For urban sociologists, Chicago is a kind of hometown. It is not always possible to trace the origins of a subdiscipline, but it is fair to say that urban sociology was “invented” by members of the Department of Sociology at the University of Chicago in the early decades of the twentieth century. Robert Park, Ernest Burgess and their colleagues set out an agenda for a distinct field of intellectual enquiry, most notably with the 1925 publication of The City: Suggestions for Investigation of Human Behavior in the Urban Environment. Both they and it went on to make easy targets for critical opposition, becoming the founding figures and the urtext against which later generations of urban scholars would define themselves.
The essays gathered in The City, Revisited developed out of a symposium held at the University of Chicago in 2007 to consider the legacy of the Chicago school thinkers, and to appraise the contributions of two more recent and competing “schools” of urban analysis in the US context: a Los Angeles school that coalesced around the analysis of postmodern urbanism in the 1980s (including Michael Dear, Edward Soja, Mike Davis and others), and a looser set of thinkers who have taken New York as their text since the 1960s (such as Jane Jacobs, William H. Whyte, Richard Sennett and Sharon Zukin). The location of these different currents in urban studies is not accidental; these urban contexts shape their intellectual focus. Critics working in New York have tended to focus on the built fabric and social life of dense urban neighbourhoods and their reshaping through gentrification. Angelenos have analysed the fragmentation and sprawl of a post-Fordist city without a centre. A revived Chicago school has a strong interest in urban politics and city government – especially the machine politics exemplified by the two mayors Daley, who between them ran the city for forty-three years between 1955 and 2011.
This is comparative urbanism as a kind of intercity rivalry, and there is some pleasurable belligerence in the exchanges collected here. The reader gets the sense that the parties to the debate enjoyed the whole thing – including the passing ad hominem and ad urbem swipes – but apart from the gratification of watching an intellectual play-fight, there is a question as to what the more disengaged or distant reader might learn from it all. Chicago, Los Angeles and New York are instructive in their differences, not least in underlining – as the editor Dennis R. Judd puts its – the “absence of a direct national role in urban land-use planning and political development [that] is unique to the United States” (17). They remain the nation's largest cities and they tend to dominate its urban imagination, but they do not necessarily capture the most interesting urban shifts or complex urban problems of the contemporary US – in respect of which Detroit, Phoenix, Miami, Seattle or New Orleans might all tell different and sometimes more pressing stories. And, as Terry Nichols Clark points out about the clientelism and patronage of Chicago politics, firmer comparisons could be made with “Taipei, Naples, Bogotá, Lagos” (221) than with any of its US counterparts. In a similar manner, New York might look to London as its most immediate comparator and competitor.
The collection is well framed by Judd's introductory essay, but as a whole it might have benefited from heavier editing. There is a degree of repetition, given that various contributors feel obliged to begin with their defence or critique of Park and Burgess. Some of the papers seem undercooked; you get the sense that they would have made rollicking conference presentations, but translate less well from the lectern to the page. (I was pleased, though, that no one picked up on Clark's two references to the “Frankfort school” of critical theory, giving rise to the nice notion that an otherwise unknown strand of western Marxism had developed in the state of Kentucky, which – unlike Germany – has a city of that name.)
It may not soothe interurban antagonisms to say that – at least on my reading – the most substantive individual pieces come from the more disinterested (or less clearly affiliated) “school” of New York. The contributions from David Halle and Andrew A. Beveridge, and from John Hull Mollenkopf, develop their analyses on the basis of telling demographic and socioeconomic comparisons. Robert A. Beauregard adds a pointed and fluent critical piece on the uses of urban theory and the analytical dead end that is any notion of a city's “radical uniqueness.” Most satisfying of all is Janet Abu-Lughod's essay on “Grounded Theory.” This may be a potted version of her 2007 book on Race, Space, and Riots in Chicago, New York, and Los Angeles, but her analysis of the twentieth-century histories of “riots” in the three cities is a concise masterclass in comparative urban studies.
