This new collection of essays critically examines the ways in which norms of rights, responsibilities, welfare and the ethic of care are – or arguably ought to be – deployed in family law, and the gender implications of these varying approaches. Each chapter presents a case-study of a different aspect of family law, involving consideration of some, though not all, of these norms. Although ‘rights’ and ‘gender’ are the central themes picked out in the title of the collection, and gender is indeed a consistent theme throughout the essays, not all of the essays deal with rights, and those that do so vary as to whether they offer a critique or an uncritical acceptance of rights discourse and the value of rights in the relevant area. In their first chapter, the editors offer a summary of the arguments for and against the welfare, rights-based and ethic of care approaches, although this reads rather like a textbook overview, and belies the complexity and subtlety of some of the analyses offered in the succeeding chapters.
The chapters that directly address rights do so on different levels. Some refer specifically to the Human Rights Act 1998 and the rights guaranteed in the ECHR, such as Felicity Kaganas's chapter tracing the minimal practical impact of the Human Rights Act in the area of child protection, and Christine Piper's chapter on the successes and limitations of rights-based claims in relation to the juvenile justice system in the UK. Shazia Choudhry's chapter on human rights and domestic violence also falls within this category, although in a much less critical vein, she simply notes state obligations to protect women from violence under Article 3 of the ECHR and discusses mandatory arrest and prosecution policies as a means of fulfilling these obligations. Despite claiming that her discussion will be conducted from ‘the’ feminist perspective, she does acknowledge that there are feminist arguments on both sides of this debate. She comes down in favour of mandatory policies, although having helpfully distinguished between different types of mandatoriness (‘hard’ and ‘soft’), she does not make clear exactly which policies it is that she favours.
Other chapters deal with broader rights discourse rather than positive rights. For example, Alison Diduck looks at the influence of human rights culture and values on family law, specifically the infusion of the concepts of equality and non-discrimination into recent family property jurisprudence. Lisa Glennon similarly focuses on the values of equality and autonomy in the advent of civil partnerships, as well as the property regimes applied and proposed to be applied to married couples, civil partners and cohabiting couples who separate, while Jonathan Herring also charts the rise of the value of individual autonomy.
Several of the chapters explicitly compare a rights-based approach to an ethic of care approach and, perhaps predictably, prefer the latter. In her chapter, Julie Wallbank argues that the fathers' rights movement has managed to achieve a highly effective discursive ‘fusion of rights and responsibilities’ in relation to the issue of contact, which combines arguments for fathers' rights to contact with arguments for fathers' desire to be responsible parents in the interests of their children. Against the appeal of this discourse, Wallbank contends that the law should recognise and reflect the actual caring responsibilities that each parent assumed during the relationship, an approach that would appropriately value actual caring work rather than aspirational claims for the future. Lisa Glennon criticises the principle of equal sharing in marital property division on the basis that it treats all marriages as the same, advocating instead an ethic of care approach to property division on separation for all relationships involving children, which again would recognise the value of ongoing familial care work. This argument may seem curious, as in practice the equal sharing principle is applied only in big money cases, while in regular cases the needs of children and their primary carer are the most prominent considerations in the division of property, as Emma Hitchings's recent empirical study has demonstrated (Reference Hitchings2010). But Glennon's argument extends beyond this, suggesting caregiver support payments somewhat along the lines of ‘wages for housework’, although this analogy isn't mentioned.
Perhaps the best example of the pro-ethic of care position is Jo Bridgeman's chapter on children with exceptional needs. Here, Bridgeman sets out welfare-based, rights-based and ethic of care approaches and clearly shows that only the latter approach enables us to see the full picture of the relationships, dependencies and gender differences involved. Jonathan Herring, on the other hand – is his gender significant? – eschews the ethic of care approach in favour of a conceptual shift from individual autonomy to relational autonomy. This is also, of course, a feminist argument (see e.g. Nedelsky, Reference Nedelsky1989; Mackenzie and Stoljar, Reference Mackenzie and Stoljar2000), but it is one with which men seem to feel more comfortable (see e.g. Leckey, Reference Leckey2008).
Apart from Wallbank's, the chapter that focuses most clearly on responsibilities (rather than rights) is Brid Featherstone's, which examines New Labour social policy on families with its emphasis on parental responsibilities. Richard Collier deals with the fathers' rights movement, but not with its rights-based claims as such. Rather, he is concerned to locate the rise of the movement within broader, complex shifts in economies and personal life, including men's emotional and psychological responses to separation. Caroline Jones's chapter on Assisted Reproductive Technologies discusses the various ways in which the law has responded to the ‘knowledge’ and ‘privacy’ concerns of donor-conceived individuals and gamete donors respectively, but the discussion focuses on the interests of these groups (and gender differences within them) rather than rights discourse or rights claims per se.
Because the essays deal with different substantive issues, there is not a lot of cross-referencing between them. Wallbank in her chapter refers to and engages with Collier's chapter to some extent, but the scope for this kind of dialogue is limited. More of a connection between the essays is gained by the fact that many of them make common arguments and cite the same authors and texts in support of those arguments, particularly in relation to ethic of care arguments and feminist critiques of rights.
One disappointing feature of the book is that it has not been well copy-edited or proof-read. For example, the footnotes go haywire (numbers and text fail to correspond) towards the end of Chapter 1, and there are, notably, too many grammatical errors and sentence fragments. Regrettably, this tendency is most prominent in the individual and joint chapters by the three editors. Although perhaps only dinosaurs like me find this distracting, there are still a few of us left stomping the earth and bemoaning the lapse of standards while we await extinction.
On the other hand, an unusual and welcome feature of the collection is the final chapter, ‘Concluding thoughts’, by Helen Rhoades. It is rare for edited collections to include any kind of conclusion, and with good reason. The editors have done enough. They have brought together the essays, pulled out the themes in the introduction, and are heartily glad to send off the manuscript to the publisher without further ado. Here, however, Rhoades provides a brief reflection on and response to the essays individually and collectively from an Australian perspective – one in which rights discourse to some extent, and certainly positive rights, remain alien features of the family law landscape. This twist in the tail is a nice touch. Of course Rhoades's summation is not the only one available, but in noting this the reader also realises that the collection adds up to more than the sum of its parts. As a whole, this collection significantly advances academic debates about the role, value and gender implications of rights and rights discourse in family law, across a broad field and in thought-provoking ways.
