It is sobering indeed to reflect on Victorian poisoning. The crime statistics depict a poisoning epidemic in the 1840s, but these, of course, are compiled from convictions. How many more deaths were intentionally expedited more subtly than by the grotesqueries of arsenic? Or should we really read these convictions as poisonings? Might they be merely the reflexes of a paranoid society, witchcraft prosecutions under the sanction of analytical chemistry? Only convince yourself that an unexpected death is unnatural and it will be easy to conjure all manner of suspicious antecedent acts by possibly interested persons, many of them female. For Victorian ingestion was gendered. It belonged to the domestic arena of trust, and therefore of vulnerability. But a few hangings will reassure: control exists; invisible murder cannot be happening.
Focusing on the mid-Victorian period, Ian Burney's story is mainly one of futile attempts at stabilization, to make clear that poisonings were anomalous events and the problem was under control. The possibility that, as had been the case in imperial Rome or in Renaissance Italy, persons could pursue their interests by insidiously doing away with their rivals was, for Victorian opinion-shapers, unacceptable. In those earlier ages, poisoning had been of a piece with the prevailing decadence and lack of liberty. But in a meritocracy of (male) liberal individualism, where interests could be successfully pursued legally, openly and honestly, widespread poisoning should not have been happening. Success was to come from hard work, not through convenient deaths of the achievers at the hands of toadies who had wormed their way into the circle of ingestive intimacy. The problem could not be domesticity itself – the happy home was to be the end product of all that individualism – hence it must represent some perverted form of domesticity.
And yet every tactic of containment seemed to backfire. Surely the poisoner must be revealed under the gaze of the analytical chemist, whose art, having languished for centuries, was now flourishing thanks to the conceptual, methodological and instrumental achievements of the chemical revolution. But chemistry's authority came precisely because of its own instability. New means for testing for specific poisons were becoming available, but rapidly growing knowledge – of the ways in which multiple substances might exhibit similar familial responses to what had been supposed a test for a single poison, or of the complicated metabolisms and manifestations of different exogenous substances – came at a cost to certainty. The tragic figure in Burney's story is Alfred Swaine Taylor, the Guy's Hospital professor of chemistry and medical jurisprudence. The greatest authority was equally the person best placed to undermine authority; in the courtroom, Taylor's wide reading and considerable experience simply provided exceptions to generalities that could be exploited by clever barristers. On the side of synthesis, too, chemistry, which was to have given us a better control of poison, brought new forms of poison, like strychnine, which further challenged analysts' ingenuities.
Likewise, the presumption that general medical practitioners could be the front line in detecting poisoning was undermined inasmuch as two of the most celebrated poisoners – Palmer and Smethhurst – were general practitioners, and it was compromised by the fact that effective medicines were poisons at some dosage. Medical education was, of necessity, education in poisoning. Even the institutions of meritocracy that were to free the flow of capital and safeguard commerce – the partnership laws, friendly societies and life-insurance schemes, and new financial instruments – turned out to provide incentives for poisoning. An underregulated life-insurance industry, in particular, supplied the poisoner with a safe investment that could be called in at one's convenience.
This is a cultural history, but in no narrow sense. Burney deals with the handling of poisoning by leader-writers and novelists (and those such as Charles Dickens who were both), but he also leads us masterfully through technicalities of analytical chemistry, of financial instruments, of legal theories of evidence and proof. This book is exemplary in mapping, always accessibly, the intricate reciprocity between culture and toxicological technicalities. I have one concern: that in this brief book, Burney, mordant analyst of irony, has not pushed as hard as he might have towards a bigger picture. Are the persistence of poisoning and the inability to contain it perhaps symptomatic of structural features? For the most part, Burney's focus is on middle-class poisoners and his concept of poisoning is conventional. He does discuss the burial club scandals of the 1840s, in which parents profited from the deaths of infants enrolled in multiple burial clubs, but issues of the expediency of expedited death arose in connection with baby-farming, the doping of infants with opiates (and more generally what historians of infanticide have recognized as underinvestment in infant life) and the marketing of adulterated and unsound foods or waters.
Burney's book is timely. We too, particularly in modern America, live in an age fascinated with forensic science. Now, as then, a free society evidently cannot actually prevent people from killing each other; how wonderful then that the cadres of hair, paint and fibre analysts can do such miracles. Murder will out!
