While several new ethnographies explore the complexity of youth identity politics in urban Africa as they relate to the expansion of Internet-based media, few have captured the complexity of a particular city's youth culture by starting at the Internet café itself. Based on several years of fieldwork in Accra, Ghana, Jenna Burrell's excellent new book addresses a number of important theoretical issues, including the materiality of new digital technologies, the usefulness of the concept of the digital divide, and the emerging religious beliefs surrounding the risks and possibilities of the immaterial online world. Like spiritual forces, the Internet in Ghana is imagined to overcome standard limitations of space and time to facilitate action in non-material worlds. The strength of Burrell's analysis lies in her historical approach to Internet-based media and the deep ethnographic description she provides.
Burrell's focus is on young, marginalized users of the Internet in Ghana, whose primary use of the Internet is to expand their social networks and connections. But the Internet café is only the starting point for her larger investigation, which also took her to youth club meetings, school yards, dormitories, and international conferences on the information society. Moving beyond simple global/local binaries, the stories she tells of Ghana's Internet cafés and their users are about struggles by Ghanaian youth to connect to the rest of the world while imagining themselves in it. Burrell is careful to define marginality not as absolute exclusion but rather as non-centrality, or relational disadvantage. Despite her focus on marginality, Burrell's approach is optimistic, and the book is positive in tone. She looks not just at deprivations but also at the many novel engagements and practices that emerge from the margins – ranging from the narrative formats of Internet scamming to the manual labor involved in dealing metal scrap and disposing of digital waste. She concludes that the real story of Ghana's marginalized Internet users is one of resilience and of a promising capacity for making use of technology that was not designed with them in mind.
One of the most significant overall contributions of the book is her critique of the overreliance upon the concepts of the information society and the ‘digital divide’ in work on the expansion of digital technologies in Africa. She convincingly argues that seeing populations in urban Africa and other economic peripheries principally as ‘non-users’ of new digital technologies is an analytical dead end. By exploring the discourse produced at Ghana's 2005 UN-sponsored World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS), Burrell further deconstructs the depiction of information as a politically neutral social good. She critiques WSIS's repeated calls for inclusion without acknowledging the trade-offs and downsides to this new global order. She characterizes attempts by development organizations to speak for ostensibly grassroots organizations (while actually excluding many of these same organizations) as a type of ventriloquism that reaffirms an official institutional discourse rather than challenging or questioning it. The result has been an artificial sense of inclusiveness that is difficult to understand without ethnographic research like Burrell's.
Her focus in a separate chapter on the issue of digital waste – second-hand computers being sold to Ghana – furthers her important materialist critique of the digital divide. Ghana's crisis of ‘e-waste’ is not one of lacking access to computers but about Africa continuing to be a dumping ground for used Western goods. Burrell's focus on e-waste usefully shifts the discussion toward the relevant issues of international trade and draws attention to the entire material process including distribution, repair, and eventual disposal of new digital technologies in Africa.
While Burrell offers a much needed ethnographic exploration of the emergent culture of African Internet cafés, she leaves certain issues unexplored. For example, because her focus is largely on youth, there is a noticeable absence of discussion of older Internet users in the book. Further, the explicit focus on Internet cafés with desktop computers means that Burrell neglects the impact of cell phones and of mobile Internet access. However, the book's focus on youth and the negotiation of marginality makes it an important text for scholars in African Studies, Science and Technology Studies, Anthropology, and related fields. Burrell's work is very readable; this book would be relevant and approachable in an upper-level undergraduate classroom. Burrell has made an important contribution to the study of how new Internet-based technologies are mediating youth identity politics and social networks in Accra and beyond.
