The 1960s is a decade of increasing interest to both historians and art historians of Japan as a time when Japanese people were centrally implicated in global processes of resistance and creativity as well as the much more popularly understood emergence of Japan within a globalized postwar capitalist economy. In Money, Trains, and Guillotines, William Marotti brings these two disciplinary traditions of history and art history together in a conversation about the relationship between avant-garde art, commerce, the Japanese state, and revolutionary politics. His book is an important intervention into both how we understand Japan in the middle decades of the twentieth century and the possibilities of art to speak truth to power and to help imagine alternatives to the realities of the present.
Structurally, Marotti sets out his book in three discrete sections, with each section containing several interlinked chapters and a brief framing introduction. This structure allows Marotti to narrow in on case studies drawn from the influential Yomiuri Indépendant, an unjuried annual exhibition that ran from 1949 to 1964, with a particular focus on its influence on the “long decade of the sixties” (p. 320). The core of the book is supported by a useful chronology of events and over 120 illustrations, 19 of which are provided in full color. Readers unfamiliar with the artworks discussed are thus given a direct representation of their form and the contexts in which they were produced. Marotti should be commended for what must have been a very large amount of time and work required to obtain permissions for the reproduction of such an array of influential postwar art. For this alone the book is a necessary addition to any serious research library.
However, the book does not have value solely as an archival collection. Marotti's accompanying analysis importantly eschews chronology—his approach is theoretical, thematic, and, in keeping with the spirit of the book, experimental. As Marotti outlines in his introduction, the decision to organize his extensive material around several case studies allows him the freedom to innovate with “horizontal forays to the broader political field” and lengthy considerations of earlier historical moments revealing “the potent combination of conflicting legacies and interests within which . . . historical actors moved and the full range of heterological possibilities with which they engaged” (p. 5). The legacies and interests explored in the first section include Meiji-era criminal codes on currency imitation; legal strictures against both obscenity and collective action seen to not be in the interests of public welfare; the centrality of the emperor to Occupation-era constitutional revision; and the emergence of shakai tsūnen (which Marotti renders variably as “common sense” and “community standards”) as a core legal doctrine (pp. 78–81).
The second section focuses specifically on the history of the Yomiuri Indépendant, with a particular emphasis on its latter years in the lead-up to the 1964 Tokyo Olympics. Here, Marotti traces the development of the Yomiuri newspaper empire through its support for the (national) imperial project from the mid-1920s through the 1940s, its central role in Occupation-era battles over production control, and its later patronage of the art Indépendant. Marotti describes this patronage as a process of occluding the paper's historical “referents” of imperial complicity and anti-labor activism (p. 121). Nevertheless, as a reaction against the staid conservatism of the official art world and the increasingly uninspiring socialist realism of the Communist Party–affiliated Nihon Indépendant, the Yomiuri exhibition fostered an “enthusiastic and committed kind of playful competition . . . [which] addressed daily life as a space of hidden processes and concealed investments” (p. 132). Marotti's exploration of the connection of artistic innovation to the transformations of daily life evident in this period is for this reader the most rewarding of the three excellent sections, rich as it is with references to a range of artists and their work.
The final section explores how avant-garde artists responded to a newly quiescent Japan after the upheaval of the U.S.-Japan Security Treaty renewal controversy in 1960. Undeterred, artists such as Akasegawa Genpei (a core figure also in section one) continued to argue for the potential for radical artistic practices to disrupt the everyday and reveal “glimpses of emancipatory possibilities” (p. 206).
Money, Trains, and Guillotines has its origins as a research project in the 1990s, but the long wait was well worth it. This book will form a major addition to my teaching, providing an important counter-balance to the dominant narrative of a postwar Japan marching in drumbeat towards a capitalist future. In illuminating the ways in which culture and radical politics were enmeshed at this key juncture of postwar Japanese history, Marotti also highlights the (arguably continued) importance of the everyday as “the central political arena for dissent and for policing” (p. 315).
