Once the civil wars and repression that plagued the region had ended, Central America saw the inception of far-reaching socio-economic and political changes. Notwithstanding the development of electoral democracies, however, gargantuan challenges remain. Today the isthmus is chiefly known, both domestically and abroad, for its multiple security problems. For the past two decades social violence has been affecting citizens across the social strata, albeit mostly the middle and working classes. Community safety, notably in the countries of the Northern Triangle, is chiefly impaired by street gangs that were imported through US-sponsored deportations, grew in size and complexity due to long-standing policy neglect, and are now associated particularly with homicides and extortions.
Crime and violence, and the democratic disenchantment they have caused, also feature in Central America in the New Millennium. Editors Jennifer Burrell and Ellen Moodie wonder, however, if the frequent emphasis on security masks a ‘new politics of poverty’ (p. 20) that is a core component in the creation of neoliberal states. The collection of 16 chapters, all written by anthropologists, takes as its starting point the renewed marginalisation that the sub-region experienced with the return of formal peace. Arguing that this fading from the geopolitical arena is not fortuitous but is rather the goal of capitalist processes that link wealthy and deprived populations across the world, the contributors propose to ‘see’ these global processes ethnographically. Accordingly, the scholars offer in-depth descriptions of everyday life and practices in order to shed light on the meanings that democracy, security, multiculturalism and neoliberalism have for individuals and communities throughout the isthmus.
Ellen Moodie's chapter on crime narratives circulating in El Salvador exemplifies the ongoing and vibrant struggle for democracy. This concept, the author signals, was once associated with human freedom and social equality, but has come to denote elections and free-market economics. Her analysis of everyday conversations shows how citizens have become dissatisfied with neoliberal democratisation and the state's failure to meet widespread expectations of the rule of law, responsive institutions, a sense of community, and development. The ‘politics of hope’ (p. 107), Moodie contends, remains alive as people continue to struggle for a better future, a struggle that goes beyond a simple change of government. This is illustrated by the Indignados-SV movement formed in June 2011 by young Salvadoreans who initially – and successfully – protested Decree 743. The latter had been adopted to require the Constitutional Chamber to vote unanimously on resolutions of unconstitutionality and to prevent rulings that might have overturned the Amnesty Law and a series of neoliberal measures. The Indignados-SV initiative, to this day small and incipient, suggested that what its members wanted above all was a democracy that was responsive to societal demands and not manipulated by political parties. Although in leftist quarters they were viewed with some scepticism given their middle- and upper-class backgrounds, Moodie's research demonstrates that many people have similar aspirations and that the struggle for an alternative democracy can be a shared one.
The economic policies pursued by Central American administrations deepened existing levels of exclusion, effectively feeding large-scale migration and criminal involvement. The volume contains numerous stories that unmask new forms of ‘neoliberal compassion’ (p. 19) and trace communities' resistance – sometimes effective, sometimes not – to poverty alleviation projects that paradoxically may achieve the opposite. An unsettling type of development is occurring in Nicaragua where tourism has emerged as one of the leading industries. Notwithstanding the revolutionary government's reduction of social and gender inequalities, since Ortega's return to power sex tourism and romance tourism (longer-term involvement in return for gifts, including marriage) have flourished under the complicit eye of the revenue-strapped state. Florence Babb's chapter reveals how falling unemployment and growing wealth disparities have increasingly made girls and women turn to sex work, since they consider it better remunerated than the informal work that is generally available to working-class females. Although non-governmental organisations seek to provide them with job alternatives, the question remains whether Nicaragua can restore earlier forms of gender-inclusive development so that women need not perform sexual services as a survival strategy.
Resistance to neoliberal policies is a theme that also comes to the fore in the experiences of undocumented Central American migrants in the United States. Focusing on the urban and demographic transformation of Williamsburg, Virginia, Jennifer Bickham Mendez chronicles patterns of economic inclusion and socio-political exclusion of migrants. Applying a transnational framework in order to analyse how local development in the United States is sustained by economically displaced Latino labourers, the author divulges how Williamsburg's suburban nature and racial-ethnic boundaries inhibit their integration into the community. Women immigrants, in particular, are affected by the social isolation deriving from the town's spatial organisation and limited availability of public transportation, the criminalisation of migrants and local immigration enforcement, and gender inequalities at home and at work. The significance of Bickham Mendez's account lies in the survival strategies that immigrant mothers adopt as a way of challenging their marginalisation. For example, participation in social programmes and the creation of car pools serve not only to mobilise much-needed resources, but also to establish valuable social networks. In short, migration, which might be interpreted as individuals' escape from the economic and social plight afflicting the isthmus, is shown to be a bid of defiance against neoliberal democracy.
Overall, Central America in the New Millennium is a superbly written, painstakingly researched volume that offers fascinating insights into the lives of ordinary citizens whose voices are often crowded out by elites. Taken together, the chapters show how far these countries have come, but also how far they still have to go before people's time-honoured dreams of democracy and social justice will come true. Politically complex and socially diverse, the isthmus evidently continues to be exceedingly relevant for understanding democracy and human rights in Latin America. The struggles that are daily being waged to achieve these ideals may rarely make it into the headlines, but they inspire hope that someday Central America may be able to offer to its populations what it denies current generations: true peace and greater prosperity for everyone. This collection of essays will appeal to those who study the sub-region as well as democracy more generally. Some of the questions that the book leaves unanswered, and that future research will need to address, relate to the challenges of overcoming political polarisation, creating public policies in the fields that currently lack them, finding sustainable alternatives to neoliberal economic policies, and making the struggle for democracy more consistent and less sporadic.
