Antinous is very much en vogue. First, there was the 2006 exhibition at Leeds' Henry Moore Institute (‘Antinous: The Face of the Antique’). Then the British Museum organized its own blockbuster show in 2008, centred around the emperor who made him famous (or rather the other way round?). If Antinous has become a veritable twenty-first-century pin-up — not to mention Gay Pride icon — previous centuries were rather more ambivalent. True, the sheer mass of Antinous portraits, coins and gems secured his place in the annals of la storia antica. But many were embarrassed by Antinous' (se)x-factor: as Caroline Vout recently reminded us, Edward Gibbon wrote of his shame before such portraits, deemed ‘still [to] dishonour the memory of Hadrian’.
What makes speculation all the more frustrating (and alluring) is that we know so little of the ‘facts’. Born in Bithynia between a.d. 110 and 112, Antinous is said to have accompanied Hadrian on his travels to Egypt, and to have drowned there in a.d. 130 (i.e. at the tender age of around twenty). The rest is essentially speculation — whether among ancient writers such as Cassius Dio and the Scriptores Historiae Augustae, or among more contemporary story-tellers like Marguerite Yourcenar (in her own blockbusting Mémoires d'Hadrien of 1951).
The book under review is the most recent attempt to reconstruct the history. In fact, it is Mambella's latest contribution within a fifteen-year-long obsession (11): the author published his Antinoo: L'ultimo mito dell'antichità nella storia e nell'arte in 1995, and a subsequent novel in 1999 (Le memorie di Antinoo: la rivelazione di un antico mistero). There is a good deal of ‘romanzo’ in this book too. We begin with a twenty-four-stanza poem composed for the occasion (‘Il tempe uccide / ciò che l'uomo va cercando …’, 6), and subsequent sections prove no less self-indulgent. Despite all best efforts, this is really not a book for scholars: footnotes are scant and thin (with many crippling mistakes and absences); sources are cited in translation (the few places where Greek is quoted, the presentation is garbled, e.g. 46); the layout is bizarre (with the flow of text suddenly interrupted by extended footnotes on e.g. 13–16, 267–73); the ‘bibliografia fondamentale’ (370–4) is still waiting to be copy-edited. Still, the book has to be taken on its merits. Two things are particularly worthy: first, the range of material surveyed; and second, the copious plates (including many of the author's own photographs), stunningly reproduced in colour.
M.'s essential argument is the same as Winckelmann's some two and a half centuries ago: the second-century ‘discovery’ of Antinous prompts or coincides with a final flowering of all things Greek and beautiful (‘Le statue di Antinoo sono l'ultima grande creazione ideale di una figura umana greca, dal momento che sono sopratutto le statue degli dei del periodo classico ad essere utilizzate’, 366). More romantically-inclined readers will shed a tear: Antinous possessed ‘una bellezza indescrivibile’, and ‘Adriano amò appassionatamente Antìnoo, non meno per le sue doti di carattere che per la sua straordinaria bellezza’ (11).
The structure of the book is — to put it kindly — haphazard. M. deals sporadically with the literary sources (13–30), and then turns to a long digression on ‘l’eros come impulso vitale e l'omofilia' (31–70) — a layman's introduction to ‘l'omosessualità e la bisessualità nell'antichità greco-romana’ (it is here, I suspect, that the closet market lies). The catalogue of material culture (unevenly scattered over two hundred pages: 71–261) proves better. M. surveys the ‘archaeology’ of Antinopolis, the Pincio obelisk, the so-called Antinoeion at Tivoli, and a host of coins, gems and statues. The likes of Hugo Meyer need not worry about their catalogues being usurped: it is unfortunate, for example, that M. does not seem familiar even with Grimm, Kessler and Meyer's 1994 edition of the obelisk reliefs. Still, the wonderful photographic album assembled on 149–261 makes for a helpful resource for anyone seeking a sculptural inventory (even though, it should be said, some of the identifications are dubious at best, and other statues are missing). The final third of the book is wholly less successful, including discussions of ‘Margherite [sic] Yourcenar’, Antinous' rôle in the Renaissance, and a bewildering essay on ‘il bello ideale come bello corporo’ (315–37; I pass over M.'s concluding prescriptions on ‘come si debba correttamente interpretare l'arte classica e il classicismo in generale’, 361–65).
All in all, a strange book. But also strangely compelling. To be sure, M. goes against the grain of all recent trends in contemporary Roman art history (‘Il problema dell'arte rappresentante Antinoo va visto come ricerca di un unico tipo ideale, di un valore assoluto, in contrasto con la raffigurazione ritrattistica tipicamente romana’, 367): there are also some frankly odd interpretations of monuments like the Arch of Constantine (88–93), and Antinous turns up in the most unlikely (viz. incredible) of places (146–7, 263–79). Philologists will have cause for complaint too, as in the interpretation of a funerary epigram on Antinous, ascribed to Hadrian in the Historia Augusta (and unquestioningly accepted, of course: ‘Animula vagula blandula non è tanto l'inizio di una poesiola semplice, graziosa o addirittura leziosa, ma è piuttosto una stanca considerazione della fragilità delle cose umane’, 30). This all makes for a rather naïve intervention ‘nella storia e nell'arte’ of Antinous. And yet the passion with which the book is written proves almost contagious. I didn't find myself reaching for my hanky. But I was led to rethink this most enigmatic of ancient actors.
