After spending months, if not years, executing a research project, presenting it at conferences, and drafting and redrafting the manuscript based on critical feedback from friends and colleagues, there are few things more disappointing and frustrating than having it bounced back mere days after submitting it to a journal for review. The dreaded desk rejection. Desk rejection is the process whereby an editor or an associate editor rejects a manuscript without the benefit of standard, blinded peer review by two to four subject-area experts. The desk reject is increasingly common as a tool of journal editors, and the merits of this tool are increasingly scrutinized within the academic community—as they should be. Anything that has the potential to impact the body of collective scientific knowledge is worthy of our careful consideration. This article represents my views on the practice of desk rejection, based on my experiences as an associate editor and international relations field editor of Political Research Quarterly (PRQ).Footnote 1 To be clear, I do not speak on behalf of the editorial team at PRQ, the PRQ editorial board, the Western Political Science Association, or SAGE Publishing. The opinions stated herein are my own.
Anything that has the potential to impact the body of collective scientific knowledge is worthy of our careful consideration.
To reject a manuscript, particularly without peer review, is one of the weightiest decisions that editors can make. Research is difficult, time-consuming work and the culmination of years of training and intellectual effort. Publishing success is high stakes, often impacting reputations, job prospects, and career trajectories. At the same time, decisions to review and potentially publish research also are salient. Reviewer time is precious and finite. Published research carries the weight of a rigorous process. Appearing in a scientific journal is the first step toward an idea representing accepted knowledge, and it will be treated (cited) as such. That is, these decisions are consequential on at least two fronts: for the author(s) and for the research community. For authors, it is hard enough to accept the often-harsh criticism associated with peer rejection of their research manuscript. When it is done by a single individual, after only a couple of days of consideration, it can feel particularly unjust and unsatisfying.
Given the salience of these decisions, it is only right that we want to understand the underlying logic behind desk rejections. Although I cannot speak for all editors, I can offer insight into my process. When considering a manuscript for peer review, I generally ask myself three questions. I first ask: Is it a good fit for the journal? “Fit”—an admittedly vague and frustrating concept—encompasses several areas in my decision making. It can be topical. Does the article comport with the journal’s subject or area mission? As an editor at a general-field journal, this rarely is an issue that motivates my desk rejections, but it is a more primary concern for many editors.
Fit can be the type of scholarly contribution represented by the manuscript. PRQ publishes original scientific research. Policy briefs, editorials, pedagogy, and state-of-the-field manuscripts are important contributions but do not fit within our mission. The most common of these types of contributions that I receive at PRQ are what I categorize as policy briefs. These are manuscripts that advance a thesis, related to a policy position, and then use the remainder of the paper to build a case for a policy recommendation. Some manuscripts are well written and argued but must be refused on the grounds that they do not fit the journal’s mission.
Finally, fit can be relative to the journal audience. As an editor at a general-field journal, I look for manuscripts that cast a wide audience net. Admittedly, it is somewhat subjective to assess which contributions will appeal to a broader audience. We can, however, ask the extent to which the theory, insights, data, or methods are portable to other fields and subfields or will be of interest to scholars outside of the narrow field or subfield of the submission.
The second question I ask is: How well is the paper executed? Most papers have flaws, and those flaws may come up during a peer-review process. Based on the reviewers’ recommendations and my own judgment, a decision is made as to whether the level of revisions needed is reasonable for an offer to revise and resubmit. Some manuscripts, however, simply are not ready for peer review. This may be because of the magnitude of a single problem—for example, a theory that lacks logical consistency or validity. Or it could be the sheer accumulation of smaller problems. When the scale of problems and challenges is beyond what would be reasonable for an offer to revise, and when this is obvious from the initial reading, then a decision to review simply is not a practical option. To do so would be a waste of both the author’s and the reviewers’ valuable time.
The third question I ask is: Does the contribution meet the expectation of the journal? This criterion will vary by journal, but PRQ’s mission statement mandates that manuscripts make “exceptional contributions to specialized fields” or engage questions that “multiple subfields or approaches within political science would find important.” Assessments such as these have an obvious subjective component, and intelligent people may disagree. As an editor covering an entire field (i.e., international relations), it may not always be clear to me whether a manuscript represents an “exceptional” contribution. If I am at all unsure, I default toward reviewing and letting the subject-area specialists decide. There are times, however, when I feel confident that the contribution does not match well with the mission of the journal and, consequently, rule that peer review is not necessary. It is impossible to list all of the types of issues that would represent a contribution that does not match well with the journal’s mission. However, the most common type that I receive that elicits a desk rejection is the relatively minor contribution to well-established knowledge. The core of the scientific enterprise is normal science, which these papers represent; however, that type of contribution, given the mission of PRQ, is better suited to more specialized subfield journals.
When determining whether a paper will be peer reviewed, I consider these criteria: fit, execution, and contribution. It is not a perfect set of decision rules and still requires me to make what are considered subjective judgments. Of course, I have made mistakes, perhaps rejecting manuscripts that would have made it through peer review and been of interest to a general audience. Moreover, the PRQ reviewers occasionally let me know when they believe a paper I sent them to review should have been desk rejected. Ultimately, however, editors must exercise judgment. Whether it is the decision to review, to offer a revise and resubmit, or to publish, and no matter how objective their intent, editors always will rely on a certain level of subjective judgment. Indeed, editors are chosen for and expected to exercise their judgment. Editorial judgment represents an important part of how they influence the journal. As a check on this, we mitigate the influence of any single editor’s judgment on the discipline by periodic turnover in editorial teams—which is good for the profession.
At this point, what might stand out to readers is what I have failed to mention. I have not discussed limited journal space and the difficulty in securing reviewers, which sometimes are cited as reasons for increased desk rejections. It is true that journal space is finite, and it would be impossible to publish every manuscript received for review. It also is true that many editors, including me, identify securing reviewers as the most difficult part of the position. If we were to review every submitted manuscript, it would slow down the process dramatically: extending the time required to find qualified and willing reviewers and, in turn, increasing review time. These are valid concerns, but I have never desk rejected a manuscript because of concerns about journal space or reviewer availability. That we may run out of space or reviewers has never even given me pause in sending out a paper for evaluation. If a manuscript is a good fit, is reasonably executed, and represents a contribution consistent with the journal’s mission, I send it out for review. The burden of finding reviewers and space is mine.
Desk rejection can be an important tool for editors to signal authors that their manuscript does not fit the journal’s mission or is not quite ready for the peer-review process. We do not do authors any favors by wasting two to four months (or longer) of their time. Time is a finite and valuable resource, particularly for graduate students and tenure-track faculty. Saving their precious time by not reviewing a paper to which the editor is not committed and that has little chance of making it through the peer-review process is a strength, not a weakness, of the process.Footnote 2 That time would be better spent by authors submitting their manuscript to a more appropriate journal or in revamping the research.
Desk rejection can be an important tool for editors to signal authors that their manuscript does not fit the journal’s mission or is not quite ready for the peer-review process.
A reasonable counterargument is that every paper deserves to be reviewed, particularly because—even in rejection—authors may receive feedback that can be used to improve the work. I disagree. We all should take reviewer comments seriously, and papers often are improved through rejection and revision. Paper-improving comments, however, at best are an ancillary benefit of manuscript rejection. Reviewers make recommendations to an editor and their comments act to justify those recommendations; they are building a case. Editors use those comments and recommendations to make their decision. Including comments in decision letters facilitates transparency in the decision-making process. The point of the process, however, is not to provide comments. Instead, it is to determine whether a scientific paper is ready to be published in the particular journal to which it was submitted.
