What, exactly, is sacrifice? “Anthropological thought,” Rene Girard asserts, “has long regarded blood sacrifice as a kind of enigma, one which it endeavored to solve, but without success” (Sacrifice, ix), despite such groundbreaking efforts as Marcel Mauss and Henri Hubert’s definitive essay, “Sacrifice: Its Nature and Function.” But in his book, Girard proposes to place the study of sacrifice on strictly scientific grounds, and thus to finally expose its bloody, horrible secret.
For Girard, the sacred texts of Brahmanic Hinduism, the Rig Veda and the Brahmanas, are simply ‘sacrificial myths,’ which disguise the secret truth behind the rituals of sacrificial killing, which is what he calls “the scapegoat mechanism,” or “the single victim mechanism” (Sacrifice, 25-29). In Girard’s thinking of sacrificial ritual as scapegoat persecution, the sacrificial community, caught up in the escalating violence of “mimetic rivalry” (Sacrifice, 1-7) between competing individuals for prestige, status, and power, fastens upon a specific sacrificial victim (the scapegoat) upon whom to inflict its ‘sacred violence,’ and thereby establishes a brief moment of solidarity among the persecutors (the sacrificers) against their designated sacrificial victim. The sacrificial victim is then slain by the primal horde, only to be posthumously deified or immortalized as the ‘savior’ or ‘god’ whose self-sacrificial martyrdom brought about the salvation of the sacrificial community by warding off its self-destructive mimetic violence, which would otherwise have destroyed the sacrificial community (Sacrifice, 31-33).
Girard purports to find evidence of this ‘scapegoat mechanism’ in the sacred texts of the Brahmanic Hindu tradition, most notably the Purushasuktah,Footnote 1 which describes the creation of the cosmos and of the four castes of Hindu society from the dismembered body of a primordial macrocosmic man, “Purusha” (Sanskrit: ‘man’), who, in Girard’s reading, is simply the mythic disguise of the primordial human victim of this scapegoat mechanism (Sacrifice, 36-44). Although Girard concedes that certain self-critical, demystifying insights into the secret truth of scapegoat sacrifice exist within the sacred texts, he argues that the Hindu scriptures remain largely oblivious or blind to the scapegoat mechanism they conceal, which must instead be salvaged or recovered from the sacrificial sub-text by his distinctive version of the Freudian ‘hermeneutic of suspicion’ (ala Totem and Taboo). Girard then reads these sacred texts ‘against the grain’ to disclose precisely what is not said by the superficial text itself: “The Crime That Is Not There” (Sacrifice, 45-47), which is the sordid truth of the primeval collective murder of the aboriginal scapegoat victim.
But while conceding to the Brahmanic texts a certain self-demystifying insight into the secret truth of sacrifice, Girard instead privileges the Judeo-Christian scriptures, and especially the Gospel account of Jesus Christ’s crucifixion, as the definitive un-sacred texts which finally demystify sacrificial violence and its scapegoat mechanism (Sacrifice, x-xii), thereby inaugurating the world-historical course of Western secular modernity, which culminates with the virtually complete desacralization of sacrifice in the 21st Century postmodern world. The profound paradox of Girard’s thinking of Western secular modernity, however, is that, by exposing the scapegoat mechanism and its sacrificial violence as the sub-textual motive for the collective murder (Girard often calls it ‘lynching’) of the sacrificial victim, it is the Christian revelation itself, in Girard’s view, that effectively destroys the sacrificial rituals which enabled the sublimation of sacred violence in primitive religious cultures, and thereby unleashes the escalating violence of mimetic rivalry, which reaches a self-destructive climax with the catastrophic world wars and un-holy terrors of 20th and 21st Century Western European world history.Footnote 2
Rene Girard’s scandalous thesis—that ‘Western civilization’ is built upon the successive demystification and desacralization of the sacrificial rituals of scapegoat persecution and collective murder, which Christian revelation itself paradoxically threatens to destroy ‘Western civilization’—is certainly capable of compelling belief in certain intellectual circles, and even of soliciting a ‘conversion experience’ in his acolytes and disciples, called ‘Girardians,’ whose scholarly works have largely expounded those aspects of Girard’s thesis left unexplained by Girard himself. In this sub-Girardian genre, Scott Cowdell’s Rene Girard and Secular Modernity: Christ, Culture, and Crisis, admirably succeeds in succinctly explicating, in its three central chapters, “Mimesis, Modernity and Madness,” “Violence, the Sacred Canopy,” and “Scripture and Secularization,” the crucial elements of the Girardian thesis, while also supplementing this discussion with recourse to the scholarly texts of other Girardians.
For Cowdell, his ‘conversion’ to ‘Girardianism,’ described in his Preface (RGSM, ix), evidently helped to assuage certain malingering spiritual qualms about the future of the Christian revelation he had experienced while writing his earlier books, Is Jesus Unique?: A Study in Recent Christology, and Abiding Faith: Christianity Beyond Certainty, Anxiety, and Violence; and he strongly emphasizes the evangelical elements of Girard’s work, especially in his Conclusion, wherein Cowdell proselytizes for “The Need for Conversion” (RGSM, 171-173) to a Girardian Christianity, and advocates that contemporary humanity adopt a non-mimetic “Imitatio Christi” (RGSM,174) as the solution to the escalating violence of a completely secularized world “veer[ing] toward an apocalypse of self-destruction and environmental devastation,” in which sacrificial rituals no longer work to provide the “unifying, pacifying outcome” to mimetic rivalry and sacrificial violence “that the archaic sacred [once] delivered” (RGSM, 169-170).
But the question is whether Cowdell’s book, or Girard’s work, really provide a satisfactory solution to the crucial paradox of the Girardian thesis: that, by demystifying the scapegoat mechanism and its sacred violence without eliminating mimetic rivalry or providing a substitute for sacrificial ritual, Western secular modernity and the Christian revelation themselves have unleashed the escalating violence of mimetic rivalry and placed contemporary humanity on its fatal course toward self-destructive apocalypse. It might then be asked, following Girard’s recent attempts, after September 11th, to place the sacrificial violence of Islamist terrorism and its mimetic rival, the Western ‘war on terror,’ in this theoretical context,Footnote 3 whether the Western (Christian?) attempt to finally abolish sacrificial ritualism and its sacred violence doesn’t itself engender an escalating un-sacrificial violence far greater than that associated with the scapegoat mechanisms of primitive sacrificial cultures.
Further, considering Girard’s and Cowdells’ surprising neglect of the specifically Christian (Pauline or Catholic) doctrine of sacrifice, espoused in the “Epistle to the Hebrews” and canonized in the sacramental ritual of the Eucharist, it might also be asked whether the orthodox Christian interpretation of Jesus Christ’s self-sacrificial martyrdom might not provide a better method of sublimating sacrificial violence than the completely desacralized imitatio christi of ‘The Girardian Gospels.’
