This monograph is based on an earlier doctoral dissertation, ‘South West Africa People's Organization of Namibia as a non-state actor in the Namibian issue’. It has shifted its focus to ‘a special context of a conflict-resolution scheme that taxed the diplomatic and political wit of some major international actors’ (1). The emphasis on international diplomacy and especially the negotiations between the United Nations, South Africa and the liberation movement SWAPO is enhanced with the inclusion of the original documents that were relevant for the Namibian independence process since the League of Nations and the establishment of the UN Trusteeship Council. However, the book, one third of which consists of appendices (as well as many more pages containing the reproduction of relevant documents), remains disappointingly descriptive and lacks analytical depth. Much to the surprise of this reviewer, the Nigerian author fails to give sufficient recognition to the roles played by the frontline states in the negotiations during the 1980s and, even more surprisingly, the relevance of Nigeria's mediation under the then military junta led by Obasanjo.
Eight chapters present a summary, starting with the nineteenth-century history and ending with the conclusion of negotiations prior to the implementation of United Nations Security Council Resolution 435 in 1978. Most notable in a positive sense is that the author refrains from a ‘patriotic history’. He does not shy away from acknowledging that the liberation movement had an external and an internal wing, the representatives of which at times differed considerably on substantive policy issues. He also acknowledges that SWAPO was never the sole agency of the Namibian people (93), and stresses that SWAPO did not achieve national sovereignty through armed struggle, which ‘did not reach the scale of success of other such liberation groups’ (129).
Such realistic assessments contrast with the odd Pan-African perspective in literature of a similar kind, often guided by a triumphant anti-imperialist diction, celebrating anti-colonial struggles by definition as heroic victories over settler colonialism and its Western allies against all odds. On the other hand, the real processes behind the negotiated settlement remain vague and often invisible. Several sloppy mistakes are also disturbing. Riaan Eksteen, the South African permanent representative to the United Nations between 1976 and 1981, had never – as claimed in the book – been the South African foreign minister (146), and the first name of the German General von Trotha – who issued the infamous extermination order against the Herero in 1904 – was not Louis but Lothar (25). It is also wrong to imply that the German merchant Adolph Lüderitz, who paved the way for the official occupation of the territory, secured the largest prize (19): he disappeared long before the diamonds were discovered on the land he had fraudulently ‘purchased’. The process by which Namibia turned into a colonial prey from which South Africa parted only reluctantly because of its wealth in natural resources happened only later.
