a general theme that weaves throughout the essays – a shift in the Cuban government from ‘building’ the Revolution to ‘protecting’ revolutionary gains, especially in the fields of education, nutrition and healthcare.
Taken together, the essays paint a complex picture of Cuban life under austerity in which divisions between official and non-state structures were severely blurred (p. 11). For example, Miren Uriarte describes how ‘neighborhood movements’ emerged in Havana in the 1990s to respond to the inability of the centralised government to manage local needs, such as garbage collection. Yet despite the potential for neighbourhood-level planning and initiatives, the groups often confronted bureaucrats who worried that decentralised control would result in greater inequalities.
At the same time that neighbourhood movements met with resistance, other civil society groups gained autonomy. In his chapter on Cuban entrepreneurship, Francisco Domínguez argues that with the creation of the agricultural cooperatives, the Unidades Básicas de Producción Cooperativa (UBPC), in 1993, Cuban agriculture presented the most significant structural transformations in civil society (p. 74). Domínguez contends that the establishment of the UBPCs reflects a critical loosening of state ownership and points out that by 1999 the private sector held up to 76 per cent of arable land, while state owned farms had dropped to 24 per cent (p. 74). Similarly, Christine Ayorinde details the re-emergence of religious organisations after the Cuban state prohibited discrimination against believers in 1992 (p. 144). In addition to exploring the political potential of Afro-Cuban religious groups, Ayorinde describes how the state agency, Oficina para la Atención a los Asuntos Religiosos, collaborated with Christian religious organisations to combat crime and enforce a ‘revolutionary morality’ during the crisis.
In the second half of the collection, authors consider the role of international organisations in the building of Cuban civil society. In his chapter on NGOs, Alexander Gray emphasises how the Central Committee of Cuba's Communist Party defined civil society as a ‘socialist’ construct that included NGOs acting within the law. Gray makes the critical distinction between ‘cooperation’ and ‘solidarity’ to explain how NGOs might not share the ideology of Cuban state socialism but still cooperate to achieve common objectives. Gray also observes that, even as NGOs were tentatively embraced, profound divisions among state functionaries remained. Many officials believed that NGOs were fundamentally incompatible with a socialist system that relied on the state to meet the principal needs of citizens. Also looking at international organisations, Nino Pagliccia draws on his extensive experience as an activist to discuss Canadian solidarity efforts in Cuba. He distinguishes between charity efforts, NGOs, and solidarity activism, which he describes as ‘people-to-people’ programs that include Pastors for Peace, the Ernesto Che Guevara Volutneer Work Brigade, and the Canadian Network on Cuba. Pagliccia often stops short, however, of questioning the assumptions behind solidarity activism or interrogating how Canadian relationships may, like NGOs, undermine state power. It would have been interesting to ascertain how Cuban conceptions of ‘socialist’ civil society conflicted with notions of international solidarity promoted by foreign solidarity groups.
In their concluding remarks, Gray and Kapcia remain optimistic that Cuban civil society does not pose a threat to the state, but represents ‘a building of the Revolution’ by contributing to the humanitarian goals of the Cuban government (p. 188). The collection provides a solid point of departure for future research on Cuba and raises a number of key questions: How has the rise of civil society groups affected state-sponsored organisations such as the Committees for the Defence of the Revolution or the Federation of Cuban Women? Is it true, as some Cuban leaders feared, that an expansion of civil society organisations has increased gender, racial and class inequalities? On a more reflexive note, how might the tensions between Western conceptions of civil society and Cuban ideas transform the assumptions of foreign NGOs about the universality of their projects? Furthermore, if we expand the insights of The Changing Dynamic of Cuban Civil Society to comparative studies of Latin America, the Cuban case allows us to reflect upon the parochialism of analytical and political frameworks that assume that civil society is by definition always in opposition to the state.
