Introduction
In Health Technology Assessment (HTA), clinical and economic evidence are assessed in the regulatory and reimbursement environments, with community input considered as complementary to this. At the same time, stakeholders across the sector are calling for more meaningful community engagement; however, we will not be able to reach this goal without a significant shift.
The Centre for Community-Driven Research (CCDR) was established in 2012 and is a nonprofit organization bringing much needed change to the way we think about community engagement in health and research. Since CCDR was established we have been testing and implementing systematic and independent approaches to community engagement and feedback processes across the health system.
This article is based on the experience of CCDR as an international agency and outlines three system changes that need to be made to advance community engagement in decisions about health and HTA. This paper comes from the perspective of acknowledging personal experience as evidence and engaging everyday people in the process, as opposed to representation on panels and committees. The three key areas of change that are discussed include building holistic evidence, creating supportive environments, and infrastructure for community engagement, with the term community referring to people affected by disease or health conditions and their carers/families.
Building holistic evidence
The first change needed is to acknowledge that the experience of a person with a treatment, device, diagnostic test, or within a health system is not just a “story.” When collected systematically and under the correct conditions, it is evidence and needs to be considered as such. The challenge however is ensuring that methodologies are not only designed to collect data needed by researchers, governments, and HTA bodies to inform decisions, but to leave space to discover the aspects of treatment and care that are important to people, in other words, community-driven research. In considering methodology, we also need to accept a volume of participation that is relevant to purpose, that is we do not necessarily need large volumes of data (big data), but we do need data that has depth and breadth (deep data) and is representative of different demographics (Reference Booth1;Reference Vasileiou, Barnett, Thorpe and Young2). Once we have that data, we need to value and respect it and not be compelled to process it to the point that it turns back into economic data.
The collection of robust data is of course important (Reference Facey, Boivin, Gracia, Ploug Hansen, Lo Scalzo and Mossman3); however, in the context of community engagement, equally important—and a contributing factor in the quality of data collected—is balancing this with an empathetic approach. Empathy in research helps to build a relationship of trust and candidness between the researcher and participant (Reference Briony and Ficklin4). While it is a somewhat natural part of qualitative methodologies, empathy in research includes making sure the questions asked of people are aligned with their values and priorities and considers who is best placed to conduct the research. Using CCDR's approach as an example, we have found that having trained researchers who are also health professionals (primarily registered nurses) gives the participant the confidence to share their experience in a safe and supportive environment and encourages a more in-depth description of events.
There are concepts in community engagement that are accepted as “best practice”; however, they do not always hold the level of evidence that is expected in the health system (Reference Martinez, Carolan, O'Donnell, Diaz and Freeman5;Reference MacQueen, Bhan, Frohlich, Holzer and Sugarman6). Just as we have levels of evidence to guide clinical data, to make the change we need to look forward and develop levels of evidence for personal experience data and individual feedback, while also looking back to interrogate the evidence that current “best practice” is based on to make sure we are following the right path.
To build experiential evidence, we need this to be a normal part of the process of community engagement, however we also need to be careful not to institutionalize it. One way to address this is by taking a holistic approach to research methodology so that if people are giving their time, we ensure that their documented experience has an impact beyond one, single HTA decision. While there is a clear need for better approaches to community engagement in the context of HTA, this is only one part of the health system and only one part of a person's experience, which may have been traumatic:
“When I participated in the PEEKFootnote 1 study the researcher conducted an hour-long recorded interview with me where I was given the opportunity to answer some open-ended questions. She listened to my story with great compassion and sensitivity. CCDR is a place where patients can talk about what is important to them … This means that a patient only needs to share their experience extensively once and would not need to repeatedly recall traumatic experiences in order to provide input to HTA. This also means that a patient or carer who has been interviewed can contribute to HTA even though they may not otherwise be aware that their contribution in these processes was possible.”
Building supportive environments
Building supportive environments includes challenging some of the outdated models and language we use in the context of community engagement. Moving away from top-down approaches and concepts such as “consumer training” will lead to a focus on creating supportive and appropriate environments for community engagement.
From our own experience, “consumer training” is resource intensive and limited in its reach, which raises issues of inequity. Additionally, it is based on the notion that people need to understand the intricacies of research and policy to provide “appropriate” input (Reference Mosconi, Satolli, Colombo and Villano7) which in itself introduces a certain bias in the way people may present their experience or feedback. However, if our aim in engaging the community is more focused on understanding what their experience has been, and based on that expertise, what their expectations or recommendations for future treatment, care, information, and support are, there should not be such a need for “training.” We should be asking ourselves, for example, whether a person who has lived with multiple sclerosis for 20 years needs to undergo training in order for their experience to be credible?
If we can step away from this concept of training, the focus then moves toward creating supportive environments. This includes making sure we provide people with the context in which decisions are made, asking appropriate questions of the community based on their area of expertise and ensuring that those asking the questions have a clear sense of the value of patient experience. The longer-term and perhaps more aspirational goal is then to create environments where the community act as the “host” of discussion, rather than the “guests.”
Infrastructure for community engagement
To really move forward and accept personal experience as evidence, we have to consider the infrastructure needed to support sustainability and independence in community engagement. When we talk about infrastructure we often think of the physical structures and systems needed to deliver health services, basic research, clinical trials, and so on. What we do not often talk about is the infrastructure needed to create an environment that supports systematic and independent community engagement. This needs to part of the new language of community engagement in HTA and the health sector more broadly.
The need for infrastructure is aligned with independence and transparency. There are two primary approaches in building sustainable community engagement. The first is to take a top-down approach where the mechanisms, methodology, and processes sit within and are ultimately decided by government agencies, with the community feeding up into those systems. The second is one of community empowerment and takes a more bottom-up approach where mechanisms, methodology, and processes are designed by and sit within the community. There are questions of where the funding for community-driven approaches can and should come from, however, regardless of the source of funding so long as it is at arms-length and the community are empowered to drive, develop, and own the process, it remains inherently less influenced than a top-down approach. Likewise, when the community are custodians of their own data, this has the immediate impact of increasing transparency as the risk of community input getting lost in the system is significantly reduced.
Individual change
The health system changes needed to improve community engagement in HTA decisions will take time and for some, a fair amount of convincing. Our approach however has been to create the systems that work for people and the health charities that support them, and we aim to lead by example and action.
There are however some immediate steps that each of us working in the sector can take to begin to change the way we engage with the community and these have been noted throughout this paper. For today however, one very simple thing that we can all do to change the way we view community engagement is to lose the word “consumer” from our vocabulary. People diagnosed with various conditions have told us time and time again that they do not like or connect with this term. If we continue to use it, we are not listening. Perhaps we bring the language back to “people,” after all, people are people before and after they are patients.
As a final note, we all need to acknowledge the expertise that people diagnosed with various diseases or conditions have and make efforts to enter their world, rather than expecting them to continually adapt their experience to ours. None of this however can happen without the appropriate governance and leadership—led by people with lived experience—in place. An advocate explained this beautifully:
“As someone who has experienced cancer, the expertise I bring is the very fact that I have lived through the symptoms before I was diagnosed, been through the treatment, navigated the health system, and continue to deal with the side-effects. I hope that in sharing my experience I can add to the scientific process so that patient-centred care rather than pattern-centred care really does become the new normal. To spark thoughts about the value that patients and carers bring to research, that's worth fighting for.”
Acknowledgements
The author would like to acknowledge Professor Robert L. Sutherland AO FAA, Sally Crossing AM, Julie Morgan, and Cathy Sertori for their contributions to community engagement in health and research, and as advocates for all people. A special thank you also to Lillian, Anita, Lisa, Marilyn, Jay and Jo, and every person that has shared their experience to inform decisions about health and for their contribution to advocacy.
Financial support
There was no funding received for this work.
